Jump directly to the Content

Kingdom Misused

An interview with Scot McKnight, and more ...

Have modern Christians forgotten what the Bible really means by "kingdom"? Theologian Scot McKnight thinks so, developing the idea in his latest book, Kingdom Conspiracy (Brazos, 2014). Paul J. Pastor interviewed McKnight to find out more.

You argue that "kingdom" is the term most misused by Christians today. In short, how do we misuse it?

We all assume we know what it means. Like the word "gospel," which I examined in King Jesus Gospel, which we constantly assume means "how to get saved" or the "message that can be shaped into the plan of salvation." But this is not how "gospel" was used in the New Testament. So it is with the word "kingdom," which has become nearly synonymous with two different standard uses.

For some "kingdom" means acting in the public sector for the common good in order to create a world with better conditions. For others it has come to mean little more than salvation, or what I often call "redemptive moments." If we care to shape our theology and our use of terms like "kingdom" on the basis of what the Bible says, then those two definitions are gross reductions of what the Bible says.

Yes, of course, kingdom includes ethics (though they are not to be secularized as progressives sometimes do) and it brings redemption (as many Christians are prone to say), but those are only two aspects of a much fuller story about kingdom in the Bible. Until we get each of the elements into play we are not looking at what the Bible is saying.
— Read the full interview at www.christianitytoday.com/le/2014/september-online-only/redefining-kingdom.html

A Thin Worship Sandwich

"… As for reciting creeds, well, no: evangelicals normally do not recite creeds in our services. Evangelicals that are not part of liturgical traditions—and that's most of us—instead tend to worship in 'hymn sandwich' services: lots of singing, with maybe a greeting and some announcements in the interstices, then a longish sermon, then more singing—with perhaps a collection and a closing prayer … no call to worship, no confession and absolution of sin, no series of Scripture readings (OT, Gospel, Epistles), no congregational prayers, no "Our Father," no Creed … and so on. It's pretty bad—and it's actually regressing, I think. When Robert Webber and others chided and educated evangelicals about liturgy in the 1970s and 1980s, some responded by adding (back) elements to their services, but nowadays the trend-setting churches seem to have fallen back into two halves—singing and preaching—which, among other bad consequences, has put a very heavy burden on worship leaders and preachers to perform at a high standard, since that's pretty much all there is to the service."
—John Stackhouse, from "American 'Evangelicals' and Heresy"

Message and Medium

"I want to attend a conference one day about being small, authentic, and missional at a church that is small, authentic, and missional. I want to read a book about overcoming the success syndrome written by a pastor who, in the eyes of the world, looks like a failure. I want to hear from the pastor whose story didn't have a happy ending, and yet who still clings to the fact that Jesus is enough."
- Darryl Dash, "Saying True Things in a True Way."

True for churches too?

"One of the true tests of a good college is how they treat their workers, and certainly a decent indicator of that is how the lowest paid workers fare in contrast to the highest paid administrators. A good question of any college president is if he or she would be comfortable exchanging salaries for a year with the janitor. After all, both are just as valuable in the eyes of God."
- Shane Claiborne, "Blessed Be the Housekeeping Staff," The Huffington Post.

2014 and the Tomb of the World

"It's difficult to prove that 2014 has been worse than other years, but it sure feels that way… . Yet at just such times, we might recall why we choose, sometimes joyfully, to let ourselves feel the weight of the world's sufferings … . When Jesus stood at the grave of Lazarus, he wept (John 11:35). Today, we can stand with Jesus as we behold the tomb that is the world. To be like Christ at such times means to weep. We do not weep without hope, for we know that Jesus, as he did with Lazarus, will bring new life. Yet part of growing into the full stature of Christ is to face suffering and learn how to weep."
- Mark Galli, "The Weight of Ferguson, ISIS, and Boko Haram," Christianity Today

Three Myths About PTSD

"PTSD" (Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder) is a term thrown around with increasing frequency in both clinical and informal settings. But misconceptions abound, which the BBC debunks here. Pastors would do well to heed this when talking about clinically-diagnosed PTSD or general situations of trauma, stress, and healing.

Myth 1: Everyone is prone to develop PTSD after trauma.
"One common assumption is that everyone is prone to developing post-traumatic stress disorder, or PTSD, and in the 1990s this led to attempts to get people to participate in a single counseling session or psychological debriefing. This approach has not been shown to be effective. When you look at the evidence, it is not true that most people develop PTSD… . Immediately after a traumatic event, people understandably feel shocked, anxious and afraid. Events loom large in their minds, and they might find themselves plagued for some days or weeks by flashbacks, nightmares and a constant anxiety that they are not safe. None of this is pleasant, but these are all very normal reactions."

Myth 2: Only people who are weak suffer from PTSD.
"Why, even after the most horrendous experiences, some people develop PTSD and others don't, is still a mystery. The psychiatrists' Bible, DSM, until recently included a person's responses to the initial event. Intense fear, helplessness or horror were thought to result in more PTSD, but those indicators have been removed from the newest version of the manual, because it's been found that they don't predict who will and won't suffer."

Myth 3: Kids don't experience PTSD.
s"It is also a myth that when children go through something traumatic, they just bounce back. They too can suffer from PTSD. Not surprisingly exposure to violence makes a difference, but it's still hard to guess who will be affected, when even the number of traumatic events they've experienced doesn't predict whether they will develop PTSD or not." One key takeaway for pastors: supportive community for those who have experienced trauma seems to play an important role in helping those at risk for developing PTSD.
—From the BBC's Claudia Hammond: PTSD: Do most people get it after terrifying incidents?

Support Our Work

Subscribe to CT for less than $4.25/month

Homepage Subscription Panel

Read These Next

A Church-Membership Sabbatical
A Church-Membership Sabbatical
The insights we gleaned from a year's worth of church visits.
From the Magazine
Parents Set the Pace for Their Adult Children’s Religious Life
Parents Set the Pace for Their Adult Children’s Religious Life
“Handing Down the Faith” shows a vast majority of Americans don’t choose their religious beliefs. They inherit them.
Editor's Pick
9 in 10 Evangelicals Don’t Think Sermons Are Too Long
9 in 10 Evangelicals Don’t Think Sermons Are Too Long
Even with recent divides in congregations, survey finds high levels of satisfaction among churchgoers.