Related articles and links |  1 of 2

In 1979, Southern Baptist Convention conservatives elected the first in a still-unbroken string of presidents who resolved to appoint only biblical inerrantists to the governing boards of SBC agencies.

But even as conservatives were winning the "battle for the Bible," another theologically oriented movement began emerging, largely from within conservative ranks: a resurgence of Calvinistic doctrine, especially among a new generation of the SBC's institutional leadership.

Currently, two of the denomination's six seminary presidents are proponents of Reformed theology: R. Albert Mohler, Jr., of Southern Baptist Theological Seminary in Louisville, Kentucky, and Mark T. Coppenger of Midwestern Baptist Theological Seminary in Kansas City, Missouri.

By some accounts, the movement began in 1982 with the formation of the Southern Baptist Founders Conference (SBFC). The SBFC—so named because many early SBC leaders were Calvinistic in doctrine—has become a loose-knit network of pastors and other church leaders who hold annual meetings to hear speakers promote "the doctrines of grace."

EARLY TRADITION: During the first 50 years following the SBC's founding in 1845, the denomination elected presidents who mostly adhered to the "five points of Calvinism":

—Total depravity: People are spiritually dead and therefore unable to respond to God's offer of salvation unless he first regenerates them.

—Unconditional election: God chose some to be saved because he loved them, not because of any merit on their part.

—Limited atonement: Christ died only for the sins of the elect, not for everyone's sins.

—Irresistible grace: All whom God regenerates will inevitably choose to repent and exercise faith.

—Perseverance of the saints: God will preserve in salvation and eternal life those he saves.

Based on the theology of John Calvin (1509-64), the five points were developed in the early seventeenth century by the Synod of Dort in Holland in opposition to key teachings of Jacob Arminius and his followers.

Though early Southern Baptists believed the five points, they rejected other traditional Calvinist ideas, such as infant baptism, hierarchical polity, and state religion. Instead, they advocated believer's baptism, congregational autonomy, and separation of church and state.

"Fifteen years ago, critics were accusing us of being 'deep-water Presbyterians' and were claiming that Southern Baptists have never been Calvinists," says Tom Ascol, editor of the SBFC's quarterly publication, The Founders Journal. "Hardly anyone is making such unfounded accusations today."

Ascol, who is pastor of Grace Baptist Church in Cape Coral, Florida, credits the distribution of more than 100,000 books by the SBFC as instrumental in helping contemporary Southern Baptists become more aware of their roots.

Bill J. Leonard, dean of the Wake Forest University Divinity School and a church historian, acknowledges that early SBC leaders had Calvinistic beliefs but says he doubts Reformed doctrine can make a widespread comeback any time soon.

"At least in this generation, I don't think you can convince a majority of Southern Baptists that Jesus died only for an elect chosen from the foundation of the world," Leonard says.

But Ascol says, "Of those who believe that church life and ministry ought to be theologically driven, a majority would consider themselves Calvinistic."

The revival of Reformed theology is growing among younger pastors and ministers in training, Ascol observes. "This is largely a young church leader movement," he says. "Boomers and busters are willing to put aside preconceived notions. More and more seminary and college students are coming to see that the doctrines are nothing more than an accurate summary of the biblical teaching of salvation."

next page... |  1 of 2

share this page

October 6 1997, Vol. 41, No. 11