Guest / Limited Access /

We live in a peculiar world where we can knowingly assert that our consumption establishes our identity, and everyone smiles, nods, and moves along as though nothing terribly interesting has transpired.

As Brett McCracken has illustrated, hipster evangelicals are expanding their consumption beyond the cloister to the coffee shops, and out of the mainline cinemas into hallowed movie houses where indie films play.

This expansion of cultural consumption is a welcome development. St. Paul exhorts us to set our minds on whatever is true, good, and beautiful, and he does not cordon off such attributes to institutions or para-church ministries. As Richard Mouw argued in his lectures on common grace, because we await the final consummation of all things, we can find goodness out in the world even while we are simultaneously dismayed at the brokenness of the church.

Given this perpetually messy relationship between church and world, it's not surprising that consumerism would become our primary identity-shaping logic. In fact, there is a serious question about how it is possible to escape consumerism other than by withdrawing from the world in the way fundamentalists do, a route that hipster evangelicals eschew. Consumerist logic runs deeply, and may not be extricated as easily as it seems.

Even if we could avoid consumerism, most of mainstream evangelicalism has not. Its long tentacles have reached into nearly every area of the evangelical culture, stunting our ability to imagine identity-shaping beliefs or practices that are non-consumptive. There is some merit to Jamie Smith's critique in Desiring the Kingdom that evangelical churches have too often bowed the knee to entertainment-driven forms of worship designed to meet felt needs.

As Anna Littauer Carrington argues, many hipster evangelicals are moving beyond consumption to "interaction" and forming communities around the elements of culture that are being consumed and produced, an encouraging sign that evangelicals are expanding their horizons. However, when the emphasis falls on the culture and our relationship to it, relationships can become a byproduct of our cultural making, inevitably leading to the sort of self-selecting communities that we are working to escape.

Traditional evangelicals and their descendants tend to divide on differing points of emphasis. While our parents' generation was preoccupied with their focus on the family, my peers have replaced  that focus with a near obsession on objects and structures of culture and how we can engage with and create them. There are some sociological reasons for the transition: Even though most younger evangelicals haven't experienced the much-discussed dissolution of their own families, we have been witnesses to the cultural decline of family life, a decline that has affected us more subtly than we know. And as younger evangelicals have begun to delay marriage and have continued to uproot themselves geographically from their local communities, it has become easier to emphasize "culture" as a way to find our identity, especially when culture is narrowed to the consumption and creation of artifacts.

Yet Andy Crouch will have none of it. As he points out in Culture Making, "Family is culture at its smallest—and its most powerful." Christian Smith's Soul Searching, an exposition of the religious lives of emerging adults, points out that parental religious life is one of the most important factors for determining the religious affiliations of emerging adults. Parental influence trumps peer—and cultural—influence.

Support our work. Subscribe to CT and get one year free.
Read These NextSee Our Latest
Current IssueHow to Regain Cultural Capital
Subscriber Access Only
How to Regain Cultural Capital
The persecuted church shows the way.
RecommendedThe Seven Levels of Lying
Subscriber Access Only The Seven Levels of Lying
We lie more than we think. And that's part of the problem.
TrendingWhy Max Lucado Broke His Political Silence for Trump
Why Max Lucado Broke His Political Silence for Trump
In the face of a candidate’s antics, ‘America’s Pastor’ speaks out.
Editor's PickI Found the Gospel in Communist Romania
I Found the Gospel in Communist Romania
And then I shared it with the man the government sent to kill me.
View this article in Reader Mode
Christianity Today
Culturally Focusing on the Family