Jump directly to the content

Feature

The Yes and No of Healing

What are we to make of people who experience inner healing and then revert to their old ways?

The Yes and No of Healing

A few years ago, as I scanned the congregation before the service, I again saw David and his wife, sitting in the back. He now attends regularly, but that had not always been the case. He had avoided church for years—until his wife became seriously ill and was suddenly healed when a group of us prayed with her. Though he had witnessed that miracle, David (no real names are used) avoided asking for prayer for himself, though at times he liked me to pray for him and his wife as they received Holy Communion together. This Sunday he asked for prayer as he came forward for Communion, explaining, "My father died."

At the end of the service, I saw him sitting alone, hunched over in the back of the church. I sat down next to him. David talked about how his father had not been an affectionate man; he rarely let David know that he loved him. The wounds of rejection and the need for fatherly affirmation were deep. As we prayed about that deep hurt, the love of the Father came over him. In the middle of our conversation, tears began welling up in his eyes as he heard deep within himself the Father's affirmation: "You are my child."

Through the tears he said, "I have never experienced anything like this before." At that moment, the lie that he had believed, "I am not loveable," was broken by the truth of God penetrating his heart. That inner healing opened him up to share with me that he and his wife were struggling in their marriage. Over the ensuing weeks, he came to me regularly for healing prayer, became more open with his wife, and their relationship began to improve.

Once the marital crisis passed, David stopped coming for healing prayer because he thought everything was fine. Then he had an affair. He came rushing back for healing prayer. Again God provided healing. He broke off the adulterous affair, and after a few marital counseling sessions that included inner healing prayer, the marriage was on the mend.

One day he answered a phone call from his former mistress, and soon he was right back in the affair. This cycle repeated several times until his wife had the papers drawn up for divorce. His chances were all used up as far as she was concerned.

Today, David still attends church, sitting by himself in a pew in the back of the church, always with his head hanging down. I feel both frustration with him and compassion for him.

Healing is at the very heart of God. "I am the lord, who heals you" (Ex. 15:26). The healing theme runs throughout the metanarrative of the Bible: Creation to Fall to redemption to consummation. Every stage involves healing, restoration, reconciliation, and transformation of God's people in spirit, soul (mind, will, emotion), and body through Jesus Christ by the power of the Holy Spirit.

Yet I have found in my ministry of healing that David's experience is not isolated. It raises important questions about how that healing manifests itself between redemption and consummation. Was David's original healing genuine? Was he perhaps "unhealed"?

How do we understand this, especially those of us who believe in and practice healing?

The Powerful No

Leanne Payne is well known in many Christian circles for her ministry of inner soul healing. In her book The Healing Presence: Curing the Soul Through Union with Christ, she says that healing is blocked by, among other things, lack of self-acceptance for who we really are. That is, we are created in the image of God but find it hard to believe. Where does this lack of self-acceptance come from?


Related Topics:
None
From Issue:
October 2012, Vol. 56, No. 9, Pg 46, "The Yes and No of Healing "
More from Christianity Today

La complejidad hispana: Todo cambió en el 2012

¿Hacia dónde vamos?—Una palabra para los creyentes hispanos sobre forjar un futuro.
Jesus' Elevator Speech

Jesus' Elevator Speech

Or was it his inaugural address? There's a difference.

The Latest in Movie News, May 20, 2013

Box office news, Benedict Cumberbatch, Cannes, and AFI honors Mel Brooks.
Divine Rehab

Divine Rehab

Whatever your addiction, God's grace is the only hope for a way out.
Get Instant Access
Christianity Today Magazine
Subscribe now for a year (10 issues) at $24.95 for print, iPad, and instant web access.

International Orders

Comments

Displaying 1–3 of 5 comments

KEVIN ANDERSON

November 02, 2012  9:08pm

I can't go with Marva Dawn's odd reading of the 2 Cor 12 passage. There doesn't seem to be any warrant for saying the "my power" in verse 9 is referring to something possessed by Paul. Seems like the power is possessed by God.

Report Abuse

Martin Tampier

November 02, 2012  7:33pm

The article seems to lack a good dose of common sense. Why would someone who committed adultery need healing? It's repentance that is required here, not healing. So it would not surprise me that the approach taken here failed utterly and ended in chaos and despair. Regarding the other lady, why don't we instead look to the Bible and move away from the self-centered approach suggested by the 'inner healing' ministries? Instead of focusing on Himself, Jesus prayed for those who did Him wrong. And He exhorted us to do the same. So what could have brought 'healing' in this instance appears to be a) forgiveness and concern for those who do us wrong (i.e., pray for the one who may have hurt you instead of avoiding him) and b) a good dose of self-evaluation to find out if the culprit may be herself and not the others. Probably not when her own family abandoned her but in other instances, who knows. So forgiving and judging ourselves while being altruistic seems a better cure to me than this.

Report Abuse

Stephen Smythe

October 30, 2012  10:06am

If such occurs then the source of the supposed "inner healing" must be questioned. Paul warns us that even Satan can appear as an "angel of light" and the apostle John warns us to "test the spirits". The Devil is always prowling to steal our souls and the best way to know if the spiritual experience is from God or Satan is whether that person subsequently lives his life in accordance with the commandments of Christ. Yes, a saved Christian can, as we all do, sin and for that, forgiveness of that sin (unless against the Holy Spirit) is available to the truly repentant. That is different however from a person who not merely occasionally falls but reverts back to his original condition; which as Christ warns us, will be worse than the first. Whether that person was originally saved and then forfeited his faith or was never saved is a continuing debate among Christians. For me, the result is all that matters. Eternal separation from the love of God and residence in the lake of fire.

Report Abuse
See All 5 Comments
You must be a Christianity Today subscriber to post comments
(on articles open to the public, you must at least register for a free account).
Login
or
Subscribe
or
Register

Don't Miss

Forgiving Iran

Forgiving Iran

Long before I knew the true God, he helped me release my hatred.
Guilt Gone Wild

Guilt Gone Wild

The right kind of guilt can be healthy. But false guilt depletes your soul and ministry.

Training for "One Pitch" Preachers

Training for "One Pitch" Preachers

If you're stuck in a rut, this is how to mix things up.

more | current issue

Facebook

CT eBooks & Bible Studies


Shopping