Guest / Limited Access /
Reviews

/

When Being Pro-Life Didn't Make You a Republican
Image: Joey Guidone
Defenders of the Unborn: The Pro-Life Movement before Roe v. Wade
Our Rating
4 Stars - Excellent
Book Title
Defenders of the Unborn: The Pro-Life Movement before Roe v. Wade
Author
Publisher
Oxford University Press
Release Date
January 7, 2016
Pages
400
Price
$25.24
Buy Defenders of the Unborn: The Pro-Life Movement before Roe v. Wade from Amazon

Historians have a favorite saying: “The past is like a foreign country.” When we travel there, we meet people who think and act very differently. We return home with a new perspective, recognizing how much we take for granted, how much is far from inevitable.

For a powerful illustration of this truth, look no further than Daniel K. Williams’s masterful new book, Defenders of the Unborn: The Pro-Life Movement before Roe v. Wade (Oxford University Press). When readers turn the final page, they may feel like they have visited not just a different country, but a different universe.

The Twilight Zone

When the Supreme Court decided Roe v. Wade in 1973, only one in six of today’s Americans were adults. The rest of us have grown up in a later age. In the world we know, abortion has always been a constitutionally protected right. It has always pitted Republicans against Democrats, conservatives against liberals, Christians against secularists.

But the world has not always been this way.

Consider the following features of the period that Williams focuses on, roughly the four decades prior to Roe v. Wade. For most of these years:

  • Evangelicals mostly watched from the sidelines as Catholics stood in defense of the unborn.
  • Women rarely played visible roles on either side of the debate. Abortion was a matter of public health or social justice, not a question of sexual equality.
  • Pro-lifers were often political liberals; political conservatives thought abortion laws were too strict.
  • Republicans were slightly more likely than Democrats to favor total legalization of abortion in the first trimester of pregnancy. While Ronald Reagan was signing an abortion liberalization law in California, Ted Kennedy was endorsing the “right to life” in Massachusetts.

Have we entered The Twilight Zone?

More important, Defenders of the Unborn demonstrates that by 1970, a vibrant, effective pro-life movement had taken off in the United States. Scholars have often portrayed the pro-life movement as if it began in 1973, when Roe v. Wade awakened conservatives to feminism, government activism, and sexual permissiveness. The book makes a compelling case that the movement “originated not as a conservative backlash against individual rights, but as a defense of human rights for the unborn.”

Williams begins his narrative with the Great Depression. It was a time when state laws almost uniformly prohibited abortion. But the number of illegal abortions soared in this era of unprecedented poverty. So did the number of women who died from botched back-alley procedures.

In this context, a few doctors began calling for loosening abortion restrictions as a way to protect women’s lives. Dissenting Catholic priests and physicians appealed to traditional church teaching about sexual morality. But they also framed the issue as a matter of social justice, and called for increased government aid to the poor as essential to reducing abortion.

From Issue:
Browse All Book Reviews By:
Read These NextSee Our Latest
Also in this Issue
Subscriber Access Only Wilson's Bookmarks
From John Wilson, editor of 'Books and Culture'.
RecommendedShould Christians Vote for the Lesser of Two Evils?
Should Christians Vote for the Lesser of Two Evils?
Even at the ballot box, morality is not relative.
TrendingNicole Cliffe: How God Messed Up My Happy Atheist Life
Nicole Cliffe: How God Messed Up My Happy Atheist Life
I had no untapped, unanswered yearnings. All was well in the state of Denmark. And then it wasn’t.
Editor's PickLetters with the Mosque Next Door
Letters with the Mosque Next Door
How a budding friendship between a pastor and an imam brought a community together.
View this article in Reader Mode
Christianity Today
When Being Pro-Life Didn't Make You a Republican