Reviews

|

Culture of Death: The Age of “Do Harm” Medicine
Our Rating
2½ Stars - Fair
Book Title
Culture of Death: The Age of “Do Harm” Medicine
Author
Publisher
Encounter Books
Release Date
May 17, 2016
Pages
360
Price
$11.64
Buy Culture of Death: The Age of “Do Harm” Medicine from Amazon

My country’s parliament recently passed the first national assisted-suicide legislation in our history. Prompted by the Supreme Court of Canada’s unanimous decision last year to strike down the previous law as unconstitutionally restricting individual rights to life, liberty, and security, Parliament is now arguing over how widely or narrowly to involve Canadian citizens—both patients and health care providers—in assisted suicide.

In Culture of Death, first published in 2000, American lawyer and activist Wesley J. Smith warned that this debate was upon us. A new, updated revision of the book sharpens this warning, drawing on a wide range of cases in Belgium, the Netherlands, Canada, and the bellwether states of Oregon and Washington.

Smith is not an elegant writer—his discussion of truly awful subjects is sometimes interrupted by jarringly flip remarks: “Nobody ever said Terri [Schiavo] would one day get out of bed and tap dance.” And in a discussion that too easily falls prey to amateurish fear-mongering, he sometimes fails to provide citations—and, weirdly, quotes Dutch documents in stilted English translated by Google.

Nonetheless, Smith is generally a clear writer, he has immersed himself in these issues for years, and the portrait he paints is, on the whole, convincing and therefore ghastly. People really are suffering grim and painful deaths over several days by having food and water tubes removed against their will. Depressed and debilitated people really are being pressured into suicide by family members and physicians wanting them out of the way. Comatose or otherwise unresponsive patients really are being treated as vegetables: useful for what can be harvested from them but otherwise having no intrinsic worth and therefore not worth keeping alive.

Advance Warning

Smith’s archenemies are secularist “bioethicists” such as Joseph Fletcher, Peter Singer, and Udo Schuklenk, whom he quotes at length—to their own damnation, it seems. He details how, among themselves, these figures discuss with shocking clarity eugenics, organ transplantation from living subjects, death to human beings with insufficiently impressive “quality of life,” transhuman cyborgs, and more—even as they speak in disingenuously soothing weasel words to the general public. Thus Smith gives us advance warning of the ideas shaping the minds of the medical professionals, lawyers, politicians, and jurists making important decisions about your life and mine.

Regrettably, Smith occasionally succumbs to making crudely populist appeals. You can almost hear him asking, “See what those horrible intellectuals and ‘experts’ are up to?” He seems deeply conflicted as to what form of health care administration could improve matters, since he strongly dislikes Obamacare but also rightly scorns corporations deciding ethical issues via HMOs and the like. And while there are genuine parallels between modern bioethics abuses and Nazi atrocities, Smith is apt to take the comparison to hyperbolic lengths.

Browse All Book Reviews By:
Read These Next
Current IssueNew & Noteworthy Books
New & Noteworthy Books Subscriber Access Only
Compiled by Matt Reynolds.
RecommendedThe Theology Beneath the Trump-Comey Conflict
The Theology Beneath the Trump-Comey Conflict
How the former FBI director’s interest in Reinhold Niebuhr shaped his approach to political power.
TrendingISIS Kills 29 Christians on Church Bus Trip to Popular Monastery
ISIS Kills 29 Christians on Church Bus Trip to Popular Monastery
(UPDATED) Egypt cancels Ramadan’s opening celebration as Copts resist revenge.
Editor's PickDo This in Remembrance
Do This in Remembrance
Participating in the “high holy day” of American civil religion is beneficial for Christians, so long as we do so thoughtfully.
View this article in Reader Mode
Christianity Today
The Precarious Future of Assisted Suicide