City Erects Pagan Sculpture

ill Quetzalcoatl statue violate Establishment Clause?

A controversial sculpture of a pre-Columbian deity is due to be unveiled in a San Jose, California, park this month after years of debate and the expenditure of an estimated $500,000 in public funds. At the same time, a vocal opponent of the statue, which features Aztec deity Quetzalcoatl, said his outspoken stand cost him reappointment to a prominent city panel.

The Quetzalcoatl statue will rise in a park dedicated to the memory of Cesar Chavez, late founder of the United Farm Worker’s union. The park itself stands opposite a Roman Catholic cathedral. The 25-foot-high statue was proposed in 1991 by Blanca Alvarado, then a city council member and now vice mayor, who said the sculpture would serve as a tribute to the city’s Mexican past—and spiritual heritage.

“There has been for me a spiritual renaissance in researching the attributes of Quetzalcoatl,” Alvarado told the city’s Urban Review Design Board in 1992. “If we use this as a tool, which is another benefit for the city, … it is a way of teaching our children.”

At the dedication ceremony of the statue, which earned sculptor Robert Graham a reported $400,000 commission, it is expected that school children, under a program sponsored by Alvarado, will bring drawings of Aztec deities and symbols to the statue as a tribute. They are expected to affix the drawings to the sculpture’s base, for which the city has allocated an additional $100,000.

No photographs of the sculpture have been released—an unusual circumstance for a public art commission. Besides standing 25 feet above its base, the statue is said to embody a coiled serpent from whose tail a “golden ball” will be suspended to diffuse sunlight into the interior and base of the work.

The issue has divided public opinion in this city, which is one hour south of San Francisco and home to many high-tech companies. Apple Computer got its start in a dusty garage here, and the town’s National Hockey League franchise was a playoff contender this year.

EARLY OPPONENT

The rush to embrace the controversial statue not only cast the city back to ancient times and themes, but it also may have cost Salvatore Caruso his job. Caruso, who had been chairman of the City Planning Commission, believes he was not reappointed to the prestigious post, which has an annual stipend of $3,600, because of his opposition to the statue.

A Roman Catholic, Caruso was an early and vocal critic of the project. He claimed extensive research showed that Quetzalcoatl was not a mere symbol of the past but a “bloodthirsty god” who demanded human hearts as part of worship.

The tradition of human sacrifice, scholarly studies indicate, harks back to the Toltec religion, said to have been predominant in Mexico from approximately A.D. 800 to 1100. Richard Townsend, who is a curator at the Art Institute of Chicago and a specialist in the religious world of ancient Mexico, told CHRISTIANITY TODAY that “Quetzalcoatl has been well known for many years as one of the principal deities of ancient Mexico. In its most basic aspect, the deity was the god of wind that brought rain in its wake.” He said it is not a deity that necessarily invites or requires human sacrifice.

Caruso, during a city council debate on the statue, declared, “Human sacrifice, for any reason, is wrong, wrong, wrong.” Yet other community leaders, including Mateo Sheedy, a priest at Sacred Heart Church in San Jose, wrote letters to the editor in support of the statue.

As the project progressed through city government channels, Caruso began to be more vocal in opposing the statue. At the same time, he found out he would not be appointed for a customary second term on the Planning Commission, despite agreement by city officials that he had performed well. Caruso alleges that intense lobbying by Alvarado blocked his reappointment. One council member told him, “Your views sound too much like fundamentalism, and that has no place in politics.”

Caruso, while no longer a member of the Planning Commission, has not totally ruled out future political involvement. Most distressing, Caruso said, was the response of local civil liberties officials when he complained the statue might violate the United States Constitution’s Establishment Clause. Because there is no current “Church of Quetzalcoatl,” he was informed, the statue, though portraying a religious figure, is not promoting an active religion and therefore would likely be found legal. San Jose City Attorney Joan Gallo has made the same claim for when the school children “pay tribute” to the statue, as Vice Mayor Alvarado describes it.

Copyright © 1994 Christianity Today. Click for reprint information.

Also in this issue

Reaching the First Post-Christian Generation: Baby Busters make new demands on the church

Cover Story

Reaching the First Post-Christian Generation

Randall Terry Attacks Religious Right

Christians Aid Forgotten Guyanese Poor

Christians Suffer Renewed Attacks

Muslim Death Threats Protested

Protesters Offer Silent Witness in Haiti

Florida Shootings Stifle Pro-lifers

Science Finds Religion at Symposium

NORTH AMERICAN SCENE: Fragrance-free Service Initiated

New Catechism a Bestseller

Christians Decry Rights Bill

Urban Relocators Build Bridges

Jews for Jesus Fights Cult Label

Has Rift Between Orthodox, Protestants Begun to Heal?

Group Picks First American Leader

Churches Challenge Synod Ruling

BOOKS: Rating Our Theologians

SIDEBAR: Worth Mentioning: News, notices, and curiosities of religious publishing

PHILIP YANCEY: What Surprised Jesus

Christians Suffer Renewed Attacks

News

FEC Targets Political Ad

News

News Briefs: September 12, 1994

News

Closing the Ultimate Sale

News

Media Campaign Targets Unchurched

Talking 'Bout a Generation

In Praise of Premise Keepers

The Unrepeatable Tom Skinner

Editorial

EDITORIAL: Blinded by the ’Lite’

Editorial

EDITORIAL: AIDS Policy Failure

News

Hard-Core Porn Technology Hits Home

SIDEBAR: Busters Online

SIDEBAR: X-ing the Church

ARTICLE: Testing the Spiritualities

ARTICLE: Charting Dispensationalism

SIDEBAR: Dispensationalisms of the Third Kind

ARTICLE: Clocking Out

ARTICLE: Who’s Afraid of the Holy Spirit?

Classic & Contemporary Excerpts from September 12, 1994

View issue

Our Latest

News

Donald Trump Takes the White House Again

In his late-night victory speech, the former president says God gave him a mission to “save our country.”

News

Florida’s Abortion Amendment Becomes the First to Fail Since Roe’s Reversal

On election night, pro-lifers cheered the news that a 6-week ban enacted under Gov. Ron DeSantis will get to stay.

News

Conservative Anglicans Call for Archbishop to Repent Over Same-Sex Relationships Stance

As the issue continues to divide the Church of England, Justin Welby spoke on a popular podcast about how his views have “evolved.”

Go Slow and Repair Things

We’re facing huge problems in our culture—problems an election alone can’t solve. But by God’s grace, we can do the small, daily work of repair.

In a Polarized World, but Not of It 

On Election Day and beyond, conservative and liberal Christians can better understand each other and be ministers of reconciliation. 

Gen Z Is Turning Online for Spiritual Guidance

Where Ya From?

Navigating Cultural Identity with Danielle Marck

Danielle Marck shares the experiences that pivoted the direction of her life toward her callings from God.

News

Charlie Kirk Aims to Expand Turning Point USA to Evangelical Campuses

But not all Christian campuses have embraced the conservative group.

Apple PodcastsDown ArrowDown ArrowDown Arrowarrow_left_altLeft ArrowLeft ArrowRight ArrowRight ArrowRight Arrowarrow_up_altUp ArrowUp ArrowAvailable at Amazoncaret-downCloseCloseEmailEmailExpandExpandExternalExternalFacebookfacebook-squareGiftGiftGooglegoogleGoogle KeephamburgerInstagraminstagram-squareLinkLinklinkedin-squareListenListenListenChristianity TodayCT Creative Studio Logologo_orgMegaphoneMenuMenupausePinterestPlayPlayPocketPodcastRSSRSSSaveSaveSaveSearchSearchsearchSpotifyStitcherTelegramTable of ContentsTable of Contentstwitter-squareWhatsAppXYouTubeYouTube