Singing the Local Church Blues

My church has just gone through an involuntary downsizing. No heresy or gross immorality was committed (though petty immoralities abounded). Half the members of my small group now attend other churches. I have heard the cause of the spiritual blood-spilling described as “disagreements over management style”—a partly true but pathetic excuse considering all the severed relationships.

I am not the only one on CT’s hallway whose Christian life is preoccupied with church issues. One editor is in the middle of a congregational conflict over one of its outreach ministries. Another has recently survived one of those exhausting reinventing-the-wheel debates about whether they really need a pastor.

If CT were to ask evangelical leaders to name the key problems confronting the church (which we regularly do), we would hear of secularism, paganism, intellectual pluralism, consumerism, the “culture of death,” and so on. And it is no accident that we address these topics often in CT. But one area that would not be on the list would be that very thing that has preoccupied me and many others: the imperfect way the local church embodies Christian ideals—how we spend hours debating nonessentials and call it “ministry,” how we let personality conflicts smother the church’s other work, or how we too easily justify doing and saying nasty things to our fellow believers. The local church can get ugly. I know.

This gap between an abstracted list of problems that plague the whole church and what many experience in their local churches bothers me. To bridge this gulf, we occasionally undertake what I call “churchly reporting.” This issue’s cover story, “Why Pastor Steve Loves His Job” (which begins on p. 13), is a good example. David Goetz, the senior associate editor of our award-winning sister publication LEADERSHIP, takes a widespread issue—the state of the pastoral vocation—and incarnates it in the story of Steve Mathewson, pastor of Dry Creek Bible Church in rural Montana. Dave, who has his own tales of woe from his experience as a pastor, brings a sharp and wise eye to the subject, revealing to us laity the secret thoughts of pastors, thereby helping us understand them better.

I don’t want to give the impression that all the news from the local church is bad, only that the local church is the most important context for the Christian life. Our spiritual lives emerge out of a community, whether First Baptist or Trinity Episcopal. It is this dimension that CT wants to give more coverage to. And while I have been singing the local church blues lately, I also realize this is the primary context in which the good news is made manifest, the place where many recognize us by our biblical name, the body of Christ (albeit a sometimes bruised and battered body).

Copyright © 1997 Christianity Today. Click for reprint information.

Also in this issue

Why Pastor Steve Loves His Job: Pastors are overworked, underpaid, and bear the weight of unrealistic expectations. Why then are so many so satisfied?

Cover Story

Why Pastor Steve Loves His Job Part 2

Cover Story

Why Pastor Steve Loves His Job

Cover Story

Why Pastor Steve Loves His Job Part 3

Training Shortfall May Imperil Growth

Ecumenism: Back to the Drawing Board for Ecumenism?

Arab Press Says Hussein Has Returned to Islam

Giving: Inheritance Windfall May Bypass Churches

Bill Sparks Abortion Controversy in Israel

Neat! Way Cool! Awesome!

Assemblies of God: Layoffs Avoided in Downsizing

What Pastor's Wives Wish Their Churches Knew Part 1

What Pastor's Wives Wish Their Churches Knew Part 2

Leaders Allege Clergy Harassment

First Lady Wants to Love Enemies

Preachers Dwell Less on Fundraising

Hatfield Praised as Christian Statesman

Muslims Destroy Christian Village

Evangelicals Plead for Korean Aid

Can Americans Still Hear the Good News?

News

News Briefs: April 07, 1997

News

News Briefs: April 07, 1997

News

Obituary: Historian Smith, 72, Dies

Letters

Editorial

A Tutsi's Hope

Editorial

Mourning the Morning-After Pill

The Dilemmas of a Pro-Life Pastor

News

Sharing Living Water

Why the Conductor Threw Away His Baton

Love and Miracles in China

The Agnostic’s Expositor

A Canadian with an Attitude

Classic & Contemporary Excerpts from April 07, 1997

Welfare Reform: God in a Box?

Evangelism: Is Jewish-Christian a Contradiction in Terms?

View issue

Our Latest

Public Theology Project

When Violence Is the Vibe

In the wake of Charlie Kirk’s death, if we bite and devour each other, we will be consumed by each other.

The Russell Moore Show

Books about Digital Resistance with Ashley Hales: Wendell Berry, Jan Karon, Jon Haidt, David Zahl, and More

Another quarterly conversation on books with Christianity Today’s Print Editor, Ashley Hales, on the subject of resisting the digital era

How Indian Christian Families are Tackling Gen Z Loneliness

Couples involved in student ministries are welcoming young people into their homes and lives.

Review

An Unpersuasive Plea for Christians to Swing Left

Phil Christman’s apology for progressive politics ignores points of natural affinity with conservatives.

News

Texas Student Ministry Sues over Law Cutting Off Free Speech at 10 p.m.

In honor of Charlie Kirk, lawmakers will meet to reevaluate campus discourse, including new state regulations.

Review

Jesus Uses Money to Diagnose Our Spiritual Bankruptcy

A new book immerses us in the strange, subversive logic of his financial parables.

‘Make the Truth Interesting to Hear, Even Enjoyable’ 

Robert Clements doesn’t shy away from his Christian faith in his newspaper column. Yet Indian readers keep coming back for more.

The Way We Debate Atonement Is a Mess

A case study in how Christians talk about theology, featuring a recent dustup over penal substitutionary atonement.

Apple PodcastsDown ArrowDown ArrowDown Arrowarrow_left_altLeft ArrowLeft ArrowRight ArrowRight ArrowRight Arrowarrow_up_altUp ArrowUp ArrowAvailable at Amazoncaret-downCloseCloseEmailEmailExpandExpandExternalExternalFacebookfacebook-squareGiftGiftGooglegoogleGoogle KeephamburgerInstagraminstagram-squareLinkLinklinkedin-squareListenListenListenChristianity TodayCT Creative Studio Logologo_orgMegaphoneMenuMenupausePinterestPlayPlayPocketPodcastRSSRSSSaveSaveSaveSearchSearchsearchSpotifyStitcherTelegramTable of ContentsTable of Contentstwitter-squareWhatsAppXYouTubeYouTube