A Pilgrim on the Way

For me, theology is like a rich feast, with many dishes to enjoy and delicacies to taste.

I welcome Roger Olson’s article and resonate with its analysis. There are different types of theologians, and we need to respect each other’s work. We are being called to strive for the dynamic equilibrium of continuity and creativity that characterizes great theology. Olson believes, as I do, that fidelity to Scripture is consonant with innovation in formulating doctrine, and that it is all right at times to challenge assumptions that underlie certain of our traditions.

DOING THEOLOGY EN ROUTE I also hear Olson saying (as a subtext) that, since more of our theologians are traditionalists, room needs to be made for reformists who are often under suspicion. I for one hope he is right in thinking that the evangelical movement is mature enough now to welcome both traditionalists and reformists.

As a reformist myself, I approach theology in a spirit of adventure, being always curious about what I may find. For me, theology is like a rich feast, with many dishes to enjoy and delicacies to taste. It is like a centuries-old conversation that I am privileged to take part in, a conversation replete with innumerable voices to listen to. More like a pilgrim than a settler, I tread the path of discovery and do my theology en route.

I also do theology contextually, recognizing that theology will reflect the culture in which it emerges. Everything I write is not only about something but is addressed to someone. I may have been unwise in introducing too many of my discoveries in too short a time since I have fallen under a cloud of suspicion on account of it. I know perfectly well that evangelicals are leery of innovation in theology (because it reminds them of liberalism), and that they expect their theologians to defend tradition, not challenge it. I have only myself to blame for calling too many things into question too quickly.

CONFRONTING PALEO-CALVINISM We must realize that it will not be easy for traditionalists and reformists to live together in harmony. To illustrate, a few years ago a group of us proposed a model we called the openness of God. In it we portrayed God as a loving person and relational being, open to and interacting with the world. We thought it was scripturally serious, theologically fruitful, philosophically striking, and practically on target.

Though there were some who welcomed it, it was also attacked severely. The new Southern Baptist Journal of Theology, for example, saw it as a shot in a new battle over the doctrine of God. And the popular Reformed theologian R. C. Sproul warned that it was “an assault not merely on Calvinism, or even on classical theism, but on Christianity itself” (Willing to Believe: The Controversy over Free Will, p. 143).

I also heard an audiotape from one of Sproul’s conferences where he said, in answer to a question, that he does not consider me a Christian any longer (not to say an evangelical); and that he would not have fellowship with me because I have espoused a theological model at odds with his own variety of paleo-Calvinism in which there is no room for a vision of God as fully personal and involved, relational and passionate, mutual and reciprocal. Evidently Sproul is comfortable with perfections of stability but not with perfections of change in God. He appears to be blind to the need for a better balance between transcendence and God’s suffering involvement in history. He loves the Reformation but does not appreciate hearing that maybe we need an ongoing reformation.

My point is that relations between traditionalists and reformists are threatened because some of the traditionalists insist on a more specific doctrinal component in the definition of evangelical orthodoxy than Olson describes. The model of openness, for example, cannot be evangelical, they say, because it disputes the manipulative nature of the divine-human relationship held by paleo-Calvinism.

In part I understand how they feel. The early leaders of the postwar evangelical coalition were for the most part conservative Calvinists, and it was mostly understood that there would not be a swing away from that theology. But over time we have developed into much more diverse groups of people, and the hegemony of paleo-Calvinism has dissolved. It will be hard for those who think that is a good thing to live in harmony with those who think it is a major disaster.

CALLED TO MODESTY In order for Olson’s call for peaceful relations to succeed, two things have to happen. First, we must become more modest in our claims. I do not have the final answers; neither does Sproul. Theology is an unfinished task, and all of our efforts at interpretation are limited in insight. As Paul says, “We see through a glass darkly.” There is more to be known about God than any of us presently knows.

Second, we need to look to the future as well as the past. Theology did not reach perfection when the Westminster Confession (or some other sectarian standard) was penned. Theology is a venture in hope for all of us; let us pray for and anticipate an ever-fuller understanding from the Spirit of God.

May God grant that we continue to grow as hearers of the Word and enlarge our vision of the truth through interaction with each other. For my part, I value the work of R. C. Sproul and wish him godspeed.

Clark H. Pinnock is professor of theology at McMaster Divinity College, Hamilton, Ontario, Canada, and author of Flame of Love: A Theology of the Holy Spirit (InterVarsity, 1996).

Copyright © 1998 Christianity Today. Click for reprint information.

Also in this issue

How Much Truth Can We Take? South Africa looks for healing from its violent past. Christian people and Christian ideas take the lead.

Cover Story

How much truth can We take?

Between a Nightmare and a Dream

Classic & Contemporary Excerpts from February 09, 1998

Revival: Brownsville Revival Rolls Onward

Moon-Related Funds Filter to Evangelicals

Profamily Groups Demand More Cyberporn Prosecutions

Prisons: Unique Prison Program Serves as Boot Camp for Heaven

New York City: King's College Resurrection Signals Big Apple's Renewal

Imprisoned Evangelicals Dispute Accusations of Terrorism

Growing Criticism

Jesusโ€™ Unanswered Prayers

Cry with a Beloved Country

The Word Became Art

Strict Antimissionary Bill Retooled

Plans Under Way for Next Day of Prayer

New Leaders Emerging After Civil War

Assemblies of God Church Attacked

NAE President Argue Takes New Post

Split Nearing for Texas Convention

Gender Revisions Completed on NIrV

Tin Drum Oklahoma Clash Marches On

Man Objecting to Foster Parents Fired

Does Evangelical Theology Have a Future?

News

News Briefs: February 09, 1998

News

News Briefs: February 09, 1998

A Tough Choice

We Get Letters

Editorial

Let the Prisoners Work

Editorial

Wimberโ€™s Wonders

Exposing the Myth That Christians Should Not Have Emotional Problems

Iโ€™m Not OK, Youโ€™re Not OK

The Alpha-Brits Are Coming

News

Seeker Sensitive on Russia's Frozen Frontier

The Real Reformers are Traditionalists

A Theology to Die For

The 'Jackie Robinson' of Evangelism

Why We Love This Deadly Sin

Don't Blame the Publishers!

The Struggle for Lincoln's Soul

Paid in Full

Racismโ€™s Faces of Faith

View issue

Our Latest

Be Afraid

Be Afraid Bonus Episode 3: Scott Teems

Sometimes, thereโ€™s safety in numbers.

News

In Appalachia, Helene’s Water Crisis Taps a Global Christian Response

North Carolina churches are seeing people suffering dehydration. Disaster groups that work overseas are showing up to help.

Public Theology Project

The Bible Doesnโ€™t Fit an Information Age

Algorithms strip us of mystery. The Gospels restore our ability to be astonished by the truth.

Wire Story

Evangelicals for Harris Asked to โ€˜Cease and Desistโ€™ Billy Graham Ad

Franklin Graham says the campaign is โ€œtrying to mislead peopleโ€ by positioning his fatherโ€™s preaching in contrast to Donald Trump.

Facing My Limits in a Flood Zone

As a minister, Iโ€™m used to helping people during crisis. But trapped at home during Hurricane Helene, I could only care for who was in front of me.

5 Lessons Christians Can Learn from the Barmen Declaration

How a wartime confession resisted Hitlerโ€™s Nazification of the German church, and why its principles are still relevant today.

The Russell Moore Show

Autocracy, Robots, and Outlaws

Russell Moore and Ashley Hales, CTโ€™s editorial director for print, discuss what theyโ€™re reading.

News

Back at Shooting Site, Trump Supporters Pray for His Protection

Still shaken by the tragic attack, Butler, Pennsylvania, welcomed the former president back with cheers of triumph and a memorial for the previous rallyโ€™s victim.

Apple PodcastsDown ArrowDown ArrowDown Arrowarrow_left_altLeft ArrowLeft ArrowRight ArrowRight ArrowRight Arrowarrow_up_altUp ArrowUp ArrowAvailable at Amazoncaret-downCloseCloseEmailEmailExpandExpandExternalExternalFacebookfacebook-squareGiftGiftGooglegoogleGoogle KeephamburgerInstagraminstagram-squareLinkLinklinkedin-squareListenListenListenChristianity TodayCT Creative Studio Logologo_orgMegaphoneMenuMenupausePinterestPlayPlayPocketPodcastRSSRSSSaveSaveSaveSearchSearchsearchSpotifyStitcherTelegramTable of ContentsTable of Contentstwitter-squareWhatsAppXYouTubeYouTube