Was the Revolutionary War Justified?

Americans fought a war to gain the kind of freedom that Canada, New Zealand, and Australia were simply given.

Q: Considering the biblical injunction to submit to civil government (Rom. 13:1 and 1 Peter 2:13-14), were Christian colonists justified in participating in the Revolutionary War?

—James Miller, Lexington, Kentucky

A:Only one population in the colonies clearly was justified by classical Christian reasoning in taking up arms to defend itself—the half-million or so enslaved African Americans who were held in bondage as the result of armed attacks upon peaceful noncombatants.

When it comes to the British actions toward the colonies in the decade before 1776, almost all historians concede those actions were insensitive, based on lamentable misconceptions of colonial life, and often simply stupid. George III, a responsible family man who tried to act like a Christian, was far from the ogre pictured in the Declaration of Independence. But he had no real feel for life in the colonies, and he, when choosing advisers, allowed political loyalty to take precedence over sound assessments of ability. So colonial leaders complaining about mistreatment from Britain were not making things up.

But were the admitted abuses serious enough to warrant an armed revolution? Patriot leaders thought so, but there is a problem with why they thought so. They were troubled less by actual evils (like the tax on tea, which, ironically, had made tea cheaper in the colonies than in England). Rather, they interpreted the bumbling British actions as a conspiracy to exterminate liberty in the colonies.

This belief explains why, as political tensions increased, patriot leaders accused the British of behaving like Roman Catholics. Decades of warfare pitting Catholic France against Protestant Britain had taught all the British, even the colonists, simply to equate tyranny with the pope and freedom with Britain. In short, it was the patriot fear of what Britain intended to do that led them to take up arms.

Some British Christians thought this fear ludicrous. John Fletcher, a leading Methodist, wrote sympathetically in 1776 about the plight of American slaves, "whose groans upbraid the hypocritical friends of liberty [in America], who buy, and sell, and whip their fellow men as if they were brutes; and absurdly complain that they are enslaved." But patriot colonists saw things very differently indeed. They thought they were menaced by a comprehensive plot to violate their rights and property, and so they went to war.

To the extent that colonists really thought that Britain intended systematic despotism, their going to war could perhaps be justified in classical Christian terms. Armed action to preempt an enemy's destructive intentions had long been considered moral. But if the problem in Britain was not primarily a malicious conspiracy but insensitive bungling, war would not have been justified.

In addition, principles of just war going back to Augustine insisted that war was justified only as a last resort after all reasonable means of ending disputes peacefully had been exhausted. By the 1770s, it had indeed grown difficult for colonial leaders and British ministers to understand the assumptions from which their opponents were speaking. But it was hardly the case that colonists went a second mile in stopping the chain of increasingly violent acts that pushed the two sides to all-out war. Rather, from the Boston Tea Party of 1773, through Lexington and Concord in 1774 and the battle of Bunker (or Breed's) Hill in 1775, to the Declaration of Independence in 1776, patriots fairly leapt to their conclusions about the evil intentions of Parliament.

During this confused misunderstanding, the Bible was used as a reservoir of images, moral principles, and types. Many sermons in America (and some in Britain) supported revolt, while a few in America and England argued against it. Serious exegesis, however, of what would seem to us like the relevant passages (such as Romans 13) was very rare. Rather, it was much more common for patriots to liken George III to Pharaoh and George Washington to Moses, or to depict the conflict as a struggle between the Woman and the Beast of Revelation 12. Patriots and Loyalists were both much more likely to add scriptural authority to political reasoning rooted in some other ideology than they were to attempt reasoning from the ground up on the basis of Scripture.

As a result, Americans fought a war to gain the kind of freedom that Canada, New Zealand, and Australia were simply given after not too many decades. An evil precedent was also established in America for later times of national crisis by employing the Bible eccentrically (instead of theologically) and by worrying about classical Christian justifications for warfare hardly at all. The lesson here is not that America had a uniquely evil history, for the Founding Fathers were morally exemplary on many other matters. It is that using the Scriptures for public disputes requires a full measure of reasoned calm as well as passionate engagement.

By Mark A. Noll, author of Christians in the American Revolution (Eerdmans).

Copyright © 1999 Christianity Today. Click for reprint information.

Also in this issue

The New Theologians: In a realm once dominated by theological liberals, many of today's top scholars are orthodox believers.

Cover Story

Ellen Charry: Reclaiming spiritual nurture.

Cover Story

N.T. Wright: Making Scholarship a Tool for the Church

Cover Story

Kevin Vanhoozer: Creating a theological symphony.

Cover Story

Miroslav Volf: Speaking truth to the world.

Cover Story

Richard Hays: Recovering the Bible for the church.

Cover Story

New Theologians

Napalm Victim Now Agent for Peace

Why I Love Small Churches

Max Lucado’s Maxims

Baroness Caroline Cox: The Price of a Slave

Classic & Contemporary Excerpts from February 08, 1999

Muddy Murals

Tales of a Reluctant Convert and more

Is Orlando New Promised Land?

Churches Accused of Electioneering

Chaplains Reach River Mariners

Bridging Kosovo's Deep Divisions

Neighbors Fight Cell Tower 'Cross'

In Brief: February 08, 1999

Why I Can Feel Your Pain

World Vision Boots Austrian Affiliate

Christians Recreate Jesus' Home

In Brief: February 08, 1999

New Unreached Group Targeted

Holy Land Archaeology Imperiled

Ethiopia Focus on Evangelism

Churches Retrain Workers

In Print-Does God Live in Your Brain

Key Year for Lewisian Thespians

On the Back Flap—Lewis Smedes

A Six-Pack of Strobel's

Letters

Revival: Pensacola Outpouring Eyes Global Goals

$12 Million Fraud Scheme Parallels Greater Ministries

Cuba: Did the Papal visit Change Anything?

Group Helps Communities Curb Smut

Congo: Missionaries Flee Amid Latest Fighting

Hypertext-Spirituality Sightings

Editorial

A Silent Holocaust in Iraq

The Gypsy Reformation

Trying Patience on for Size

View issue

Our Latest

News

As Shutdown Strains Incomes, Church Ramps Up to Feed the Hungry

In suburban Detroit, a $50,000 ministry grant helps families keep food on the tables during furloughs.

News

Kenyan Churches Struggle to Support Childless Couples

One Christian woman hopes to destigmatize infertility.

The Just Life with Benjamin Watson

Lecrae Moore: Why Lecrae Won’t Be Silent

Exploring faith that acts, how the gospel grounds justice, why silence wounds, and what hopeful, everyday courage looks like.

Review

‘Roe v. Wade’ Eroded the Church’s Historic Pro-Life Consensus

It was already unraveling by 1973. Repairing it today won’t be easy.

Taylor Swift Makes Showgirls of Us All

Something compels us to perform our relationship with the pop star’s music. Maybe that’s her secret to success.

Public Theology Project

The Loss of One Forgotten Virtue Could Destroy the Country

We’ve all become numb to this unserious, trivializing age.

The Russell Moore Show

Benjamin Watson and Russell Moore on The Just Life

Christian justice, gospel-centered living, and faithful action

News

Amid Floods and Heat Waves, Indian Church Fights Climate Change

Christ Church in Kerala tends to its garden while helping its parishioners and neighbors live sustainably.

Apple PodcastsDown ArrowDown ArrowDown Arrowarrow_left_altLeft ArrowLeft ArrowRight ArrowRight ArrowRight Arrowarrow_up_altUp ArrowUp ArrowAvailable at Amazoncaret-downCloseCloseEmailEmailExpandExpandExternalExternalFacebookfacebook-squareGiftGiftGooglegoogleGoogle KeephamburgerInstagraminstagram-squareLinkLinklinkedin-squareListenListenListenChristianity TodayCT Creative Studio Logologo_orgMegaphoneMenuMenupausePinterestPlayPlayPocketPodcastRSSRSSSaveSaveSaveSearchSearchsearchSpotifyStitcherTelegramTable of ContentsTable of Contentstwitter-squareWhatsAppXYouTubeYouTube