ARTS: Messiaen’s Complicated Contemplations

Composer Olivier Messiaen (1908-92) humbly reigned over modern classical music from the 1930s on, but as concert pianist Jacqueline Chew learned, he never neglected to express his reverence for the God of the Bible.

In 1944, Messiaen bequeathed Twenty Contemplations on the Infant Jesus to a torn, conflicted postwar world. This mammoth collage of musical extremes can sound as incomprehensible and lively as a child pounding a keyboard with unfettered glee, or as ageless and endless as a sober Zen Buddhist chant. It is still acclaimed as one of the peak piano compositions of this century.

When Chew first heard Contemplations, she felt an almost supernatural “calling” toward the music–an odd sensation for an atheist. Exploring Messiaen’s influences, Chew studied Thomas Aquinas, Giotto’s fourteenth-century frescoes, thirteenth-century Hindu rhythms, and the biographies of such Christian saints as Saint Terese of Lisieux. She began this labor of love as a skeptic, but eventually Messiaen’s devotion won her over. “Little by little, I started believing,” Chew remembers. “First I had responded purely to the music; eventually, the religious context became essential.”

OF TRIAL AND TRUST

Memorizing from a score over a thousand pages long, Chew labored 11 years to master five of the twenty movements, including “The Kiss of the Infant Jesus” and “By Him All Things Are Made.” In 1988 she pursued trilingual piano tutorials with Messiaen’s wife, Yvonne Loriod, in Paris. Loriod was an invaluable guide to mysterious fingerings that allowed the pianist to coax out Messiaen’s nuanced tonalities. Chew explains a cupped, rolling use of the small finger in a fashion that would be distinctly heretical to classical pianists.

Messiaen’s notations for chords were highly imaginative–as when he called for “orange with pigmentations of red and green, touches of gold, also milky white . . . iridescent reflections like opal.” Chew still conjures up images of “reflections, light effects, battles on horseback, gardens, a baby” to achieve the proper tones during a two-and-a-quarter-hour performance. “It’s absolutely impossible to learn by the notes,” she asserts. “They’re just a distraction.”

Chew’s pursuit of Twenty Contemplations became a metaphor about trial and trusting God. Grueling eight-hour practices for her first full-length performance literally wore out her forearms. “I was constantly in pain. I had to practice less, and that’s very scary. After 20 minutes I had stop, focus, and simply have faith that I knew the piece.” Specialists warned that her muscles might be irreparably damaged.

“At that point I wasn’t sure if I should cancel the concert. I didn’t even know if I could get through the whole piece, so there was no dress rehearsal. I wasn’t sure if I would permanently injure myself.” But she decided to go ahead; then, after a successful 1988 performance, she stopped playing the piano for a year to rest. Today Chew teaches and performs regularly with the Woman’s Philharmonic Orchestra of Berkeley (Calif).

Contemplations is so demanding that Chew must put her life on hold to prepare for a live performance. She is one of only three pianists in the Bay Area, including Messiaen’s wife, who have performed Twenty Contemplations in its entirety. Her satisfaction is more than professional. “Hearing it live is a very different experience; when I’m sharing it with someone new, I can’t say, ‘just go listen to the CD.’ ” She feels the listener has to be prepared–an act akin to prayer before Communion. “Sometimes I play a few parts in a church service, or give a talk. People go into shock. I expect that. I’m not one who goes around verbalizing my faith, but this music simply is my testimony.”

Chew, who met Messiaen in 1988, hesitates to call him a genius only because she was so impressed by his obvious humility. “I think he saw himself as an instrument trying to express God’s glory,” she says. “His gifts convey something about God, something he understands directly from God and communicates to us. To me this is more than ‘just’ music. This is a message from God. It is, literally, like being with God.”

One of several recordings of “Twenty Contemplations” (Vingt Regards) is a performance by Yvonne Loriod on the Erato label (WEA Records, $19.98); there are versions by Michel Beroff on EMI and by Roger Muraro on MCA Classics.

Copyright © 1996 Christianity Today. Click for reprint information.

Also in this issue

Persecuted: A crisis for the contemporary church

Christians, Jews Form Coalition

Lutheran, Catholic, and Black Churches Join Graham Effort

1,800 Churches Participating in Olympic Outreach

Gayle White in Atlanta

YANCEY: Confessions of a Spiritual Amnesiac

Why the Psalms Scare Us

Kathleen Norris

From the Fringe to the Fold

Ruth Tucker

NORTH AMERICAN SCENE: Arsons Continue, Frustration Sets In

Foes, Backers Seeks Common Ground

Ross Pavlac in Madison, Wisconsin

Congressmen Focus on Persecuted Believers

Bishops Propose Chastity Canon

Women Become 'Promise Keepers'

WORLD SCENE: Abducted SIL Missionary Freed

News

OBITUARY: Ex-Fuller President David Hubbard Dies

Palau Preached to a Preoccupied Metropolis

John W. Kennedy in Chicago, with reports from Bradley Baurain and Christian Coon

Evangelist Sets Sights on U.S. Latinos

By Andres T. Tapia in Chicago

The Suffering Church

Kim A. Lawton

SIDEBAR: Forgive Us Our Trespasses

News

News Briefs: July 15, 1996

Wire Story

SBC Targets Clinton, Disney, Jews

Timothy C. Morgan in New Orleans, with reports from Baptist Press

Risky Business

LETTERS: No Middle Ground

Editorial

EDITORIAL: Ministry in the Real World Order

Robert A. Seiple, president of World Vision U.S

Editorial

EDITORIAL: Burned, but Not Consumed

Richard A. Kauffman

ARTICLE: Saving the Safety Net

Everett L. Wilson

SIDEBAR: When Your Church Says It’s Wrong

Camilla F. Kleindienst, who lives in Fulton, Missouri.

News

News Briefs: July 15, 1996

ARTICLE: Tolerance Without Compromise

Richard J. Mouw

BOOKS: Getting Evangelicals into the Church

Robert W. Patterson

BOOKS: Wesley on CD

BOOKS: Hymns for the Politically Correct

Donald G. Bloesch

Classic & Contemporary Excerpts from July 15, 1996

SIDEBAR: Escaping Martyrdom in Saudi Arabia

SIDEBAR: Help for the Persecuted

View issue

Our Latest

My Top 5 Books on Christianity in South Asia

Compiled by Nathanael Somanathan

Wisdom on staying faithful in ministry and navigating multireligious realities in India, Sri Lanka, and beyond.

News

Top Women’s Cricket Player Trolled for Her Christian Faith

Vikram Mukka

Christian public figures in India face online attacks and offline consequences for speaking about Jesus.

The Russell Moore Show

Our Favorite Moments from 2025 Episodes

Russell and Leslie meander through the 2025 podcast episodes and share some of their favorite moments.

The Case Against VIP Tickets at Christian Conferences

Jazer Willis

Exclusive perks may be well-intended business decisions, but Christian gatherings shouldn’t reinforce economic hierarchy.

The Bulletin

Pete Hegseth’s Future, Farmers on Tariffs, and Religious Decline Stalls

Mike Cosper, Clarissa Moll

Hegseth scrutinized for drug boat strikes, farmers react to Trump’s tariffs, and a Pew report says religious decline has slowed.

The Debate over Government Overreach Started in 1776

Three books to read this month on politics and public life.

The Call to Art, Africa, and Politics

In 1964, CT urged Christians to “be what they really are—new men and women in Christ.”

Apple PodcastsDown ArrowDown ArrowDown Arrowarrow_left_altLeft ArrowLeft ArrowRight ArrowRight ArrowRight Arrowarrow_up_altUp ArrowUp ArrowAvailable at Amazoncaret-downCloseCloseEmailEmailExpandExpandExternalExternalFacebookfacebook-squareGiftGiftGooglegoogleGoogle KeephamburgerInstagraminstagram-squareLinkLinklinkedin-squareListenListenListenChristianity TodayCT Creative Studio Logologo_orgMegaphoneMenuMenupausePinterestPlayPlayPocketPodcastRSSRSSSaveSaveSaveSearchSearchsearchSpotifyStitcherTelegramTable of ContentsTable of Contentstwitter-squareWhatsAppXYouTubeYouTube