Pakistan: Court weighs appeal of death-row Christian.

Family pins hopes for release on attorney’s novel argument

Ayub Masih has been behind bars for five and a half years, the last four on death row, for allegedly blaspheming Muhammad. One year ago, the Multan Bench of the Lahore High Court confirmed the sentence—death by hanging.

The case, brought under a 16-year-old blasphemy law, is now before Pakistan’s Supreme Court. A final ruling is expected soon. The 32-year-old Christian’s last hope rides on the novel legal strategy of his Marxist attorney, Abid Hasan Minto, who says local authorities did not ascertain the reliability of the witnesses who brought charges against Masih.

“Islamic law instructs the courts not to take people as witnesses before there has been a report by authorities with regard to their credibility,” Minto told Christianity Today. “This has not happened in this case. I’m confident that we will win.”

“The blasphemy case against me is false, baseless, and concocted,” Masih told International Christian Concern in a rare interview from his small cell (CT, Oct. 22, 2001, p. 13).

Fleeing radical Islam

Although human rights advocates have spoken out for years about Masih’s case, the Masih family had not talked to the news media until an exclusive interview with Christianity Today in March. For the first time, they presented their side of the events leading to Masih’s arrest.

Members of the Masih family live in a crowded two-room house in a village known as 133/16-L, or Amrat Nagar, in the fractious province of Punjab. They fled there on October 14, 1996, after Muslim radicals looted and then burned their house in village 353 E.B., or Arifwala.

The new family home, two hours from Arifwala, has an outdoor kitchen and a toilet with no roof. Family members draw their meager income from a milk cow and day labor using their three water buffalo. Ayub Masih has seven brothers and four sisters. Only four of them, ages 15 to 22, still live here with the parents.

Shahzad Babar Masih, 22, says a simple land dispute sparked the trouble. Shahzad says that Muslim neighbors set up Ayub when the Masih parents were away. “One man slapped Ayub in the face, and the Muslims came in big numbers, accusing him of defaming their prophet,” Shahzad says. “They took him to the police station. The Muslims had torn off all his clothes except his underwear and tied up his hands.”

Another brother, Hasroon, now 20, was also beaten by the Muslim mob, but he escaped to the family home. “All of us were crying,” Hasroon says. “I was terrified. On the loudspeakers, we heard the mullah warn the Christian families to leave 353 or be stoned. We were afraid Ayub was already dead.”

Hasroon says all 14 Christian families in 353 cleared out within hours. Shahzad says that Ayub was studying in Karachi for the ministry before his arrest.

Ayub, hoping Minto’s strategy will pay off, is making plans.

“He has become very prayerful,” Shahzad says. “He’s fasting and studying the Bible. When he is released, he wants to serve the church in Pakistan.”

Adds Masih’s attorney, “The evidence has been fabricated because [Muslims] wanted to oust Christian settlers. … The case is based purely on witness testimony, and in my view, these persons are not reliable.”

Copyright © 2002 Christianity Today. Click for reprint information.

Related Elsewhere

Previous Christianity Today’s articles on Masih’s plight include:

High Court InjusticeWhat you can do to help persecuted Christians in Pakistan. (November 14, 2001)

Condemned Prisoner Appeals for HelpSentenced to death in 1998, Ayub Masih continues to fight “baseless and concocted” blasphemy charge. (October 19, 2001)

Pakistani Bishop’s Death Sparks RiotsSuicide was in protest of the death sentence pronounced on Ayub Masih, 25, by a local judge. (June 15, 1998)

Christian Solidarity Worldwide has a special page on Ayub Masih’s story.

In 1998, Anglican Communion News Service issued a press release on Masih’s sentence with background on the blasphemy law.

For more articles, see Christianity Today’spersecution and world report section on Pakistan.

Also in this issue

How Firm a Foundation? Habitat for Humanity's greatest challenge: its massive popularity

Cover Story

How to Build Homes Without Putting Up Walls

Tim Stafford

From the Fringe to the Fold

Letters

Hindus Continue to Slaughter Muslims in India

Anton Ankara

"Growing Protestants, Catholics Draw Ire"

Felix Corley and Geraldine Fagan

Heresy Charge Torpedoes Pastor's Political Debut

LaTonya Taylor

The Wages of Secularism

Interstate Nation

The Postmodern Moment

Glenn T. Stanton

"Bearing the Cross: Hounded, Beaten, and Shot in India"

Jeff M. Sellers

Prayer

Richard A. Kauffman

Two Cheers for Celibacy

Christianity Today editorial

Free the Burnhams

Christianity Today Editorial

Mark the Date

Separation of God and Gridiron

Quotation Marks

"Do the Dew, Davey"

No Secrets about Agents, Man

Kazakhstan: Constitutional Council rejects new religious restrictions.

Keston News Service and CT

Who's a Jew?: Messianic ministry sued over use of menorah.

Carol Lowes

Family Feud: Theologians Decry 'Narrow' Boundaries.

Timothy C. Morgan

National Association of Evangelicals regroups in nation’s capital

Jeff M. Sellers

Right to Die: Hawaii kills physician-assisted suicide bill

LaTonya Taylor

"Religious Liberty: Falwell, ACLU fight church restrictions and win."

LaTonya Taylor

"RU-486: After two die, Danco Labs warns doctors about dangers."

Defender of Dignity

The Smiling Grandfather Clock

Evelyn Bence

Evangelism of the Hammer

Keeping the Faith

Todd Hertz

View issue

Our Latest

My Top 5 Books on Christianity in South Asia

Compiled by Nathanael Somanathan

Wisdom on staying faithful in ministry and navigating multireligious realities in India, Sri Lanka, and beyond.

News

Top Women’s Cricket Player Trolled for Her Christian Faith

Vikram Mukka

Christian public figures in India face online attacks and offline consequences for speaking about Jesus.

The Russell Moore Show

Our Favorite Moments from 2025 Episodes

Russell and Leslie meander through the 2025 podcast episodes and share some of their favorite moments.

The Case Against VIP Tickets at Christian Conferences

Jazer Willis

Exclusive perks may be well-intended business decisions, but Christian gatherings shouldn’t reinforce economic hierarchy.

The Bulletin

Pete Hegseth’s Future, Farmers on Tariffs, and Religious Decline Stalls

Mike Cosper, Clarissa Moll

Hegseth scrutinized for drug boat strikes, farmers react to Trump’s tariffs, and a Pew report says religious decline has slowed.

The Debate over Government Overreach Started in 1776

Three books to read this month on politics and public life.

The Call to Art, Africa, and Politics

In 1964, CT urged Christians to “be what they really are—new men and women in Christ.”

Apple PodcastsDown ArrowDown ArrowDown Arrowarrow_left_altLeft ArrowLeft ArrowRight ArrowRight ArrowRight Arrowarrow_up_altUp ArrowUp ArrowAvailable at Amazoncaret-downCloseCloseEmailEmailExpandExpandExternalExternalFacebookfacebook-squareGiftGiftGooglegoogleGoogle KeephamburgerInstagraminstagram-squareLinkLinklinkedin-squareListenListenListenChristianity TodayCT Creative Studio Logologo_orgMegaphoneMenuMenupausePinterestPlayPlayPocketPodcastRSSRSSSaveSaveSaveSearchSearchsearchSpotifyStitcherTelegramTable of ContentsTable of Contentstwitter-squareWhatsAppXYouTubeYouTube