Style: Rock with plenty of power chords; compare to The Replacements and Thin Lizzy

Top tracks: "Barely Breathing," "The Sweet Part of the City," "Our Whole Lives"

"Heaven is whenever/ We get together and listen to records," sings Craig Finn on the fifth Hold Steady album. It's a nice thought on an album that celebrates hope in hard times, but a bit limp coming from the man who authored the fiery, gospel-drenched resurrection rock of, say, Separation Sunday. But cut Finn some slack: His own band is undergoing hard times of their own. After the departure of keys player Franz Nicolay, Finn and the gang make some thrilling transitions into country- and jazz-inflected territory, along with some cookie-cutter anthems that sound a little tired here.

Subscriber access only You have reached the end of this Article Preview

To continue reading, subscribe now. Subscribers have full digital access.

Heaven Is Whenever
Our Rating
3 Stars - Good
Average Rating
(not rated yet) ADD YOURS Help
Release Date
May 1, 2010
Browse All Music Reviews By: