Subscribe to Christianity Today
Subscribe to Christianity Today
Donate to Christianity Today
login | my account
May 26, 2012

Home > 2007 > DecemberChristianity Today, December, 2007
Courageous Nonviolence
At the first Christmas, the angels proclaimed, 'Peace on earth.' Just-war and pacifist Christians together can make it happen.




The 20th century was the bloodiest in human history. In Humanity: A Moral History of the 20th Century, Jonathan Glover estimates that 86,000,000 people died in wars fought from 1900 to 1989. That means 2,500 people every day, or 100 people every hour, for 90 years.

In addition to those killed in war, government-sponsored genocide and mass murder killed approximately 120,000,000 people in the 20th century—perhaps more than 80,000,000 in the two Communist countries of China and the Soviet Union alone, according to R. J. Rummel's Statistics of Democide.

It is ironic, then, that the 20th century also produced numerous and stunningly successful examples of nonviolent victories over injustice and oppression. The best-known campaigns are probably those led by Gandhi and Martin Luther King Jr. King's nonviolent marchers changed American history. (The fact that the police and National Guard sometimes guarded civil-rights marchers does not change the fact that King's movement was overwhelmingly nonviolent.) And Gandhi's nonviolent campaign defeated the British Empire and won India's independence. In contrast to Algeria's violent independence campaign, in which one in every 10 Algerians died, only one in every 400,000 Indians died in India's nonviolent struggle.

One of the most amazing components of Gandhi's campaign was a huge nonviolent "army" (eventually over 50,000) of Muslim Pathans in the northwestern section of India. These are the same people we now know as the Taliban in Afghanistan and along the Pakistan border! Even when the British humiliated them and slaughtered hundreds of them, they remained faithful to Gandhi's nonviolent vision.

There are other examples: In Poland, the nonviolent campaigns of Solidarity, an anti-Communist movement affiliated with the Catholic church, successfully defied and helped defeat the Soviet empire. In the Philippines, a million peaceful demonstrators overthrew the brutal dictatorship of president Ferdinand Marcos. The list of successful 20th century nonviolent campaigns is long.

Considering these successes, one wonders what might happen if the Christian world became serious about exploring the full possibilities of applying nonviolent methods of seeking peace to unjust, violent situations around the world. All Christians claim to believe Jesus when he says, "Blessed are the peacemakers, for they will be called children of God" (Matt. 5:9). But we have not made much use of one demonstrably successful way of making peace.

Recently, the Christian Peacemaker Teams (CPT), made famous by the kidnapping of four team members in Iraq in late 2005, have been working to apply the nonviolent techniques of Gandhi and King to conflict situations around the world. At Hebron in the West Bank, a few Jewish settlers live in the midst of the overwhelmingly Palestinian city of Hebron. Taunts, anger, violence, and deaths are frequent.

For 10 years, CPTers have lived in Hebron, seeking to befriend both sides, accompanying those oppressed by violence, sitting in houses threatened with illegal demolition, and walking children to school in neighborhoods where gunfire has too often struck down the wrong targets. CPT teams are defending the rights of native Canadians and Latin American peasants, as well.

The team's work made nightly news when four members were kidnapped by militants in Baghdad. Months later, three were released after the body of Tom Fox was found in the city. Last month marked the second anniversary of that kidnapping. One need not agree with all of CPT's political and theological ideas to conclude that now is the time for the entire Christian community to ask: Could we build on and vastly expand CPT's nonviolent approaches to peacemaking?





Christianity Today


  


Subscribe to Christianity Today and get 3 free trial issues. No credit card required.

Please allow 4-6 weeks for delivery. Offer valid in U.S. only.

If you decide you want to keep Christianity Today coming, honor your invoice for just $19.95 and receive nine more issues, a full year in all. If not, simply write "cancel" across the invoice and return it. The three trial issues are yours to keep, regardless.


Click here for international orders2-for-1 Gifts!

Displaying 1–5 of 28 comments

Alex

December 28, 2007  10:09am

Thank you Mr. Sider. I have been impressed with the CPT for a while now and have thought if we (as a global or local church) could only get organized to do this kind of "standing in the gap" on a massive scale, imagine the impact. Let's get this going. Keep us updated on how we can help financially or otherwise. I hope Christianity Today will help to provide a mouthpiece for such a large scale ongoing operation.

Kozak

December 27, 2007  11:30am

I see way too much naivete and historical ignorance in the CPT's. In Iraq the violence is perpetrated by Muslims who think of Christians as contemptible inferiors. Teams that think that "all people are basically the same" will get nowhere, or will be cynically used, or will be martyred. In a place like Nicaragua, stopping the guerrilla war on these grounds just ratifies the status quo, unless you also get a commitment from the leaders to pressure the government. Also, Christians may be united in opposing bloodshed, but may differ 180 degrees in their desired outcome. In Palestine some Christians want Israel to rule the entire place, others want a Palestinian state. Even if you manage to stop the fighting, what then?

ScottR

December 27, 2007  10:40am

We must also stop to consider if we are waging a "just peace". Are we using the absence of war as a masquerade for gross injustice and oppression (i.e. Salt Treaties, Hitler, North Korea, UN "sanctions")? I think Ron Sider underestimates the nature of evil and has been too strongly swayed by the peace-at-all-costs movement He also seems to overlook parts of Scripture. Ecclesiastes says it most simply: there is "a time for war and a time for peace." Exodus states clearly, "The LORD is a warrior; the LORD is his name." Also, the image in Revelation 12 of the baby slipping past the mouth of the dragon --and the ensuing battle-- is hardly a peaceful one. The Kingdom of God does not always come so peacefully -- just war can reap a harvest of wholeness and healing. Having said that, Ron Sider made me stop and think -- Do we wage war too easily? Have we learned from our mistakes? Can we better reconcilers? How do we follow a God who calls Himself both Lion of Judah and Prince of Peace?

A.Yeshuratnam

December 27, 2007  8:54am

Gandhi's movement cannot be called non-violent. The British were tolerant, and there were democratic assemblies created by them as early as 1909. More importantly, there was a vibrant democratic government functioning in England, and the opposition was always championing the cause of Indians in the British parliament. There was also a free press in India and Gandhi got lot of publicity. Even without Gandhi India would have got her independence, for after World War II Britain was giving freedom to most of her colonies. Was there a Gandhi in Malaya? Was there a Gandhi in Indonesia or Burma? Moreover, Gandhi used non-violence because he knew that violent tactics would be put down by the British government. Once India became independent, Gandhi allowed Indian troops to march into Hyderabad State to bring it under India. He also asked Nehru to send troops into Kashmir. No wonder Churchill called him a hypocrite! A.Yeshuratnam Trivandrum India.

Rev. Keith Dendy

December 25, 2007  5:37pm

I was disappointed as I read Ron Sider's "Courageous Nonviolence;" surely he is not so naive as to think that pacifism is an EFFECTIVE counter-measure to Islamic extremists who are sworn to the goal of destroying all "infidels"---i.e., everyone who is not Islamic!

You must be a Christianity Today subscriber or have created a FREE registration to post comments
[Browse More Christianity Today]



War and Peace

War and Peace

Pastor Tullian Tchividjian survived a leadership coup by finding rest in the liberating power of the gospel.

Facing Fears

Facing Fears

Max Lucado employs preaching to overcome fear.

more | current issue

Christian Bible Studies

Unbalanced Blessings

Unbalanced Blessings

The balancing act of...

Books & Culture

Quiet

Quiet

Shhh! Introverts working...

Preaching Today

NFL Star Junior Seau Searched for Peace

Small Groups

Prepare with Prayer

Prepare with Prayer

Don't leave out this...

Search
Search
Search
Scripture Search
Go Deeper