Subscribe to Christianity Today
Subscribe to Christianity Today
Donate to Christianity Today
login | my account
February 12, 2012

Home > 2008 > MarchChristianity Today, March, 2008
Church in State
In post-Communist Germany, Christian political involvement is surging.




Last November I spent a week in Germany courtesy of the Konrad Adenauer Institute, a foundation named after the first chancellor of West Germany. Adenauer had the unenviable job of restoring government to a demoralized land in which every large city had been bombed to rubble. He founded the Christian Democratic Union political party and, with the help of U.S. largesse in the Marshall Plan, led Germany into a new era.

This party's very name shows a major difference in European and American approaches to religion and politics. Whereas the U.S. insists on a strict separation of church and state, the monarch of Britain holds the title "Supreme Governor of the Church of England," Polish priests openly campaign for like-minded politicians, and many European governments subsidize church activities, including the teaching of religion in public schools. On the day Nicolae Ceausescu was executed in Romania, ending 45 years of Communist rule, the state television station led with the pronouncement, "Today the Antichrist died and Jesus Christ was reborn in Romania!" To European eyes, our controversies over Christmas crèches and the Ten Commandments in public places seem strange indeed.

Yet in the last 50 years, almost all European countries have seen a precipitous decline in church attendance and religious belief. When Harris pollsters asked, "Do you believe in any form of God or supreme being?" only 27 percent of French and 35 percent of British respondents said yes; the others counted themselves atheist, agnostic, or unsure.

Germany offers an interesting case study. Although only 41 percent of adults claim to believe in God, a majority of Germans still formally belong to a church, though few attend. Church affiliation in Germany matters, if for no other reason than it adds an extra 8 percent or so to your income tax bill. In other words, if you declare yourself an unbeliever, you save significant money. The government distributes the "church tax," more than $10 billion annually, to approved denominations for their work in schools, hospitals, and general church upkeep.

Now churches are seeing an alarming decline in their income stream. Every year some 300,000 Germans remove their names from church rolls, with the number of Protestants declining by half since World War II. In one meeting I attended, the bishop of Saxony—the region where Martin Luther posted his 95 theses and Bach wrote his cantatas—calmly reported that of 4.5 million citizens, only 850,000 had affiliated with a church. He expected that number to decline to 350,000 by 2015 and perhaps dip as low as 30,000 by 2030. After four decades under Communist rule, citizens of the East feel no civic pressure to keep traditional ties with a church. The bishop faces a discouraging task: cutting pastors' salaries, eliminating hospital chaplains, and shuttering churches and schools.

In the same meeting, a lively pastor showed a far more upbeat spirit. First he recounted personal stories of the difficulties that Christians faced under Communist rule. His children had limited educational opportunities, and he had to work as a plumber to supplement his meager pastor's salary. Everything changed "after the wall came down" (a phrase I often heard).

Although less than 20 percent of Saxony's citizens may belong to a church, he estimated that 70 percent of those in Parliament are active, practicing Christians. Having lived under Communism, Christians quickly volunteered to step into a cultural vacuum of meaning and help the newly free society lay a foundation for moral and legal structure. They realized all too personally what can happen when Christians are excluded from the public square.





Christianity Today


  


Subscribe to Christianity Today and get 3 free trial issues. No credit card required.

Please allow 4-6 weeks for delivery. Offer valid in U.S. only.

If you decide you want to keep Christianity Today coming, honor your invoice for just $19.95 and receive nine more issues, a full year in all. If not, simply write "cancel" across the invoice and return it. The three trial issues are yours to keep, regardless.


Click here for international orders2-for-1 Gifts!

Displaying 1–5 of 13 comments

Steve

March 12, 2008  9:26pm

This article is way too simplistic. I expected the author to present something with much more thoughts and insights - after all,he is the favorite of my son who read almost all of Yancey. Separation of church and state is not the real problem. The real issue is this: for what purpose does the church work with or without the state? So called state churches can do an excellent job working for the best interest of people (education, health care, law making etc...) the 8% "church tax" can establish a feeling of togetherness and keep the level of solidarity high in a country, whereas independent churches can do horrible-horrible things (see the Christian Right in the US) no matter how far they are separated from the state - in principle... This article could have argued for or against Christians' responsibility in a world where billions live under their potential due to exploitation supported by their own political leaders under the watch of their own spiritual and/or church leaders.

Joseph

March 12, 2008  8:25pm

The origins of the celebration of any holiday is much like etymology, interesting, but not necessarily relevant. Christmas and easter are not pagan holidays. The fact that there were corresponding pagan holidays on similar dates to Christmas and easter is interesting... but not a very convincing point for one who wants to argue that two Christian holidays celebrating events from the earthly life of our Lord and savior, are in fact pagan. They are not pagan holidays.

T P

March 11, 2008  3:21pm

Yancey is misleading in a number of areas. 1st: Germany was not Communist. It was Fascist and a form of Socialism in competition with Italy's form. Russia is Communist. China is Communist. 2nd: Having a Catholic foreign exchange student from Germany, the reason "Church affiliation in Germany matters," is because if they aren't, then they are not allowed to bury their dead in Catholic sanctioned cemetaries. 3rd: Christmas is a pagan holiday as is Easter. Anyone willing to put the effort into research will learn that. Celebrate giving, but put away lying. 4th: The gov distributes the "church tax"...to *approved* denominations for their work in schools, hospitals [another gov. socialist welfare program] and church upkeep. 5th: In opposition to Yancey's "our mission"--Christ gave His [com]mission for the church to PREACH the gospel and tell what the woman did. Government is by nature an enemy of the church & faith. Christians have become lazy & want salvation without responsiblity.

chuch

March 11, 2008  10:13am

I think that this in not possible in our country. almos 200 year behind Benito Juarez the Mexican President (1860) made the division between the church and the state. it will be a chaos, usually the peoples try to use the church seeking a personal benefit. great that Germany can do. we have a official church. church that has recognaized receive money from the narcotrafic, but the church has said no problem with this, because the money to enter to the church is holy. can you believe this?

Andrew

March 10, 2008  11:48pm

There is a difference between 1) keeping organized religion separate from control over activities of the state and 2) having Christians, Muslims, Jews, Mormons, or atheists, for that matter, be "public servants." In positions of political power, persons of faith have the right to bring their worldviews to bear on their decisions. But whenever the church and the state have gotten in bed with each other the bastard offspring of bad theocratic policies have caused the people to suffer and have hurt the gospel. Why can't we let the state be the state and the church be the church? This way, they can keep an eye on each other and each challenge the other to live up to its stated principles. In other words, rather than trying to take over the state, the church can "mix religion and politics" by speaking up in service not to itself but to the common good. The so-called Christian Right, hell-bent on theocracy has shown us recently how fragile the separation of Church and State really is.

You must be a Christianity Today subscriber or have created a FREE registration to post comments
[Browse More Christianity Today]



Search
Search
Search
Scripture Search
Go Deeper

Books & Culture
Christianity Today
Church Law & Tax Report
Church Finance Today
Leadership Journal
Men of Integrity
Kyria.com
ChristianityTodayLibrary.com
PreachingToday.com