Subscribe to Christianity Today
Subscribe to Christianity Today
Donate to Christianity Today
login | my account
February 10, 2012

Home > 2008 > October (Web-only)Christianity Today, October (Web-only), 2008
SPEAKING OUT
The Engine of the Market
It's not capital. Why wealthy evangelicals and others need to reconsider executive compensation.




American evangelicals are becoming a wealthy lot. This has created opportunities for the wider evangelical world. Rich evangelicals have deployed their financial resources to establish new ministries, expand opportunities for young leaders, and develop initiatives around the world.

But didn't Jesus talk about it being easier for a camel to pass through the eye of a needle than for a rich man to enter the kingdom of God? The rich young ruler went away sorrowful in the Gospel of Luke. Money, in and of itself, was not the problem. It was the love of money that tripped him up. He may have been generous, but he wasn't willing to sell everything. I can hardly blame him.

But as the nation's economy continues to spiral downward, we have to consider how the greed of an individual or a group of people affects the structure of our economy. Americans are growing angry over the "golden parachutes" that protect business executives even if their companies fail. After serving eighteen days as the chief executive of Washington Mutual before the bank collapsed on September 26, Alan Fishman stands to receive a $19 million severance package. That is the equivalent of $1.12 million for each day he led the company—a company that subsequently imploded, no less. Analysts tell us that curbing excessive compensation packages for executives will not dramatically change the current financial outlook for the United States. Perhaps that is so, but the nation needs business leaders they can trust. The engine of the free market is not so much capital as it is trust.

The dark side of wealth

Evangelical executives frame their business life as a moral activity. But what happens when they enjoy lavish compensation packages even as workers are called upon to tighten their belts? In 2004, John Tyson was serving as CEO of Tyson Foods, one of the 100 largest companies in the United States. The company experienced a financial downturn and decided to shore up money by demanding wage cuts from line workers. At that same time, Tyson's annual compensation grew by leaps and bounds—upwards of $20 million. Eric Schlosser, writing for the Nation, summarized the feeling of many critics: "During an interview … Tyson outlined his personal theory of labor management, … [citing the importance of] a moral anchor. Tyson said, 'You have to serve the people that work for you … and in effect become a servant to the people that work for you.' He said it with a straight face."

There are some evangelical business leaders who eschew the accoutrements of an executive lifestyle. Ralph Larsen, the onetime chief executive of Johnson & Johnson, and his wife made a conscious decision to live significantly beneath their means. That meant that they did not move to a bigger house or a better neighborhood even as Larsen rose up through the company ranks. They gave away vast sums of their annual income. Evangelicals in Silicon Valley and in other places around the country have made similar decisions. Joel Manby, who once ran Saab USA, told me, "We could afford a second home, [but] with all these people … homeless, I just don't feel right about that … .I'd rather do Habitat for Humanity where I'm building second homes [rather] than living in one."

The current cultural moment is unique for evangelicals. There have always been a few of them who had great wealth. J. Howard Pew, for example, was an extraordinarily wealthy industrialist in the first half of the twentieth century. With his support, evangelical initiatives such as Christianity Today were established and grew. A century earlier, Arthur and Lewis Tappan funded Charles Finney's ministry during the Second Great Awakening, as had John Wanamaker supported A.T. Pierson, the popular Presbyterian pastor and evangelical leader.





Christianity Today


  


Subscribe to Christianity Today and get 3 free trial issues. No credit card required.

Please allow 4-6 weeks for delivery. Offer valid in U.S. only.

If you decide you want to keep Christianity Today coming, honor your invoice for just $19.95 and receive nine more issues, a full year in all. If not, simply write "cancel" across the invoice and return it. The three trial issues are yours to keep, regardless.


Click here for international orders2-for-1 Gifts!

Displaying 1–5 of 22 comments

homebuilding

October 11, 2008  1:42pm

EXCESSIVE GREED EXCESSIVE PAY EXCESSIVE ADVERTISING EXCESSIVE "FOLLOWING THE WAYS OF THE WORLD" I taught my kids to boycott products and services of companies that overpaid their executives, created phony "needs" in their advertising, and perpetually seek to minimize employee compensation and benefits I try to live this way myself Please provide me with any meaningful justification for the fancy pay and fancy lifestyles--anywhere.

beer christianity

October 08, 2008  2:31am

When you consider paid golf vacations as "thank you gifts," housing stipends, and using increased congregational giving as justification for higher salaries, perhaps the executives that should take the lead in "[eschewing] the accoutrements of an executive lifestyle" are those who chose the life of pastors and ministers. If one's humble vocational choice happens to lead to employment at a mega-church, should she or he refuse the high salary and insist on getting paid what the pastor of a 30-person home church pulls down every year? If we have extra money in our congregation, and people in our city who are homeless and Christ-less, what does that say about how we value wealth? A whole lot.

H. D. Schmidt

October 05, 2008  11:17am

However excellent this article is; it is in essence referring to basically only one very tiny symptom, of what really is in reality what now is an absolute mortal morally condition of America, the nation under God and claims to trust God, as Christians of every persuasion, for many decades just stood by and actually supported politicians in Washington, many even becoming politicians, and little by little making America into the most abusive and far-reaching Empire the world has ever known. I challenge anyone to prove me wrong, basing the rebutall and the legacy of the Founding Fathers? Yes, as also America all along evermore falling in love with Socialism/Communism. period. Just to refresh the memory of some who can still remember Krushchev in the 60's at the UN while pounding his shoe on his desk amongst many thing he said thIs: "Americans will accept Communism and not know it". Yes, America's war machinery all over the world, while internally melting economically as a piece of ice!

Michele M.

October 05, 2008  8:58am

Who are you responding to Pastor Don? Did I miss an article? Don't get me wrong - it looks like we agree on this overall issue, but I was wondering who "Jay" was?

Doug B

October 04, 2008  3:11pm

As believers we have to lead in everything, especially in this current climate of ridicule from the media (i.e. - scoffing of Sarah Palin's faith and Bill Maher's new documentary). When we "walk the walk" we make room for people to trust and inquire. When we say one thing and do another, all of our credibility is damaged. This holds true for the pulpit, the boardroom, the living room and even the hall of Congress and the White House. It must begin with me, but not end there. On "Caveat Bettor": Yes, you bring up all kinds of inequities in our society, business is the current hot topic, but we could expand it to sports, media, et. al. I do believe that your shots at Charles Swindoll and Rick Warren are mis-informed at best and a bit caustic. Please do research on their giving and philanthropy before making them examples of a misplaced ethic.

You must be a Christianity Today subscriber or have created a FREE registration to post comments
[Browse More Christianity Today]



Search
Search
Search
Scripture Search
Go Deeper

Books & Culture
Christianity Today
Church Law & Tax Report
Church Finance Today
Leadership Journal
Men of Integrity
Kyria.com
ChristianityTodayLibrary.com
PreachingToday.com