Subscribe to Christianity Today
Subscribe to Christianity Today
Donate to Christianity Today
login | my account
February 23, 2012

Home > 2011 > August (Web-only)Christianity Today, August (Web-only), 2011
SoulWork
Trusting God with the Ones You Love
Few things are harder or scarier than trusting God to do what is just and right and good.




Questions regarding God's justice will be with us always—at least until the kingdom comes. A current example: Since Love Wins brought it up, we are pondering the fate of those who have never heard of Jesus. The New Testament clearly teaches that we can appropriate the forgiveness wrought for us on the cross only by trusting in Christ. But of course, those who haven't heard of Christ cannot do that. So how will God judge them?

In my book, God Wins, I argue that when it comes to such questions—questions the Bible does not answer—our only recourse is to trust in the God who has shown himself to be perfectly merciful and perfectly just in Jesus Christ. We are called to trust that this God will do what is just, right, and good.

This answer has seemed too easy to some. One reviewer of my book referred to this type of answer as "punting"—by which he inferred that it was an easy way out of theological dilemma.

In one sense, the criticism is just, because in the book I did not signal what an extraordinary thing such faith is. I may have given the impression that this sort of faith is an easy out, a comforting escape, a way to avoid tension and ambiguity. It is anything but that.

To me, the easy way out of such dilemmas is to foreclose the tension. For some Christians today, that means positing a loving God who would never in a millennium condemn such people to hell in such an arbitrary fashion. Others say that people who have never heard the gospel will be judged by their good works, or by the lights of their religion. Some speculate that upon their death, such people will be given knowledge of Jesus and will be able to make a decision for Christ right then and there.

The problem with each "solution" is that each is a sheer fabrication. The Bible—what we take to be God's revelation of himself and his will—says little or nothing about the fate of those who have never heard the name of Jesus. But we continue to trust in such solutions because, well, they relieve the tension. To me, they are different ways of "punting," taking the easy way out.

The hard way, the narrow way, the way that demands more than human beings can do on their own, is to trust God to do what is right and just and good.

We can see this more clearly when we bring the issue of God's justice closer to home. You have a brother or sister, son or daughter, mother or father, husband or wife, or best friend who simply refuses to believe in the gospel. But their reasons are complex. Maybe they were abused by a pastor in their youth. Maybe they were raised in a church that was oppressively legalistic. Maybe they have faced tragedy after tragedy. The point is, you understand why they refuse to trust in Christ—everything in their life suggests that the Christian faith is absurd. And yet in many ways, this loved one lives more like a Christian than do a lot of people in your church. They make lifestyle changes to preserve the environment. They volunteer at the homeless shelter. They never judge other people. They are the nicest people to be around. And so forth.

There's the tension: What is God going to do with such people, people who literally have failed to trust in Christ but whose circumstances suggest they may now be psychologically incapable of even hearing the gospel?

Some revert to the letter of the gospel law: Since these people have heard the literal words of the gospel and refused to name the Name, they are destined for hell. Tension eliminated.





Christianity Today


  


Subscribe to Christianity Today and get 3 free trial issues. No credit card required.

Please allow 4-6 weeks for delivery. Offer valid in U.S. only.

If you decide you want to keep Christianity Today coming, honor your invoice for just $19.95 and receive nine more issues, a full year in all. If not, simply write "cancel" across the invoice and return it. The three trial issues are yours to keep, regardless.


Click here for international orders2-for-1 Gifts!

Displaying 1–5 of 31 comments

Chris Hearn

August 30, 2011  8:40am

Can one consciously reject the Gospel and still go to Heaven? Some problems with this view: 1. This creates a new category of "faith" which is neither biblical nor necessary. Scripture does not teach that one can reject God, yet still go to Heaven. It is unnecessary because people are raised in legalistic churches and still come to true faith in Christ. People are abused in church or raised in cults or other religions and still come to faith in Christ. 2. It creates a second "gospel," one of works. It says that if one is so psychologically damaged so that he or she can't believe, then that's okay. Their good works may indeed save. 3. Where does it end? If abuse by ones pastor is good enough, what else fits? Poverty? Being incarcerated? Loss of a parent? Illness? Where are you going to draw the line? 4. What happens to someone who rejects Christ, because he or she is so psychologically damaged, but then turns to a different religion? Will such a person still go to Heaven?

Joseph Green

August 24, 2011  7:48pm

Someone once asked Billy Graham how a loving God would condemm those who never heard of Christ. I do not remember his exact reply, but it went someting like this " There is a small quiet voice that will teach us if we are willing to listen to it. That voice is the Holy Spirit. Did God himself not declare that to Job. I believe those that never heard of Christ are given a chance by listening to that small quiet voice. Those that refuse, do so because they do not want God to rule in their lives but live according to their own wisdom

Mark H

August 24, 2011  6:29pm

as I see it there are two types of lost peoples in the world, those who have never heard the Gospel, in any shape or form and those who may have heard of it but rejected it quite probably because of the reasons you give, For the 1st group the bible says that they are without excuse because the invisible things of God are plainly seen in creation itself so that if they would so much as question the creator of the universe He would answer and reveal Himself and his Salvation, even if He had to send a missionary super naturally to that one person, it has been said that things similar to that have happened although those reports are not substantiated. AS for the other group, Our best bet is to pray for the tilling of their hearts and that the good seed sown will choke out the tares. And holding to Gods word and promises that that word which came from him will not return void but will accomplish the thing where unto he sent it.

Chuck V.

August 23, 2011  1:26pm

"God is perfectly just and perfectly merciful, and this we must proclaim right in the midst of the most awful circumstances and in the face of the most mysterious questions." Excellent words Mark Galli. As I see it our problem is that we insist on answering questions that likely do not have an answer this side of glory. Yes, we can and should trust in God, his justice, and his mercy, especially in those realms of mystery that we cannot authoritatively answer. If we cannot "punt" in this way then I submit that we have a bigger problem - a problem with God.

Rob Conrad

August 23, 2011  10:07am

From 8am April 27, 2011 to 8am April 28, 2011, 211 tornadoes hit the southeast leaving 334 people dead. The evening of April 27, my son and I were camping in the Smoky Mtn backcountry when an EF4 tracked about 1.5 miles from our site. I suffered a broken leg on our hike out. I have thought often about God's mercy shown to us. If the storm had come a little south that night, we'd be dead. Video of the damage to the park can be seen here: www.youtube.com/watch?v=PlnGMxBGk6I He chose to spare us but not many others. So, while I grieve for those who lost precious friends and family in these storms, I choose to be grateful to this merciful God. Out of gratitude, I choose to live more fully for Him and less for myself. And each day, I fail to do that. God, guide and strengthen me to respond to your mercy with love and mercy toward all!

You must be a Christianity Today subscriber or have created a FREE registration to post comments
[Browse More Christianity Today]

Rod and Reel, or Net?

Rod and Reel, or Net?

What it means to catch in community.

A 'Move' in the Right Direction

A 'Move' in the Right Direction

A new book takes a closer look at how churches foster spiritual growth.

more | current issue

Kyria

I Gave Up Worry for ...

Consider taking 40 days to give up a deep...

Books & Culture

Coming to Terms with Our Inheritance

Coming to Terms with...

Slaveholders, segregationists, all of us...

Small Group Dynamics

Recognizing a Blind ...

Learning from the introverts among us

Building Church Leaders

Coaching the Full Life

Coaching the Full Life...

Use the principles of coaching to lead people...

Managing Your Church Blog

Congress Extends Payroll...

Churches must verify employee withholdings...

Search
Search
Search
Scripture Search
Go Deeper