Subscribe to Christianity Today
Subscribe to Christianity Today
Donate to Christianity Today
login | my account
February 23, 2012

Home > Movies > Commentaries > 2012
The Most Redeeming Films of 2011
Quiet, contemplative movies top the list. So put the popcorn down and pay close attention.




Stop, look, and listen.

That could be the motto for Christianity Today's list of the Most Redeeming Films of 2011. A number of them, including No. 1 Of Gods and Men, are slower-moving, contemplative movies, films that ask you to put the popcorn aside, pay close attention, engage your heart, soul, and mind, and invest in the movie. In other words, everything Transformers 3 would never ask you to do.

Of Gods and Men, an inside look at life in a monastery, will force you to ask yourself, "What would I do in their shoes?" The Tree of Life is, on a macro level an artistic meditation on, well, life itself (and the afterlife), and on a micro level, on the thin line between family devotion and family dysfunction. Win Win also explores family dynamics, love, loyalty, and difficult ethical issues that any of us could face in a down economy. The Way is an introspective examination of a man's heart and soul in the wake of terrible tragedy, as he literally takes a long journey to find himself—and, in a sense, his son.

Hugo will not only make you fall in love with the beauty of Paris, but its music, its food, and its people, but also with old movies themselves. Oh, and it includes arguably the year's best reflection on what it means to be in community and/or the body of Christ—by using a metaphor for the human race as a machine with no missing parts, and how each of us, as an individual part, was created for a specific purpose … and this from Martin Scorcese, no less! But, as is the case with a number of these films, such insights only exist for those who have ears to hear and eyes to see. Great filmmakers won't bash you over the head with a Message You Need to Hear; the best auteurs let the story do the talking, and you, the viewer, may need to peel back a layer—or three or four—to see what's beneath. That's exciting.

As we do annually, we first roll out our Most Redeeming list—simply the year's best movies that include stories of redemption. Several feature characters who are redeemers themselves; all have characters who experience redemption to some degree. Some are feel-good flicks; others, less so. Several of the films are rated R and PG-13 and are not intended for young viewers, so please use discretion. But in all of these films, redemption itself is one of the main characters or plot points.

Posting next Wednesday (January 25): Our Critics' Choice list.


1. Of Gods and Men

Directed by Xavier Beauvois
(Sony Pictures Classics) | Rated PG-13


2. The Tree of Life

Directed by Terrence Malick
(Fox Searchlight) | Rated PG-13


3. Win Win

Directed by Thomas McCarthy
(Fox Searchlight) | Rated R


4. The Way

Directed by Emilio Estevez
(Arc Entertainment) | Rated PG-13


5. Hugo

Directed by Martin Scorsese
(Paramount Pictures) | Rated PG


6. Harry Potter & the Deathly Hallows, Part II

Directed by David Yates
(Warner Brothers) | Rated PG-13


7. Soul Surfer

Directed by Sean McNamara
(TriStar Pictures) |Rated PG


8. The Mill & the Cross

Directed by Lech Majewski
(Kino Lorber) | Not rated


9. War Horse

Directed by Steven Spielberg
(Touchstone Pictures) | Rated PG-13


10. Courageous

Directed by Alex Kendrick
(Lionsgate) | Rated PG-13


Honorable mention (in alphabetical order):

The Help, Machine Gun Preacher, The Muppets, Super 8, Warrior, Winnie the Pooh.




Christianity Today


  


Subscribe to Christianity Today and get 3 free trial issues. No credit card required.

Please allow 4-6 weeks for delivery. Offer valid in U.S. only.

If you decide you want to keep Christianity Today coming, honor your invoice for just $19.95 and receive nine more issues, a full year in all. If not, simply write "cancel" across the invoice and return it. The three trial issues are yours to keep, regardless.


Click here for international orders2-for-1 Gifts!
[Reader Reviews]

Displaying 1–3 of 20 comments

Paula

January 26, 2012  9:21am

If u had watched harry potter dh pt 2 you would have def saw the correlation to being reborn and how good character over comes demonic powers. Just curious all you hp bashers that say good magic is theme... What about cs lewis magic themes? What about lord of the rings trilogy? That was all about good magic and bad magic? Just wondering? Harry potter is personally a choice and u can choose to watch it and teach ur kids about concepts from it. We teach them magic is not real but there are truths in these stories that we can learn from. All my kids have seen all the Harry Potter movies and i have yet to see them try spells or question their faith because of it.

Report Abuse

Sharon Espino

January 26, 2012  8:31am

@Daryl- The quote you say that JK Rowling made is urban legend. If it is true, show me the quote. And not from Wikipedia. As a Christian, I let my two children read and see the Harry Potter movies. Yes, there is witchcraft, but I also let them watch the Wizard of Oz, Star Wars, about every Disney movie i.e. Snow White, Sleeping Beauty, Beauty and the Beast, but you get my point. HP is the tale of good and evil. And good wins. As it does in Wizard of Oz, Star Wars, and Disney movies. If it not your choice, that is fine, but to judge others who are not convicted as you are is as great a sin as you say the writers/editors of this article have committed. My question, have you read the books at all or only listened to the 'experts' pontificate on them? And neither of my children have any interest in the occult. Both are still active church goers. You might not like the books, but that does not mean that those who do are any less Christian than you set yourself up to be

Report Abuse

Daryl Borgquist

January 25, 2012  3:34pm

It is surprising that you have Harry Potter on your list. The underlying theme is that there is good witchcraft and it has positive value. The author's intention in writing the Harry Potter series, as stated in interviews she has given, was to initiate a new generation to the occult. This runs counter to the Christian message of Jesus' redemptive message the new life that we have in Christ. That is not the message of Harry Potter. You missed by a lot here. That your critics considered it at all and that you did not prevent it before publication is significant and causes pause about what you include as Christian.

Report Abuse

Comment on this article *

1000 character limit

* Comments may be edited for tone and clarity.

[Browse More Christianity Today]

An Ontological Pep-Talk

An Ontological Pep-Talk

Switchfoot's "Vice Verses"

Random Reality, Part 4

Random Reality, Part 4

God rolls the dice.

more | current issue

Kyria

I Gave Up Worry for ...

Consider taking 40 days to give up a deep...

Books & Culture

Coming to Terms with Our Inheritance

Coming to Terms with...

Slaveholders, segregationists, all of us...

Small Group Dynamics

Recognizing a Blind ...

Learning from the introverts among us

Building Church Leaders

Coaching the Full Life

Coaching the Full Life...

Use the principles of coaching to lead people...

Managing Your Church Blog

Congress Extends Payroll...

Churches must verify employee withholdings...

Search
Search




Search
Scripture Search
Go Deeper