Jump directly to the content
Born This Way? The Moral Universe of 'Glee'

Born This Way? The Moral Universe of 'Glee'


May 23 2012
Last night's season finale underscores how the show is just as preachy as 'Christian films.'

Growing up, our weekly family movie nights always starred the same nimble-footed, velvety-voiced stars—Gene Kelly, Fred Astaire, Ginger Rogers, Bing Crosby, Rosemary Clooney—and the musical genre danced its way straight into my heart. So it's no surprise that when the musical television show Glee premiered on Fox three years ago, I was instantly hooked.

Created by Ryan Murphy, the show sought to capitalize on the success of American Idol and Disney's High School Musical series, but it was also unlike anything else on prime-time television. The postmodern musical has followed the misfit members of McKinley High Glee Club through the travails of high school and their attempts to win at show-choir nationals. Last night, in the season finale, several of the show's biggest stars graduated.

Initially, the show was wildly popular, winning Emmys and Golden Globes (and even some coverage on Her.meneutics). Despite uneven writing, overdrawn caricatures, and ridiculously soapy situations, it had heart, not to mention the vocal talents of Broadway star Lea Michele (Rachel) and Chris Colfer (Kurt). I'd be lying if I said I had never teared up while watching.

But this season, Glee morphed from quirky, guilty-pleasure entertainment to a preachy, poorly patched-together morality play. Like a weekly after-school special, Glee took on one social "issue" after another: public funding for the arts, bullying, texting and driving, domestic violence, and, several times over, sexual identity. A failure of creativity and imagination in the writing turned Glee into a series of PSAs for teens, programs every bit as reductively moralistic in their own way as "Christian" movies like Fireproof and Facing the Giants—while taking far less heat from the critics for it.

It's not that I don't agree with some of Glee's lessons. Bullying is despicable and discrimination is wrong; it's not okay to stay in an abusive relationship, and the arts enrich our lives. (I admit that I have texted while driving, but I'm trying to change.) Sadly, Glee's simplistic way of addressing these issues diminishes them, and often misses the richer stories that could be told.

if Ryan Murphy is an evangelist, his moral universe has one guiding principle: tolerance. We were born this way, he preaches, and we should accept ourselves and others as we are.

But the Christian story tells us that we are born broken, and that we need to be transformed; that we must put off the old self, and be made new. I believe this to be true; but beyond that, I believe it to be a better story, every time, than a story about a person who learns to accept herself the way she is.

Related Topics:Media; Television
From: May 2012
Support our work. Subscribe to CT and get one year free.

Comments

To add a comment you need to be a registered user or Christianity Today subscriber.

orSubscribeor
More from Her.menutics
The Universal Call to ‘Mothering Like Christ’

The Universal Call to ‘Mothering Like Christ’

Childbirth illustrates the life-giving sacrifice of body, mind, and soul that applies to us all.
Don’t Call Me the Best Mom Ever

Don’t Call Me the Best Mom Ever

Why it's time for Mother's Day to retreat from the extremes.
I Forgave My Teen Daughter’s Killer

I Forgave My Teen Daughter’s Killer

The gospel taught me that forgiveness is not a pardon.
Why We Want to Return to Stars Hollow

Why We Want to Return to Stars Hollow

The weirdest part of the Gilmore Girls hometown? How they did community right.
Include results from Christianity Today
Browse Archives:

So Hot Right Now

My Son’s Autism Changed Everything—Even Our Church

I came to see special needs families as an unreached people group.

Twitter

  • The experience of labor and mothering, in their reflection of the incarnation, reflect a life we're all called to https://t.co/LkbJyaavGp
  • In honor of the #NationalDayofPrayer: Why you shouldn't settle for just praying alone https://t.co/Ib8g7gJ1q2
  • Around Mother's Day, some people say we are all "like mothers." Is that really true? https://t.co/LkbJyaavGp
  • RT @BarnabasPiper: Fellas (especially pastors) - Stop Calling Your Wife Hot https://t.co/yABUGW7cJc
  • RT @leigh_powers: Challenging and thought provoking: I Forgave My Teen Daughter2019s Killer @CT_women https://t.co/ItcUpYnSVg


What We're Reading

CT eBooks and Bible Studies

Christianity Today
Born This Way? The Moral Universe of 'Glee'