Biotech: Pro-lifers Resist Embryo Research

American pro-life groups, often associated with anti-abortion protests and crisis-pregnancy counseling, are intensifying their campaign against the use of human embryos in medical research.

In January, the Clinton administration began to form guidelines for federal funding of medical research that uses cells from discarded human embryos. The supply of excess embryos mostly comes from fertility clinics. In such research, the embryo is dissected and its stem cells cultivated. Stem cells develop into many varieties of human tissue. They are a critical component in the emerging field of regenerative medicine, which aims to use human cells to repair bone and tissue.

In 1995, Congress banned any re search on human embryos, but scientists tapped private funds for research using aborted fetuses or with embryos donated by parents. Under proposed new guidelines, federal funds could be used to finance research on stem cells. Yet the federal money could not pay for isolating and developing the embryonic stem cells, which currently requires destroying a human embryo. Opponents strongly object to such guidelines, saying they evade the congressional ban on embryo research and that the proposed research depends on destroying human life.

REGENERATIVE MEDICINE: The goal for stem-cell research is to develop specialized cells, which could be transplanted into patients. For example, people with Parkinson’s disease have lost cells that produce dopamine, needed for normal functioning of the central nervous system. Future treatments may include restoring dopamine-producing cells to Parkinson’s patients.

In a major medical breakthrough, a researcher at the University of Wisconsin last November announced that he had isolated a line of stem cells using human embryos from the hospital fertility clinic. Although public money did not figure in the Wisconsin research, the matter sparked a congressional subcommittee hearing in December about whether the 1995 ban on public financing of research using live human embryos should be dropped.

Pro-life advocacy groups such as the National Right to Life Committee op pose the use of live human embryos in research. The pro-life organizations are not opposed to the possibility of stem-cell research. But they urge re searchers to use stem cells obtained from umbilical cords or adults. Researchers are making progress in isolating stem-cells from adults, but it is proving to be difficult and costly.

NO LEGAL STANDING: In the United States, embryos kept alive outside the uterus have no independent legal status, and thus their fate remains in limbo.

But Nigel Cameron, professor of theology and culture and senior vice president at Trinity Evangelical Divinity School in Deerfield, Illinois, is skeptical of widely publicized claims that embryonic stem cell research must be allowed because it may generate cures for cancer, Alzheimer’s disease, or Parkinson’s disease. The research “can go in ten different directions or nowhere,” he says.

Cameron is also concerned that the researchers will push the envelope by keeping the embryos alive and growing as long as possible for additional experimentation. “Plainly, once it is possible to maintain embryos in vitro for longer periods, there will of course be immense scientific interest in doing so because of the research possibilities.”

The debate over research using embryonic stem cells is heavily influenced by the politics of abortion.

The logic of the 1973 Roe v. Wade ruling by the U.S. Supreme Court means that many advocacy groups oppose protection for embryos outside the womb in principle, in case it impacts the right to abortion.

In most of Europe, by contrast, embryos outside the womb are not viewed as persons. But the Council of Europe’s bio ethics treaty protects embryos from nonbeneficial research.

BIOTECH REVOLUTION: Efforts to restrain research on human embryos faces not only the abortion-rights lobby, but also the biotech industry and health charities that hope stem-cell research will lead to historic advances against crippling diseases.

Jeremy Rifkin, in his book The Biotech Century: Harnessing the Gene and Remaking the World (Putnam Publishing, 1998), predicts that scientific advances in human biology will force liberals and conservatives to rethink their positions on long-standing quarrels. Rifkin believes their common enemy will be a commercial eugenics industry in which both parents and society aim to weed out unhealthy or unwanted genes from humanity.

In 1995, Rifkin mobilized a broad array of liberal and conservative religious leaders to oppose corporate patents on life forms. The coalition was unsuccessful because the biotech lobby proved stronger and won the right to patent life, creating the possibility of patenting as well as manipulating human cellular tissue.

In the United States, legal protection against being patented begins at “birth,” which would be precluded for human entities kept alive outside the womb.

Richard Land, president of the Southern Baptist Convention’s Ethics and Religious Liberty Commission, commented recently on the issue. “Human cells, tissues, and organs should not be commodities to be bought and sold in a biotech slave market,” Land said. “Some researchers have established in their own minds an arbitrary lesser moral status for human beings in their embryonic stage of development.”

The Clinton administration’s draft guidelines are meeting some resistance in Congress with 57 representatives going on record against them.

Copyright © 1999 Christianity Today. Click for reprint information.

Also in this issue

Gambling Away the Golden Years: Casinos are seducing an alarming number of seniors. Where is the church?

Cover Story

Gambling Away the Golden Years

Exotic Dancers Find Escape Route

The Church's Mr. Manners

Born-again Stories

Does Kosovo Pass the Just-War Test?

Dental Miracle Reports Draw Criticism

Tattoos No Longer Taboo?

Two Held in O'Hair Case

Nation's Last Leprosarium Closes

Food Banks Face Shortfalls

Celebration of Traditions

In Brief: May 24, 1999

Expatriate Congregations Thrive

Multinational Focus Spurs Church Growth

Global Death Rates May Skyrocket

Missionaries or Mercenaries?

In Brief: May 24, 1999

Ancient Church Discovered in Gaza

Materialism, Heresy Plague Churches

Exit Strategy

Letters

Firebombs Threaten Messianic Jews

Disney Ditches Dogma

Firebombs Bolster Prayers Among Messianic Believers

Editorial

Church Discipline on Trial

Editorial

Compassion Doesn’t Choose Sides

No Luck With the Churches

Surprised by Death

How Abortion Became a Necessary Evil

Re-Imagining Women

Is Lying Always Wrong?

Men Need Church, Too

Classic & Contemporary Excerpts from May 24, 1999

Where No Ministry Has Gone Before

The Art of Being Christian

View issue

Our Latest

Ethics Aren’t Graded on a Curve

President Joe Biden’s pardon of Hunter Biden was wrong, and no amount of bad behavior from Donald Trump changes that fact.

News

UK Christians Lament Landmark Vote to Legalize Assisted Dying 

Pro-life faith leaders say Parliament’s proposed bill fails to protect the vulnerable and fear it will “create more suffering and chaos.”

Strike Up the Band: Sixpence None the Richer Goes Back on Tour

With its perennial hit “Kiss Me” still in our ears and on our playlists, the Christian band reunites with nothing to prove.

Christianity Today’s Book of the Year

Two volumes rose to the head of the class.

The Christianity Today Book Awards

Our picks for the books most likely to shape evangelical life, thought, and culture.

The Bulletin

Matrescence with Lucy Jones

 

The Bulletin welcomes Lucy Jones for a conversation with Clarissa Moll on the neuroscience and social transformation of motherhood. 

Testimony

I Demolished My Faith for ‘My Best Life.’ It Only Led to Despair.

Queer love, polyamory, and drugs ruined me. That’s where Jesus found me.

The Book Screwtape Feared Most

Once a bedrock Christian classic, Boethius’s “Consolation of Philosophy” has been neglected for decades. It’s time for a revival.

Apple PodcastsDown ArrowDown ArrowDown Arrowarrow_left_altLeft ArrowLeft ArrowRight ArrowRight ArrowRight Arrowarrow_up_altUp ArrowUp ArrowAvailable at Amazoncaret-downCloseCloseEmailEmailExpandExpandExternalExternalFacebookfacebook-squareGiftGiftGooglegoogleGoogle KeephamburgerInstagraminstagram-squareLinkLinklinkedin-squareListenListenListenChristianity TodayCT Creative Studio Logologo_orgMegaphoneMenuMenupausePinterestPlayPlayPocketPodcastRSSRSSSaveSaveSaveSearchSearchsearchSpotifyStitcherTelegramTable of ContentsTable of Contentstwitter-squareWhatsAppXYouTubeYouTube