Thus Spoke Superman

Troubling language frames the stem-cell debate

The language problem begins when infertile John and Jane visit a clinic, where John’s sperm and Jane’s eggs are removed from their bodies. Scientists then coax the sperm into 10 eggs, which at that point become “embryos,” that is, the first stage of human life. Five of these embryos are placed in Jane’s womb, with the hope that at least one will mature into a “fetus” (the next stage of human life). This procedure is called in vitro fertilization. What happens to the other five prefetal human beings? They are either frozen for possible later use (in case Jane’s body rejects the first five), or they are simply tossed into a Dumpster—how many each year, nobody knows, but it likely ranges in the tens (if not hundreds) of thousands. This strikes almost everybody as a great tragedy, but for alarmingly different reasons. Christianity Today objects to the callous destruction of human life. Superman star Christopher Reeve—who has been paralyzed since 1995—is horrified by the waste, arguing that it is a pity because these embryos, which contain some perfectly good stem cells, could be put to good use.

“Is it more ethical for a woman to donate unused embryos that will never become human beings,” he reasoned before the Senate subcommittee debating stem-cell research, “or to let them be tossed away as so much garbage when they could help save thousands of lives?”

Stem cells are the cells from which all 210 different kinds of human tissue originate. Stem cells taken from embryos (versus adults) are especially effective at maturing into any tissue, and thus can heal or restore diseased tissues. Thus some scientists believe that cures for heart disease, Alzheimer’s, Parkinson’s, and other afflictions may be in sight.The government currently bans federally funded laboratories from embryo research, and for good reason: it requires the destruction of embryos. Nonetheless, Reeve and others are petitioning Congress to permit the “harvesting” of stem cells.

“I teach you the Superman,” said Friedrich Nietzsche in Thus Spake Zarathustra. “Man is something that is to be surpassed.” And in language that combines Nietzsche and American pragmatism, thus spoke the former Superman: “No obstacle should stand in the way of responsible investigation,” and “It is our responsibility to do everything possible to protect the quality of life of the present and future generations.”

That the wheelchair-bound Reeve resorts to such language is especially ironic. He seems unaware of the cultures—fascist Germany being only the latest example—that with the same logic have harvested parts from the paralyzed, the insane, and others considered subhuman to

“protect the quality of life of the present and future generations.”

The complex ethics of stem-cell research, not to mention in vitro fertilization, are too subtle to explore here (for a fuller discussion, see On Human Embryos and Stem Cell Research: An Appeal for Legally and Ethically Responsible Science and Public Policy, prepared by The Center for Bioethics and Human Dignity (www.stemcellresearch.org/statement.htm). But they need to be addressed in a fuller way no matter what this subcommittee decides: stem-cell research is already being pursued for profit in privately funded clinics across America.For now we limit ourselves to noting again the troublesome language used to frame the debate. It is the Superman’s language, the language of man trying to transcend himself, the alluring language of the serpent:

“You will be like God.”

It is a language we Christians should repudiate whenever the issue is discussed.

Related Elsewhere

Various opinions on human stem cell research can be found at Lutherans for Life, the Juvenile Diabetes Foundation, Focus on the Family, Discover, National Review, Technology Review, the Foundation for Biomedical Research, the Coalition of Americans for Research Ethics, and the Federation of American Societies for Experimental Biology.The National Institutes of Health Web site offers an area on stem-cell research that includes the controversial research guidelines and a primer on “what stem cells are; what pluripotent stem cells are; how pluripotent stem cells are derived; why pluripotent stem cells are important to science; why they hold such great promise for advances in health care; and what adult stem cells are.” The American Association for the Advancement of Science has also addressed the issue of human stem cell research.The Web site for Trinity’s Center for Bioethics and Human Dignity includes several areas on stem-cell research and a daily bioethics Weblog. Last year, The New York Times looked at the religious aspects of the debate over human stem cell research. Christopher Reeve discussed the possible benefits of stem cells for spinal cord injuries on Good Morning America. The Christopher Reeve Paralysis Foundation is also online.See our past coverage of this issue:New Stem-Cell Research Guidelines Criticized | NIH guidelines skirt ethical issues about embryo destruction, charge bioethicists (Feb. 7, 2000) Human Embryo Research Resisted (August 9, 1999) Embryo Research Contested (May 24, 1999) Editorial: The Biotech Temptation | Research on human embryos holds great promise, but at what price? (July 12, 1999)

Copyright © 2000 Christianity Today. Click for reprint information.

Also in this issue

We're in the Money! Evangelicals fun parachurch organizations to the tune of over $22 billion. How did we become so wealthy, and what has it done to us?

Cover Story

We’re in the Money!

AME Zion: And God Said, 'Get out of Zion'

A Healthy Cult

Holding the Middle Ground

Seminary President Steps Down

Higher Education: Eagles, Crusaders, and Trolls—Oh My!

Updates

Puerto Rico: Puerto Rican Christians Unite Against Navy Bombings

Briefs: North America

Evangelism: Anne Graham Lotz Launches Five-city Revival Tour

New Mexico: Can Prayer Cut New Mexico's Crime?

Suffer the Children

Belief Police

Children's Ministry: Toon Time

Commission Urges Economic Sanctions

Laos: Enemies of the State

Pakistan: Military Leader Backpeddles on Human Rights Decision

Briefs: The World

Iraq: Sanctions Missing the Mark

Colombia: Death in the Night

Follow the Money

When Burkett Speaks, Evangelicals Listen

Forgive Us Our Debts: Rich Christians in an Age of Easy Credit

The Seven Deadly Signs

The Freedom to Resist

Potlatch Gospel

Discipleship by Numbers

Suicide—A Preventable Tragedy?

A Living Birthday Letter

Peter Jennings on Jesus

We’ve Got Porn

In the Word: In the Valley of the Shadow of Idi Amin

The Real Christian Coalition

Classic & Contemporary Excerpts from June 12, 2000

A Lonely Day in the Neighborhood

The New Civic Family

The Personhood Wars

View issue

Our Latest

Public Theology Project

Russell Moore’s Favorite Books of 2024

The top 10 picks of CT’s editor in chief range from dystopian fiction to philosophy, with a dose of Sabbath poems, Inklings, and country music.

My Book Sales Stink. But I’m Glad I Took the Publishing Plunge.

Even though the experience bruised my ego, God redeemed it in surprising ways.

Latino Christians Deserve a Straight Answer on Immigration

The Russell Moore Show

A Conversation with Peggy Noonan

The Pulitzer Prize winner ponders who we are and what we may become.

A Better Trans Conversation

As the Supreme Court hears oral arguments on youth gender medicine, Christians must prepare to speak with love while holding fast to biblical truth.

Ethics Aren’t Graded on a Curve

President Joe Biden’s pardon of Hunter Biden was wrong, and no amount of bad behavior from Donald Trump changes that fact.

News

UK Christians Lament Landmark Vote to Legalize Assisted Dying 

Pro-life faith leaders say Parliament’s proposed bill fails to protect the vulnerable and fear it will “create more suffering and chaos.”

Strike Up the Band: Sixpence None the Richer Goes Back on Tour

With its perennial hit “Kiss Me” still in our ears and on our playlists, the Christian band reunites with nothing to prove.

Apple PodcastsDown ArrowDown ArrowDown Arrowarrow_left_altLeft ArrowLeft ArrowRight ArrowRight ArrowRight Arrowarrow_up_altUp ArrowUp ArrowAvailable at Amazoncaret-downCloseCloseEmailEmailExpandExpandExternalExternalFacebookfacebook-squareGiftGiftGooglegoogleGoogle KeephamburgerInstagraminstagram-squareLinkLinklinkedin-squareListenListenListenChristianity TodayCT Creative Studio Logologo_orgMegaphoneMenuMenupausePinterestPlayPlayPocketPodcastRSSRSSSaveSaveSaveSearchSearchsearchSpotifyStitcherTelegramTable of ContentsTable of Contentstwitter-squareWhatsAppXYouTubeYouTube