Ideas

Post-Truth Society

Columnist; Contributor

The recent trend of lying is no accident.

It was the dream of a lifetime for George O’Leary: A chance to coach the world’s most prestigious football teamโ€”Notre Dame’s Fighting Irish. But the dream soon became a nightmare.

The day after he signed his contract with Notre Dame, O’Leary’s rรฉsumรฉ was sent to the pressโ€”a rรฉsumรฉ that included “inaccuracies” about his education and college football letters. A few days later, O’Leary resigned in disgrace, the victim of his own long-ago lies.

It’s the latest example of what’s become an epidemic of lying.

In recent years, politicians and pundits, professors and even Pulitzer Prize-winners have been caught dealing in deceit. One of the nation’s most respected historians, Stephen Ambrose, plagiarized portions of other historians’ works andโ€”notwithstanding his public apologyโ€”seemed hardly disturbed by the resulting controversy.

Historian Joseph Ellis, who won the Pulitzer Prize for his book, Founding Brothers, was caught inventing a Vietnam War record for himself. So was Tim Johnson, manager of the Toronto Blue Jays. Ex-conservative writer David Brock admitted he’d made up sordid details about Anita Hill. Gloria Steinem’s claim about the number of women who die of eating disordersโ€”supposedly 150,000 a yearโ€”turned out to be a huge feminist hoax. James Patterson and Peter Kim, authors of The Day America Told the Truth, estimate that 91 percent of us regularly embroider the truth. “We lie and don’t even think about it,” Patterson and Kim write.

Why has lying become so much more prevalent? Some scholars believe the problem arose out of the gradual adoption of a utilitarian ethicโ€”one that began eroding the traditional Christian ethic in the West in the middle to late 19th century. This ethic says the (good) end justifies the meansโ€”that if a lie helps more than harms, then we should feel free to employ one.

In the late 20th century, the rise of postmodern deconstructionism on college campuses exacerbated this problem. Postmodernists teach that the truth is not merely irrelevant; they believe it simply doesn’t exist.

As Lynne Cheney observes in her book, Telling the Truth, academics “leaped beyond the commonsense observation that people’s descriptions of reality differ to the conclusion that there is no independent reality and thus no basis for making judgments about truthโ€”or falsity.”

For these academics, truth claims are “the constructs of dominant groupsโ€”the creations of the powerful,” Cheney writes. “Might makes right, in other words; and so intimidation was a perfectly natural way to try to gain assent.”

The assault on truth has spread beyond academia to infect the arts, law, journalism, and psychotherapyโ€”and Cheney points out the grim results. For instance, when it turned out that New York teenager Tawana Brawley had lied about being sexually assaulted by white men, The Nation claimed that “it doesn’t matter whether the crime occurred or not” because it symbolizes “what actually happens to too many black women.”

Those who maintain that truth exists, and that telling falsehoods is wrong, are increasingly under assault. “Fact fetishists” is how New York University professor Thomas Bender characterizes people who insist on accuracy. When reporters hounded him about Clintonian lies, then-White House aide George Stephanopoulos accused them of “an excess of literalism.”

Postmodernism has filtered down to the masses; today, even the man on the street sees little wrong with lying. While Washington Post sportswriter Tony Kornheiser agreed that a religious college like Notre Dame was “completely right in separating itself from George O’Leary,” he argued that “some people” will suggest that O’Leary’s lies are “insignificant” when compared to his 20-year coaching record.

In the pages of the New York Post, that’s exactly what a sports fan did suggest. “I think Notre Dame is acting holier than thou,” huffed salesman Jim McNulty; O’Leary should be judged not on his integrity, but on his coaching record.

It’s the perfect postmodern answer to lying: It’s perfectly acceptable to reinvent ourselves, because what we say and do matter less than how people perceive us.

The good news is that while America’s tolerance of lying is greater than ever, Americans retain enough of their Judeo-Christian ethic that they are still scandalized when a public figure lies. We have to help our neighbors understand what’s behind the current propensity for lying: A worldview that denies the existence of truth itself, which merely exacerbates our human fallenness in this area. And then we must point them to the Author of truth, the one who said, “I am the Way, the Truth, and the Life.”

Copyright © 2002 Christianity Today. Click for reprint information.

Related Elsewhere

Christianity Today addressed honesty in Christian publishing in a 1982 editorial, “Ghostwriting: A Borderline Deceit?The evangelical world is being plagued by ghostwriters in the sky.”

In George O’Leary’s resignation statement from Notre Dame, he said that “Many years ago, as a young married father, I sought to pursue my dream as a football coach. In seeking employment, I prepared a resume that contained inaccuracies regarding my completion of course work for a Master’s Degree and also my level of participation in football at my alma mater.

The Washington Post’sTony Kornheiser wrote that “if the inaccuracies O’Leary carved into his life story had come to light after he had been at Notre Dame for a couple of years, he would not be fired.”

For more information on O’Leary’s resignation, see ESPN’s coverage.

Coverage of Stephen Ambrose’s plagiarism and apology includes:

Ambrose Apologizes โ€” The Weekly Standard (Jan. 7, 2002)

Author Admits He Lifted Lines From ’95 Book โ€” The New York Times (Jan. 6, 2002)

Stephen Ambrose, Copycat โ€” The Weekly Standard (Jan. 4, 2002)

Articles on Joseph Ellis inventing his own Vietnam War record includes:

A History of His Own Making โ€” Time (June 24, 2001)

The Greatest Dishonor โ€” Accuracy in Academia (July 2, 2001)

According to Baseball Library.com, Tim Johnson was fired as manager of the Toronto Blue Jays after it was revealed he told fabricated Vietnam stories to inspire players.

The Christian Science Monitor reported that “David Brock, the former writer for the right-wing American Spectator magazine that attacked Anita Hill so hard and then later went after Bill and Hillary Clinton, alleges in an upcoming book that he made up most of the things he wrote about Hill in the Spectator.”

Telling the Truth and The Day America Told the Truth are available at Amazon.com.

Recent Charles Colson columns for Christianity Today include:

Drawing the Battle LinesWe need to be informed and discerning about the Islamic worldview. (Jan. 9, 2002)

Wake-up CallIf September 11 was a divine warning, it’s God’s people who are being warned. (Nov. 5, 2001)

The New TyrannyBiotechnology threatens to turn humanity into raw material. (Oct. 5, 2001)

Merchants of CoolWe should be angry that the media hawks violence and that parents allow it. (June 6, 2001)

Slouching into SlothThe XFL is but the latest sign of the coarsening of our culture. (Apr. 17, 2001)

Checks and (out of) BalanceMoral truth is in jeopardy when the courts enter the business of making law. (Feb. 27, 2001)

Pander PoliticsPoll-driven elections turn voters into self-seeking consumers.(Jan. 3, 2001)

Neighborhood OutpostChanging a culture takes more than politics. (Nov.8, 2000)

MAD No MoreIn this post-Cold War era, it’s time to rethink our nation’s defensive strategy. (Sept. 27, 2000)

Salad-Bar ChristianityToo many believers pick and choose their own truths. (Aug. 8, 2000)

A Healthy ‘Cult’A lively response by one unusual audience shows how God’s power transforms culture. (June 12, 2000)

Also in this issue

New' China: Same Old Tricks: Top communists, despite their denials, endorse arrest and torture of Chinese Christians by the thousands.

Cover Story

'New' China: Same Old Tricks

Hungry for Something More

Afghanistan: Moonscape with Tents

Pakistan: Christians Hail Electoral Reform

Central Asia: Christians Fear Decade of Freedom Is Over

Philippines: Agency Disputes Rumors about Burnhams

Criswell's 15 Minutes

Bloodsuckers

Quotation marks

The Organ's Revenge

Holy Smoke

Hostage Vigil: Families of Hostage Couple Wait

Hannah's Sisters

Super Bibles

The Interfaith Public Square

Shortchanging Charities

Crucifixion

Hiding from Religion Police

Thou Shalt Be Cool

God's Peculiar People

The Unlikely Activist

News

CCM's Growing Pains

Wire Story

Church vs. State: Churches Seek Help in Abuse Suits

Wire Story

Just War: Christian Ethicists: Afghan War Is Just

Wire Story

Government Rethinks Nazareth Mosque

What China's Secret Documents Reveal

China Persecution Dossier: Zhang Wu-Ji

China Persecution Dossier: Shi Yun-Chao

China Persecution Dossier: Gu Xiangmei

News

Go Figure

The Battle of Lexington and Wilmore

No Easy Victory

The 'Baptist Pope'

Nuptial Agreements

Adam and Eve in the 21st Century

The Forgotten Founder

Out of Uniform: Flier Shuns Abaya

Faith-Based Setback: Court Strips Faith Works of State Funds

Workplace Bias: Religious Bias Case Back on Track

View issue

Our Latest

News

Died: Jack Iker, Anglican Who Drew the Line at Womenโ€™s Ordination

The Texas bishop fought a bitter legal battle with the Episcopal Church and won.

Why Canโ€™t We Talk to Each Other Anymore?

Online interactions are draining us of energy to have hard conversations in person.

Church Disappointment Is Multilayered

Jude 3 Project founder Lisa Fields speaks about navigating frustrations with God and fellow believers.

The Robot Will Lie Down With the Gosling

In โ€œThe Wild Robot,โ€ hospitality reprograms relationships.

How Priscilla Shirer Surrenders All

The best-selling Bible teacher writes about putting God first in her life and how healthy Christian discipleship requires sacrifice

The Bulletin

Second Hand News

The Bulletin talks presidential podcasts, hurricane rumors, and the spiritual histories of Israel and Iran.

Which Church in Revelation Is Yours Like?

From the lukewarm Laodicea to the overachieving Ephesus, these seven ancient congregations struggled with relatable problems.

Apple PodcastsDown ArrowDown ArrowDown Arrowarrow_left_altLeft ArrowLeft ArrowRight ArrowRight ArrowRight Arrowarrow_up_altUp ArrowUp ArrowAvailable at Amazoncaret-downCloseCloseEmailEmailExpandExpandExternalExternalFacebookfacebook-squareGiftGiftGooglegoogleGoogle KeephamburgerInstagraminstagram-squareLinkLinklinkedin-squareListenListenListenChristianity TodayCT Creative Studio Logologo_orgMegaphoneMenuMenupausePinterestPlayPlayPocketPodcastRSSRSSSaveSaveSaveSearchSearchsearchSpotifyStitcherTelegramTable of ContentsTable of Contentstwitter-squareWhatsAppXYouTubeYouTube