Trouble in the Garden

Historic Chicago homeless shelter is under siege by City Hall

The world-famous Pacific Garden Mission has been struggling for 126 years to help Chicago’s homeless with hot meals and give them a roof over their heads. For the last 4 years, it has also been battling the city.

The mission provides meals and shelter for up to 1,000 people a day at its historic brick building at 646 South State Street—known as the Old Lighthouse—with its famous neon-border cross reading Jesus Saves. Pacific Garden tapes its radio drama, Unshackled, there every Saturday.

The Chicago Board of Education has been attempting to buy the building since 1999. The city says it wants to make room for a planned expansion of the adjacent Jones College Prep High School. “We need more space to become a fully functioning high school,” said Cynthia Barron, founding principal of Jones High and an officer for Chicago Public Schools.

Advocates for the poor think more is going on. John Donahue, executive director of the Chicago Coalition for the Homeless, said gentrification is a prime reason for the push. “The city is responding to the new people in the neighborhood who want the shelter moved and are using the school as an excuse,” he said.

In the last decade, Donahue said, four large homeless shelters in Chicago—the Olive Branch, Sousa’s Place, Cooper’s Place, and the Christian Industrial League—have been pushed to move or make plans to move.

Pacific Garden Mission has been at this site since 1923, but it is open to moving, said David McCarrell, the mission’s president.

“We have agreed to move to four different locations,” he said. “Three times the city has given initial approval and then withdrawn that approval. The last place we looked at…was priced right out of the market.”

He told Christianity Today that relocating would cost around $20 million, nearly three times the Board of Education’s latest offer of $7 million.

After the mission rejected that offer, the City of Chicago filed a lawsuit to condemn the building. If it wins, the city could take possession by eminent domain. One hearing took place in June. The next is set for December.

Donahue said there are 15,000 homeless people in Chicago on any given night. The city’s 125 shelters provide only 6,000 beds. He said that losing Pacific Garden, the city’s oldest and largest homeless shelter, “would be a calamity for poor people.”

• Bob Smietana in Chicago

Copyright © 2003 Christianity Today. Click for reprint information.

Related Elsewhere

The official website of the Pacific Garden Mission has more information on its mission and history, ministries, and news.

In 2000, CT profiled Pacific Garden Mission’s radio ministry, the “Longest-Running Radio Show On Earth.”

Also in this issue

Suburban Spirituality: How to free your spirit when the 'burbs try to squeeze you into their mold.

Cover Story

Suburban Spirituality

David Goetz

Faith-based Bathing

Ignoring God in the Constitution

Tomas Dixon

Religion in the 'Burbs

Inside CT : Away from the Crowd

Jesus in the Jury Room

Out of the Garden

Quotation Marks

Youth in a Haze

Cross Purposes

The Book on Tape (Not Tapes)

Put Yourself in Jesus Shoes

Showing Schools Grace

Souls on Ice

Christianity Today Editorial

Beyond Virtue and Vice

Christianity Today Editorial

Classic & Contemporary Excerpts from July 01, 2003

Richard A. Kauffman

Criminal Faith

Jeff M. Sellers

Baptists Fire Missionaries

staff reports

Roe vs. Judicial Sense

Christ via Judaism

Sarah Hinlicky Wilson

Rabbit Trails to God

Mark A. Buchanan

As Close as Our Breath

Anna Waterhouse

Soul Language on Paper

Cindy Crosby

Navigating Life Storms

Cindy Crosby

Taming the Techno Monster

Cindy Crosby

Everyday Truths

Cindy Crosby

Church Sells Armstrong's Works

Marshall Allen

Going It Alone

Breakthrough Dancing

Tim Stafford

Hit by the SARS Tornado

Jeff M. Sellers

400K and counting

Bob Smietana

Study Lauds Prisoner Program

Tony Carnes

Being Here

Charles Colson with Anne Morse

News

Go Figure

News

Big Idea Loses Suit

Todd Hertz

The State of Missions

interview with Luis Bush

Damping the Fuse in Iraq

interview with Canon Andrew White

Turning the Mainline Around

Michael S. Hamilton and Jennifer McKinney

Watch that Invocation

Marshall Allen

Daring to Dream Again

Adam Piore

Pakistan Court Acquits Christian of Blasphemy

Barbara Baker

Courting Trouble

David Karanja

"Baptists Cut Staff, Missionaries"

Roadblocks and Voting Blocs

Christianity Today editorial

Bumper Sticker Theology

Richard A. Kauffman

Creature Discomforts

Matthew Scully

News

Jesus' Woodstock

Todd Hertz

"Fun, Friendly Advice"

Cindy Crosby

Tangling with Wolves

Chris Armstrong

Coming Attractions

A Christianity Today Editorial

Christian Research Institute Accused of 'Naïve' Bookkeeping

Marshall Allen

Pro-life Groups Ready to Defend Partial-Birth Abortion Ban

Anglican Communion Frays

Peter T. Chattaway

Canada Backs Gay Marriages

Carol Lowes

Cooling off Gay Agenda

Douglas LeBlanc

"Prayer, Incorporated"

Ken Walker

Evangelicals Advise on Muslim Dialogue

Mark Stricherz

Doctrinal Aftershocks

Marshall Allen

Yankee Stadium Strike Out

Todd Hertz

Power in Punjab

Manpreet Singh

View issue

Our Latest

News

Trump’s Visa Suspension Leaves Adoptive Families in Limbo

Hannah Herrera

The government doesn’t provide a blanket exemption for international adoptions but will examine them case by case.

The Bulletin

Mercy in Minnesota, Pro-Life in Trump 2.0, and Syrian-Kurdish Conflict

Churches’ aid for immigrant neighbors, March for Life in DC, and Kurdish-Syrian military clashes.

News

Kenyan Churches Compete with Bullfights on Sunday Morning

Pius Sawa in Kakamega County, Kenya

As the traditional sport regains popularity, pastors report young people have disconnected from church.

How Football Shaped Christian Colleges

John Fea

Three history books to read this month.

What CT Asked Advice Columnist Ann Landers

As America teetered on the edge of revolution, the magazine called for more innovation, responsibility, sensitivity, and stewardship.

News

After Their Kids Survived the Annunciation Shooting, Parents Search for Healing

Families in the same Anglican church watched their young children deal with trauma, anxiety, and grief. They found one solution: each other.

News

Refugee Arrests Shatter Sense of Safety in Minnesota

A federal judge ruled that ICE can no longer arrest legally admitted refugees in the state, many of whom are persecuted Christians. But damage has been done.

Inside the Ministry

The Big Tent Initiative

Anne Kerhoulas

The Big Tent Initiative is building bridges across the American Church.

Apple PodcastsDown ArrowDown ArrowDown Arrowarrow_left_altLeft ArrowLeft ArrowRight ArrowRight ArrowRight Arrowarrow_up_altUp ArrowUp ArrowAvailable at Amazoncaret-downCloseCloseEmailEmailExpandExpandExternalExternalFacebookfacebook-squareGiftGiftGooglegoogleGoogle KeephamburgerInstagraminstagram-squareLinkLinklinkedin-squareListenListenListenChristianity TodayCT Creative Studio Logologo_orgMegaphoneMenuMenupausePinterestPlayPlayPocketPodcastRSSRSSSaveSaveSaveSearchSearchsearchSpotifyStitcherTelegramTable of ContentsTable of Contentstwitter-squareWhatsAppXYouTubeYouTube