Ideas

It’s Not About Stem Cells

Why we must clarify the debate over harvesting embryos.

You’ve heard the lament by now. Embryonic stem-cell research is the Scientific Thing to do; the religious bio-Luddites standing in its way are so Middle Ages. How can they allow the continued suffering of many with so-far incurable diseases because of a moot religious speculation?

At least that’s how some pundits cast the debate, some of them conveniently leaving out key distinctions. But the Devil and God both are in the details.

We see it in the August 24 Pew Research Center survey, which inadvertently reinforces a false dichotomy. Respondents were asked if it’s more important to conduct stem-cell research or protect embryos—as if these were mutually exclusive options. Not even a hint that many scientists are already doing both: conducting promising stem-cell research on (adult) stem cells and not destroying embryos in the process.

Democratic presidential nominee John Kerry perpetuates similar falsehoods. In an early August radio address, he asserted that “at this very moment, some of the most pioneering cures and treatments are right at our fingertips, but because of the stem-cell ban, they remain beyond our reach.” First, the soonest even the most optimistic researchers say cures can be developed is in five to ten years. Second, Bush didn’t institute a “stem-cell ban.” In an ethically unsatisfying move, he actually allowed federal funding for limited embryonic stem-cell research. Third, the implication that Bush’s ban and Christians’ opposition has to do with stem cells is a fallacy committed so frequently that it seems intentional. It’s not about stem cells. It’s about embryonic stem cells.

According to Mayo hematologist C. Christopher Hook, stem cells—extraordinarily flexible—can be derived from six sources: umbilical cord blood, bone marrow, peripheral blood, the biopsy of specific organs, fetal tissue, and the human embryo.

The research on adult stem cells, derived from the first four sources, poses no ethical dilemmas. Fetal stem-cell research is ethically murky because it is associated with abortion. But it’s not debated much because it’s deemed impractical, Hook says.

Then there are the controversial embryonic stem cells. What’s all the fuss about? After all, as Ron Reagan Jr. assured Americans, “No fetuses are created, none destroyed” in the process of their production. No one, of course, was arguing that fetuses are destroyed in the process. Embryos are. Therefore, humans are.

Take the scenario Reagan described: Grab a cell from your arm and put its entire DNA into a shell of a donor egg. What you’ve just done is clone a human being. (Somehow, Reagan failed to mention that.) What results is an embryo, defined as a fertilized egg up to eight weeks of development. Putting it outside the womb doesn’t change the fact that this process commodifies human life, making it raw material for our enhancements.

The supporters of embryonic stem-cell research say they are motivated by their compassion for the sick. We resonate with their concern. But why end one vulnerable human life in order to potentially prolong another? Why not use adult stem cells?

Scientists disagree whether the healing potential of adult stem cells is going to equal that of embryonic stem cells. But about a dozen biotech firms are developing therapies using adult cells. Recently, a Johns Hopkins University lab converted bone-marrow stem cells from animal donors into healthy liver cells for humans. “It’s mind-blowing stuff,” the head of this lab told The Washington Post. “I never would have thought this would be possible. Preposterous. Not possible. No way.”

Yes way. Yes to all defenseless human life.

Copyright © 2004 Christianity Today. Click for reprint information.

Related Elsewhere:

Also posted today is California’s Prop. 71 Stem-Cell ‘Scam’ | Supporters of cloning embryos for research have $11 million to convince state voters.

Other Christianity Today articles on stem cells and other life ethics issues includes:

Weblog: Despite Catholic Church Support, Prop. 71 Opponents Still $12 Million Behind in Funding (Sept. 09, 2004)

The Proposition 71 Stem Cell Scam | The biotech lobby is attempting to buy a law in California, Wesley J. Smith says. (Aug. 17, 2004)

Weblog: Britain Starts Cloning | Send in the clones (Aug. 12, 2004)

When Does Personhood Begin? | And what difference does it make? (June 18, 2004)

Cloning Report Breeds Confusion | Does it open the door to ‘therapeutic cloning’? (May 13, 2004)

A Law That Shouldn’t Be Cloned | New Jersey legalizes human cloning for research (Feb. 10, 2004)

Federal Funds Approved to Study Fetal Stem Cells | Life ethics advocates troubled by the discrepancy that allows days-old embryos more protection than more mature fetuses. (July 10, 2002)

Two Cheers | President Bush’s stem-cell decision is better than the fatal cure many sought. (Aug. 10, 2001)

Britain Debates Cloning of Human Embryos | Scientists want steady stream of stem cells for “therapeutic” purposes. (Nov. 22, 2000)

Beyond the Impasse to What? | Stem-cell research may not need human embryos after all. But why are we researching in the first place? (Aug. 18, 2000)

Also in this issue

The CT archives are a rich treasure of biblical wisdom and insight from our past. Some things we would say differently today, and some stances we've changed. But overall, we're amazed at how relevant so much of this content is. We trust that you'll find it a helpful resource.

Cover Story

Wooing the Faithful

Cover Story

John Kerry's Open Mind

Salt-and-Pepper Politics

Jon Warren: Eyewitness to Suffering

Land of Warlords

Living with Fundamentalists

Mei-Chun Jau: Community Journalism

Not Far from the Brahmin Tree

Ordinary Terrorists

Pick Your Shibboleths Wisely

Poetry, Parables, and Prose

News

Quotation Marks

Sin and Evil

John H. White: Mercy Over Justice

Second-Best Kid Lit Ever

Senate's Top Democrat in the Cross Hairs

Smuggling Cats for a Gay Celebrity

The Ecstatic Heresy

The Moral Home Front

The Nightmare of North Korea

Why Commitment Matters

Wind of Terror, Wind of Glory

Wind of Terror, Wind of Glory

A Heartless Homeland

News

<em>Christianity Today</em> News Briefs

News

Passages

Wire Story

Charley's No Angel

LDS and DNA

Operation Human Rights

Building Alliances to Save Lives

Fighting Flight

Church Militant

'Termites to National Security'

A Stopped Pulse

Ordinary Terrorists

News

Go Figure

Blogging for Jesus

California's Prop. 71 Stem-Cell 'Scam'

Changed by the Unchanging

From Sex Pistols to <em>Shadowmancer</em>

Vegetarians in Paradise

Greg Schneider: God's Personal PR Firm

Editorial

Heat Stroke

Good Shooters

Joanna Pinneo: Intimate Storyteller

View issue

Our Latest

Review

New & Noteworthy Books

Chosen by Matt Reynolds, CT senior books editor.

News

Recovery Ministries Help Portland Get Clean

After an attempt to decriminalize drugs made the addiction crisis in Oregon even worse, local Christians are pleading with the sick—and the state—to let them help.

News

When a Stanford Bible Study Led to an AI Startup

Two young Christians made a college counseling tool, saying AI should serve those on the margins—not just the rich and powerful.

A Solution for Seasonal Overwhelm

Focusing on the few in front of us makes a tangible difference in our local communities.

News

Finding Sobriety—and Jesus—in Vietnam’s Christian Drug Rehabs

The country’s church-run addiction centers are so effective that communist officials are taking notice.

Review

The Black Church Has Five Theological Anchors

Walter Strickland’s sweeping narrative of African American Christianity portrays a big God who is strong to deliver.

Review

Tending and Keeping the Christian Past in an ‘Ahistoric Age’

Why the work of historical stewardship isn’t just for historians.

Apple PodcastsDown ArrowDown ArrowDown Arrowarrow_left_altLeft ArrowLeft ArrowRight ArrowRight ArrowRight Arrowarrow_up_altUp ArrowUp ArrowAvailable at Amazoncaret-downCloseCloseEmailEmailExpandExpandExternalExternalFacebookfacebook-squareGiftGiftGooglegoogleGoogle KeephamburgerInstagraminstagram-squareLinkLinklinkedin-squareListenListenListenChristianity TodayCT Creative Studio Logologo_orgMegaphoneMenuMenupausePinterestPlayPlayPocketPodcastRSSRSSSaveSaveSaveSearchSearchsearchSpotifyStitcherTelegramTable of ContentsTable of Contentstwitter-squareWhatsAppXYouTubeYouTube