Ideas

Downton Abbey’s Real Legacy

Columnist; Contributor

Why we strive to preserve places rich with memory.

Downton Abbey's Real Legacy

Downton Abbey's Real Legacy

Mike Searle

Most houses are just houses. Some, however, deserve honor.

My parents lived in three different apartments in the first phase of their life together. Three times they shared living quarters with in-laws. In the second half of life, they bought or built four different houses.

The places they built had unique features. The one tract house was so unspecial that they called their subdivision "North Manure" instead of the developer's more elegant designation, "North Manor."

Only their final house became so memory filled and was so beautifully situated that it took on a life of its own. Surrounded by mountainous national forest land, it featured beautiful vistas, an amazing variety of wildlife (12 species of hummingbird alone), and a babbling brook. As a teenager, I helped develop the property. My children visited their grandparents there every summer, and later they brought their own spouses and children to visit. It was a magnet for generations of cousins, uncles, and aunts. Visitors made its capacious veranda their own. For our family, the place almost became what Hyannisport was to the Kennedys or Kennebunkport to the Bushes.

When my parents moved, no one felt the need to preserve any of their other houses. But when they died, we scrambled to keep their mountain home in the family.

Houses like that have names. My parents' house was Hummingbird Hill. Masterpiece fans have fallen in love with Downton Abbey, the setting for the most popular costume drama since the 1981 television adaptation of Brideshead Revisited.

The fictional abbey and my parents' mountain home are more than the sum of their walls and windows. On my summer vacation, I read Lady Fiona Carnarvon's Lady Almina and the Real Downton Abbey, the story of Highclere Castle, which served as the set for its fictional counterpart.

House and household were welded through generations. Even in the postwar economy, Lady Fiona writes, Highclere was "a mutually dependent community of people who lived and worked together, mostly in harmony." The house and its estates were the responsibility of both those who lived upstairs and those who served downstairs. When Highclere's house steward Albert Streatfield (counterpart to Downton's fictional Mr. Carson) retired after nearly 40 years of service, Lady Fiona remarked, "Countesses come and Countesses go, but a good house steward stays for life." Marriage decisions were made for the sake of preserving the great house—something held in trust for future generations and the public good.

Sure that war would soon break out, Lady Almina decided to turn Highclere into a hospital. As Lady Fiona tells it, it would "provide the best of everything a soldier could possibly need to recover …. Almina's instinct was to create a hospital that soothed and cheered the senses of men who had been half destroyed by horror." Within days of England's declaring war on Germany, Almina installed a medical director and began recruiting the best nursing staff. Six weeks into World War I, she had her first patients. "Almina had re-imagined the Castle as a therapeutic space, one where the atmosphere in the Library or the excellent cooking from the Castle's kitchen was as important as the services of the radiologist she planned to bring down from London."

What are we to make of these homes that model hospitality, sacrifice, and generosity and embrace large circles in their welcome?

Almina adopted the nurse's uniform and treated the patients as country-house guests, offering them the finest food and the softest sheets. Lady Fiona calls this Almina's "greatest legacy. She realized that post-operative and trauma care were as much a part of the healing process as the best surgical techniques and the latest equipment."

Decades later, patients and their families expressed affection for Highclere because Almina's "generous spirit and Christian view of the world inspired her to spread her wealth and share its benefits."

What are we to make of these homes that model hospitality, sacrifice, and generosity and embrace large circles in their welcome? How shall we understand our desire to preserve them?

In 2 Corinthians 5, Paul famously used temporary housing ("the earthly tent we live in") as a metaphor for our present bodily existence as we await a new and better body ("an eternal house in heaven"). Housing is a concrete (or stucco or brick) reminder of our mortality and our future immortality. If Paul were writing today, maybe he would substitute "tract house" or "assisted living facility" for "earthly tent."

But our natural admiration for great houses that shine with hospitality, beauty, generosity, and sacrifice—even though they may be brought to nothing by death duties or the steady assaults of weather—is a sign of the longing God has planted within us for the eternal habitations.

Also in this issue

The CT archives are a rich treasure of biblical wisdom and insight from our past. Some things we would say differently today, and some stances we've changed. But overall, we're amazed at how relevant so much of this content is. We trust that you'll find it a helpful resource.

Cover Story

50 Women You Should Know

Excerpt

How We Hide Our Suffering

Tullian Tchividjian

The Yes and No of Healing

Sharon L. Lewis

News

Uganda Tells 1 Million Couples: You're Not Really Married

Isaiah Mbuga in Kampala

Review

The Foreign Mission Field Two Minutes Away

Jeff Haanen

News

How Not to Care for Widows

Sarah Eekhoff Zylstra

'Once Upon a Time:' When Pagans Get Real

Joy Craun

News

Christian Colleges Try Massive Online Courses

Melissa Steffan

Review

The Love We Dare Not Ignore

Love Isn't Easy in Man Camp Ministry

Ruth Moon in Williston, North Dakota

Is It Stealing From God to Split Your Tithe Between the Church and Other Charities?

Gary Moore, Amie Streater, and Douglas LeBlanc

Justin Zoradi Believes Education Can Eradicate Poverty

Mark Moring

How to Eat, Play, Love—And Do Other Christian Acts

Interview by R.M. Stone

Ajith Fernando: On the Anvil of Suffering

Tim Stafford

News

Why Churches Worship Illegally—In Paris

Allison J. Althoff

News

Opening the Adoption Files

Ken Walker

Wilson's Bookmarks

John Wilson

The Bonds of Freedom

Roger Olson

Review

Born to Sing: No Plan B

Josh Hurst

Review

Review: Finding God

Matt Reynolds

Review

Review: The Gentle Giant of Dynamite Hill

Matt Reynolds

My Top 5 Books on The Cold War

Paul Kengor

How Books Helped Save My Soul

Editorial

Abusing the Megaphone

A Christianity Today Editorial

Letters to the Editor

The Regnerus Affair

News

Is Megachurch Worship Addictive?

Compiled by Ruth Moon

News

Quotation Marks

News

Go Figure

The Spiritual Sex

A Women's Issue

News

Gleanings

Compiled by CT Staff

The Confessions of Scott Stapp

Mark Moring

View issue

Our Latest

Review

In Netflix’s ‘Frankenstein,’ Monster Is More Compelling Than Maker

The Guillermo del Toro adaptation brings unique perspective—but fails to match the depth of its source material.

More Than a Magic Pill

Kathryn Butler

Rebecca McLaughlin’s latest book shows the radical health benefits of church attendance.

The Bulletin

SNAP Benefits, Iran Update, and Practices to Calm Anxiety

Mike Cosper, Clarissa Moll

Federal funding for food assistance, what’s new in Iran, and embodied practices to address anxiety.

Chinese House Churches Play Matchmaker

Facing pressure from parents, Christian women struggle to find a man.

Backbone in a Gumby Culture

“He was furious, but somehow it put steel into my heart.”

The Russell Moore Show

Listener Question: Should We Sing Worship Songs By Fallen Songwriters?

Russell takes a listener’s question about whether the work of fallen songwriters and authors should be used for worship.

Excerpt

Apologetics After Christendom

The Bulletin with Collin Hansen

How to share your faith in a “spiritual but not religious” world.

Analysis

Christian Brides Don’t Need to Wear White

How Scripture offers grace in wedding planning.

Apple PodcastsDown ArrowDown ArrowDown Arrowarrow_left_altLeft ArrowLeft ArrowRight ArrowRight ArrowRight Arrowarrow_up_altUp ArrowUp ArrowAvailable at Amazoncaret-downCloseCloseEmailEmailExpandExpandExternalExternalFacebookfacebook-squareGiftGiftGooglegoogleGoogle KeephamburgerInstagraminstagram-squareLinkLinklinkedin-squareListenListenListenChristianity TodayCT Creative Studio Logologo_orgMegaphoneMenuMenupausePinterestPlayPlayPocketPodcastRSSRSSSaveSaveSaveSearchSearchsearchSpotifyStitcherTelegramTable of ContentsTable of Contentstwitter-squareWhatsAppXYouTubeYouTube