Subscribe to Christianity Today
Subscribe to Christianity Today
Donate to Christianity Today
login | my account
February 11, 2012

Home > 2007 > OctoberChristianity Today, October, 2007
Tethered to the Center
The Gospel Coalition is committed to core evangelical beliefs and wide-ranging cultural engagement.




The Gospel Coalition kicked off in late May with little fanfare, just how organizers wanted it. Any conference headlined by D. A. Carson, Tim Keller, and John Piper would likely attract more than 500 attenders with a little publicity. But Gospel Coalition leaders chose a word-of-mouth strategy and capped attendance by hosting the two-day conference in the chapel at Trinity Evangelical Divinity School (TEDS). They wanted to test their ideas on a relatively small, friendly group.

Don't let the low-key strategy fool you. This new group, spearheaded by 40 stake-holding theologians and pastors, has big goals. They want nothing less than a renewed evangelical commitment to core confessional beliefs. And they have the strategy to match their ambition.

The Gospel Coalition already boasts one hallmark achievement with its foundational documents, a confessional statement and theological call to ministry. Gospel Coalition's diverse leadership, ranging from Presbyterian pastor Phil Ryken to emerging leader Mark Driscoll, hashed out the documents in meetings over more than two years. Carson wrote the original draft of the confessional statement, while Keller penned the theological call to ministry. The confession, dense and comprehensive, addresses current trends with a positive tone meant to attract rather than condemn. But because the confession betrays a broadly Reformed perspective and expects that men lead churches and homes, it will not appeal to every evangelical. The ministry statement, on the other hand, can help all evangelicals navigate cultural challenges such as politicized faith, consumerism, and theological and moral relativism.

Bolstering the Center

Nearly every speaker during the May event expressed a sense of loss. They lamented how the evangelical movement has fragmented as it has grown in the last 60 years. Holding in one hand a statement of belief and in the other a cultural strategy, Gospel Coalition leaders could have been reenacting early meetings of the National Association of Evangelicals.

"I want to see more churches and leaders joining hands across denominational and network lines to think out how to do effective mission based on the historic, classical understanding of the gospel as it has come down to us from the Reformation and through the Awakenings," said Keller, senior pastor of Redeemer Presbyterian Church in New York City.

Carson, a New Testament professor at TEDS, said the Gospel Coalition wants to renew evangelical faithfulness to a set of unimpeachable doctrines. One popular workshop, led by Ryken, addressed justification by faith alone.

"There are lots of people today who call themselves evangelicals, who no evangelical would have recognized as such 50 years ago," Carson said. "And partly because of the drift toward postmodern epistemology, there is less and less sense of the need for a center."

Even five years ago, this group could not have come together, Carson said.

"Maybe the drift is so bad in the broader culture that [the group's members] want friends, they want colleagues in ministry who have a similar vision," he told CT. "They're not always found in the same denomination or same geographical areas. They're crossing all kinds of boundaries to strengthen their understanding of the center."

But if the center could not hold these last few decades, how can it hold today with a larger and more diverse evangelical movement? Gospel Coalition leaders warn that cooperation cannot come at the expense of clarity. They hope to avoid the problem of whittling away important beliefs in order to reach a lowest common denominator. They also recognize that too much definition will end in a fellowship of one.





Christianity Today


  


Subscribe to Christianity Today and get 3 free trial issues. No credit card required.

Please allow 4-6 weeks for delivery. Offer valid in U.S. only.

If you decide you want to keep Christianity Today coming, honor your invoice for just $19.95 and receive nine more issues, a full year in all. If not, simply write "cancel" across the invoice and return it. The three trial issues are yours to keep, regardless.


Click here for international orders2-for-1 Gifts!

Displaying 1–5 of 10 comments

Alison

October 22, 2007  12:07pm

I'm absolutely thrilled.

Mrs. Donna L. Carlaw

October 22, 2007  12:02pm

P: As long as the confessional statement is tied to the outdated idea that women cannot serve as leaders in churches and are not equal to their husbands in providing leadership, ...> I would be interested to know why you say "outdated idea" rather than "unbiblical idea." Is male-only leadership in the church and in the home unbiblical or just outdated? If oudated, it will go the way of the Dodo bird. OTOH, if male-led homes and churches are the biblical norm, then you have a problem. I did not know that truth was a kind of popularity contest as you seem to be saying. J: The Apostle's and the Nicene Creeds are foundational in the confession of the Christian Faith. I think Protestants, particulary Evangelicals and Pentecostals need to get reacquainted with these creeds. > I'm wondering how many women were present when these Creeds were hammered out. Why these creeds especially? In what ways are you saying we have forgotten who the real Christ is?

Darren King

October 18, 2007  8:36pm

Postmodern developments have helped evangelicals to realize that what many once considered "a biblical view" was really just a systematic reading of scripture based on one particular view. This is the reason why Carson and gang's perspective on evangelicalism is waning. They are simply defending their one, subjective reading of the scriptures and calling this "Evangelical Christianity". Others, realizing this subjective underpinning, have chosen to see the text more as a living narrative; a narrative that needs to be contextualized (read: "tethered") within 2000 years of Christian history, not merely the last few centuries of the modern era.

Arrogance

October 18, 2007  12:30pm

Carson's comment "There are lots of people today who call themselves evangelicals, who no evangelical would have recognized as such 50 years ago," and "And partly because of the drift toward postmodern epistemology, there is less and less sense of the need for a center." have to be the most arrogant statements I have heard coming out of the mouth of a so called evangelical. Who does Carson think he is? This is the problem with movements like Gospel Coalition, and why most people who call themselves evangelicals will NEVER affiliate with it. Do you really want some arrogant person like Carson telling you that because you believe X, Y or Z or because you don't believe A, B or C you should not consider yourself an evangelical?? Well, I for one do not, nor do I care in the least what Carson or the Gospel Coalition have to say about anything. I am accountable to God, and God alone, not some self appoint group of power grabbers, who want to control the agenda and what people believe.

Patrick

October 18, 2007  8:33am

"But because the confession betrays a broadly Reformed perspective and expects that men lead churches and homes..." As long as the confessional statement is tied to the outdated idea that women cannot serve as leaders in churches and are not equal to their husbands in providing leadership, I can't see it having much appeal to large numbers of evangelicals. And as long as some churches insist on propounding that idea, they are going to be increasingly irrelevant. And funny, many Reformed denominations themselves have shed that artifact.

You must be a Christianity Today subscriber or have created a FREE registration to post comments
[Browse More Christianity Today]



Search
Search
Search
Scripture Search
Go Deeper

Books & Culture
Christianity Today
Church Law & Tax Report
Church Finance Today
Leadership Journal
Men of Integrity
Kyria.com
ChristianityTodayLibrary.com
PreachingToday.com