The Truth Is Somewhere

Legacy of Guatemala’s evangelical deposed dictator remains unsettled.

A Spanish court issued an arrest warrant on July 7 for former Guatemalan military ruler Efrain Rios Montt, charging him and seven other leaders with genocide, terrorism, and state-sponsored torture.

Retired army general Rios Montt, 80, a longtime lay pastor in Guatemala’s Pentecostal Verbo Church, came to power after a 1982 military coup during the nation’s civil war that pitted four Marxist guerrilla groups against the government. Seventeen months later, a bloodless coup toppled Rios Montt from power.

He ruled during the Central American Cold War struggles between governments and leftist insurgencies in Guatemala, El Salvador, and Nicaragua, which took place in the late 1970s and 1980s.

Rios Montt once counted Luis Palau, Jerry Falwell, and Pat Robertson among his friends and supporters. (Christianity Today ran multiple articles promoting his presidency.) “It’s great to have a Christian president as a model,” Palau told CT in 1983. “The hand of God appears to be on him.”

A U.S. State Department report, however, describes Rios Montt’s 17-month rule as “probably the most violent period of the 36-year internal conflict, resulting in about 200,000 deaths of mostly unarmed indigenous civilians.” A 1996 peace treaty ended Guatemala’s civil war. In 1999, a U.N.-sponsored truth commission, called the Historical Clarification Commission, found government forces responsible for 93 percent of war deaths. President Bill Clinton apologized for support the United States granted to Guatemala’s military rulers.

Many evangelical Guatemala watchers, however, say Rios Montt did not order or even know about the massacres. Others maintain that during the Cold War, drastic measures were justified to keep Communists from overthrowing Guatemala’s government.

“Nobody is saying we need to prosecute the other side, the guerrilla leaders,” said Steve Sywulka, interim Guatemala field director of CAM International, a missions agency. “[They] were also responsible for many deaths, both directly and indirectly.”

Manuel Dionicio, secretary general of the Evangelical Alliance of Guatemala, told CT that Rios Montt’s duty was to defend Guatemala from Communism. “But I don’t believe he’s killed anybody,” Dionicio said. “Perhaps his biggest ‘sin’ is that he professed to be evangelical.”

Retired CAM president and former missionary to Guatemala J. Ronald Blue told CT he spoke years ago with Rios Montt. “I am convinced that he was not the one who ordered all the atrocities that were committed during his presidency,” Blue said. “I tend to trust people, and in this case, I trust Rios Montt’s testimony. I am convinced that he is a brother in Christ and is an honorable man.”

Last year, Spain’s constitutional court authorized tribunals to try defendants for crimes against humanity, regardless of whether they involved Spanish citizens. Guatemala has granted Rios Montt amnesty.

Rios Montt remained a fixture in Guatemalan politics even after the coup stripped him of power. Long known for fighting corruption, he became president of Guatemala’s Congress in 2000.

“He was seen as somebody who brought stability and order into a very chaotic situation,” Sywulka said.

But later that year, Rios Montt’s image suffered in a scandal involving liquor tax legislation. In 2003, he garnered only 11 percent of the vote while running for president.

“We’ve moved on. He’s nobody, a failed politician,” said Danny Carroll Rodas, who has taught for 24 years at Central American Theological Seminary. Carroll trusts the Historical Clarification Commission report and doubts claims of Rios Montt’s ignorance, in part because he was a military leader.

“He may have known something but couldn’t do anything about it,” Carroll said. “Will we ever know that?”

Yet the seminary professor holds out hope that a warehouse full of early-1980s military records discovered in July 2005 will provide answers. Bringing Rios Montt to trial may expose what really happened. “The story needs to be told,” Carroll said, “and in the telling, there’s a sense of healing.”

Copyright © 2006 Christianity Today. Click for reprint information.

Related Elsewhere:

News elsewhere includes:

War justice is still elusive for many in Guatemala | Spanish arrest warrants highlighted Guatemala’s problems prosecuting rights abuses during its civil war. (The Miami Herald, July 30, 2006)

Spanish judge orders Guatemalan ex-rulers arrested | A Spanish judge on Friday ordered the arrest of two former Guatemalan military rulers for genocide, torture, illegal arrest and terrorism during the central American country’s civil war. (Reuters)

Spanish judge in Guatemala for genocide probe | A Spanish judge arrived in Guatemala on Saturday to investigate atrocities committed during the Central American nation’s armed conflict, but local officials might not allow him to proceed. (Reuters)

Wikipedia has an entry on Montt.

More CT coverage of Guatemala is available on our site.

Also in this issue

The CT archives are a rich treasure of biblical wisdom and insight from our past. Some things we would say differently today, and some stances we've changed. But overall, we're amazed at how relevant so much of this content is. We trust that you'll find it a helpful resource.

Cover Story

Young, Restless, Reformed

'Divine Conspirator' Dallas Willard Dies at 77

It's All About God

Inside C.S. Lewis's Toolbox

Embrace Your Inner Pentecostal

China's New Legal Eagles

Spiritual Classics

Class Warfare

What Happened to Religion in Canada?

Despair Not

The Call of Samuel

Logic Left Behind

The Whole Word for the Whole World

Jeffrey Dahmer's Story of Faith

For Shame?

Christ's Story

Postcard from Africa

Editorial

God's Will in the Public Square

Wrongful Love

Theology for an Age of Terror

News

Quotation Marks

The New Missions Generation

News

Go Figure

News

<em>Christianity Today</em> News Briefs

News

Passages

Excerpt

A Call to an Ancient Evangelical Future

Together in the Jesus Story

Nicholas Kristof on Evangelicals, China, and Human Rights

'Volcanic' Response

We're Not Spectators

Bygone Protests

Two Degrees of Separation

News

Scrubbing CleanFlicks

Thinking Straight

Echoes and Voices from Beyond

How to Create Cynics

Sermons of Frederick Buechner

Estranged Bedfellows

The Problem with Prophets

Sit Down, Sit Down for Jesus?

Pluralist Impotence

Dr. Willard's Diagnosis

View issue

Our Latest

Go Slow and Repair Things

We’re facing huge problems in our culture—problems an election alone can’t solve. But by God’s grace, we can do the small, daily work of repair.

In a Polarized World, but Not of It 

On Election Day and beyond, conservative and liberal Christians can better understand each other and be ministers of reconciliation. 

Gen Z Is Turning Online for Spiritual Guidance

Where Ya From?

Navigating Cultural Identity with Danielle Marck

Danielle Marck shares the experiences that pivoted the direction of her life toward her callings from God.

News

Charlie Kirk Aims to Expand Turning Point USA to Evangelical Campuses

But not all Christian campuses have embraced the conservative group.

News

Sarah Jakes Roberts Evolves T. D. Jakes’s Women’s Conference

At a record-setting event this fall, 40,000 followers listened to her preach about spiritual breakthrough and surrender.

News

The Evangelical Voters Who Changed Their Minds

Amid a hyperpartisan electorate, a minority plan to vote differently than they did in 2016 and 2020.

Being Human

Walking the Camino de Santiago with Barrett Harkins

The missionary to pilgrims shares wisdom from the trail.

Apple PodcastsDown ArrowDown ArrowDown Arrowarrow_left_altLeft ArrowLeft ArrowRight ArrowRight ArrowRight Arrowarrow_up_altUp ArrowUp ArrowAvailable at Amazoncaret-downCloseCloseEmailEmailExpandExpandExternalExternalFacebookfacebook-squareGiftGiftGooglegoogleGoogle KeephamburgerInstagraminstagram-squareLinkLinklinkedin-squareListenListenListenChristianity TodayCT Creative Studio Logologo_orgMegaphoneMenuMenupausePinterestPlayPlayPocketPodcastRSSRSSSaveSaveSaveSearchSearchsearchSpotifyStitcherTelegramTable of ContentsTable of Contentstwitter-squareWhatsAppXYouTubeYouTube