Reply All

Responses to our November issue.

Image Source: Peter Stark / Getty Images

Meet the Minnie Church

As a former Cast Member, I think Cast Member Church is a great idea. When you consider the size and scope of Disney, you have quite a large population to reach. While I was aboard the cruise ship Disney Wonder, I created and led the first ever Disney Crew Christmas Choir. Every evening we would perform Christmas carols on the grand staircase for the guests. I was able to include some Jesus songs in the set, like “O Come All Ye Faithful” and “Silent Night” (sung in three different languages). The cruise director would give a disclaimer prior to our show that “Disney does not endorse any specific religious beliefs.” Nevertheless, we sang songs of the story of Christ’s birth on the Disney Wonder!

Additionally, while working as a musician aboard a Princess cruise ship, I started and led a passenger Bible study. On each cruise, the first day would bring a handful of people. By the third day, I would have 25 to 30 guests.

I often felt like I was the only Christian on the entire ship! How I longed for fellowship while living at sea for months at a time. And I am sure I would have felt the same if I were at the parks.

Kurt Kelley Indianapolis, IN

What Real Leaders Look Like

Mark Galli reminds us of the importance of biblical character and spiritual maturity in our leaders. But he seems to say it’s either/or—we can have leaders gifted in strategy, finance, marketing and human resource development, or we can have 1 Timothy 3 leaders. I’ve known many CEOs who recognize they can do all things through Christ, but apart from him they can do nothing. Unfortunately, not all were capable and effective leaders. If elders regularly and candidly evaluated their senior pastor, and if boards of Christian nonprofits set clear expectations for their CEO then monitored progress, many of the problems Galli points out would be identified and addressed before they did serious harm. Unfortunately, far too many elders and boards fail to do that most important part of their job.

David Bugher Frederick, MD

In Europe, many Christians are deeply concerned witnessing the diminishing role of American leadership in the global church. The history of our own continent has taught us, ever since the Roman emperor Constantine gave privileges to Christians, that the church is weakened by allying with financial and political power. We hope that America will not follow the same path. As is rightfully pointed out, the growth and soundness of the church in the long run depend on leaders serving by the grace of God rather than other sources of power.

Trond Bruun Bergen, Norway

“Pastor, you are a good shepherd, but what we need is a CEO.” This was the counsel from one of the church leaders prior to a vote of no confidence regarding my pastoral leadership. I resigned, wondering about my future and that of the thousands of others pastors I learned were leaving ministry for reasons other than moral failure. I went on to have 15 more years of productive and enjoyable ministry. Recently, I happily retired after a total of 45 years in ministry. I simply want to say thank you.

Bruce R. Nelson Moorhead, MN

The Cross Is Our Stairway to Heaven

I resonated with the line in Jen Wilkin’s column: “Indeed, our stairway to heaven is not a ‘what’ but a ‘who.’ ” She cites John 1:51 in its traditional translations—angels ascending and descending “on the Son of Man.” Wilkin could have bolstered her point. The NLT and Amplified Bible more clearly identify Jesus as the stairway, as “the Son of Man, the one who is the stairway between heaven and earth.”

Evelyn Bence Arlington, VA

Pious Pledges and Consecrated Keggers

As I come upon my 18th year as a sister of Sigma Alpha Omega, I’m thrilled to see such a well-done piece highlighting the ministry that is Christian Greek life. I especially applaud the final section emphasizing that Christian sororities and fraternities are not intended to be a replacement for church but an additional fellowship and opportunity for Christian growth and development. While a student at North Carolina State University, my sorority sisters often drove me to church each Sunday when I did not otherwise have a ride, invited me to Campus Crusade and InterVarsity, and held me accountable to “not forsaking the assembling” with other believers outside of just my sisterhood.

Elizabeth Lusk Kroner,Sigma Alpha Omega Covington, KY

Working Harder to Understand Laziness

When Jesus comes, he will not ask whether we interviewed someone regarding their poverty and how they got here, nor what they’re going to do with the help we give them. He’ll ask if we fed and clothed them. I find most times that when people talk about laziness when it comes to poor people, they come from a place of judgment rather than compassion.

Dawit Baisa

Tempted in Every Way?

Oliver Crisp gets closer than most but still ends up like the rest of us, with a Jesus who’s invincible in the face of temptation. When God’s people are tempted, sometimes we sin, sometimes we resist. Jesus never sinned, always resisted, but only after desperate battle. If the Scriptures that showed us his deity are comfortable with this, why aren’t we? If Jesus was invincible in the face of temptation, then he was not made in every respect as we are and he was not tempted in every respect as we are. He does not understand our weakness from his own experience, and we have rejected Hebrews at a critical point.

Ed Neufeld,Providence Theological Seminary Otterburne, Manitoba, Canada

Also in this issue

The CT archives are a rich treasure of biblical wisdom and insight from our past. Some things we would say differently today, and some stances we've changed. But overall, we're amazed at how relevant so much of this content is. We trust that you'll find it a helpful resource.

Cover Story

The Hidden Cost of Tax Exemption

Paul Matzko

Cover Story

What A Church Does, in Dollars and Cents

News

US Religion Census Maps Changing Churches, Declining Denominations

News

The New Face of Medical Missions

Susan Mettes

News

Gleanings: Jan/Feb 2020

CT Staff

We Need to Read the Bible Jesus Read

Brent A. Strawn

Americans Are Having Fewer Kids. Evangelicals Are No Exception.

Liuan Huska

New & Noteworthy Fiction

Heather Day Gilbert

Review

Our Lives Aren’t Conducive to Prayer. But a Better Way Is Possible.

Justin Whitmel Earley

Review

Her Son Took up Heroin. She Was the One Whose World Unraveled.

Anne Kennedy

To Touch or Not to Touch?

Interview by Abby Perry

Testimony

What Bill Maher, Donald Miller, and John Piper Have in Common

John Joseph

Sacred Duties

News

Should Methodists Split into Two, Three, or Four Churches? Delegates Consider.

God Works Within Us and Beyond Us

Lighting the Way Back Home

Editorial

Christians in the Age of Callout Culture

God Will Not Speak to You Through Skywriting

When Prayer Requests Become Viral Hashtags

Excerpt

What If I’m Not the ‘Submissive’ Type?

Rebecca McLaughlin

Christianity Today’s 2020 Book Awards

View issue

Our Latest

Review

Today’s Christians Can Learn from Yesterday’s Pagans

Grace Hamman

Classicist Nadya Williams argues for believers reading the Greco-Roman classics.

Trading TikTok for Time with God—and Each Other

Some young Christians embrace lower-tech options.

Beyond the CT Book Award Winners

20 more suggestions from our editor in chief.

The Bulletin

Welcoming Christmas with Russell Moore, Clarissa Moll, and Steve Cuss

Steve Cuss, Clarissa Moll, Russell Moore

Hosts of CT Media podcasts discuss their Christmas traditions, memories, and advice for navigating the season.

The Christianity Today Book Awards

CT Editors

Our picks for the books most likely to shape evangelical life, thought, and culture.

Blaming Women Harms Us All

Dorothy Littell Greco

When we fail to protect and honor women like Jesus, we all lose.

Synthetic Love Will Tear Us Apart

When we outsource intimacy to machines, we become what we practice. And we’re practicing the wrong things.

Apple PodcastsDown ArrowDown ArrowDown Arrowarrow_left_altLeft ArrowLeft ArrowRight ArrowRight ArrowRight Arrowarrow_up_altUp ArrowUp ArrowAvailable at Amazoncaret-downCloseCloseEmailEmailExpandExpandExternalExternalFacebookfacebook-squareGiftGiftGooglegoogleGoogle KeephamburgerInstagraminstagram-squareLinkLinklinkedin-squareListenListenListenChristianity TodayCT Creative Studio Logologo_orgMegaphoneMenuMenupausePinterestPlayPlayPocketPodcastRSSRSSSaveSaveSaveSearchSearchsearchSpotifyStitcherTelegramTable of ContentsTable of Contentstwitter-squareWhatsAppXYouTubeYouTube