The First Amendment’s Establishment Clause is really quite simple: “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion.” But religious groups, civil libertarians, and even Supreme Court justices continue to differ over exactly what that means. This spring, two key religion cases could afford the high court an opportunity to provide new definitions for proper church and state boundaries.
Since 1971, the Court has used the so-called Lemon test to determine whether a government action constituted the establishment of religion. Under that framework, a government action must have a “secular purpose,” its primary effect must neither advance nor inhibit religion, and it must not foster “excessive government entanglement with religion.”
In Zobrest v. Catalina Foothills School District, justices are considering whether the state of Arizona should have provided a sign-language interpreter for a deaf student who attended a Catholic school. Under the federal Individuals With Disabilities Education Act, James Zobrest was eligible for such a government-financed interpreter.
School district attorney John Richardson told the Court, “We draw the line at a public employee … going to work and conveying to Jimmy Zobrest that Jesus Christ was the son of God and died to save his sins.”
However, attorney William Bentley Ball, arguing for the Zobrest family, said the Establishment Clause would not have been violated because an interpreter merely would be “serving as this child’s ears,” enabling the child to hear, not advancing religion.
Bradley Jacob, executive director of the Christian Legal Society (CLS), said the issue is fair treatment for religious students. “Every other deaf student in Arizona is entitled to a sign interpreter ...
1
You have reached the end of this Article Preview
To continue reading, subscribe now. Subscribers have full digital access.
You have reached the end of this Article Preview
Three women have come forward with additional allegations against the late Christian apologist.
Drugs had derailed my baseball career and driven me to despair. A chance encounter with a retired pastor changed everything.
Woman of Faith speaker celebrated life of singleness.
