I like writers I can argue with as I turn the pages, and the eminent Catholic thinker George Weigelalways clear and decisive in his judgmentsfills the bill. Broadly sympathetic at the outset to his "call for action," I found myself frequently noting passages that seemed simplistic, inflated in their rhetoric. I ended with more understanding for critics of American policy with whom Weigel and I both disagreenot exactly the author's intention, but I thank him for it anyway.
Understanding Four Views on the Lord's Supper
John H. Armstrong, ed.
The format of this volume, framed by the editor's helpful introduction and conclusion, encourages give-and-take among the representatives of the four views: Russell D. Moore, Baptist ("Christ's Presence as Memorial"); I. John Hesselink, Reformed ("The Real Presence of Christ"); David P. Scaer, Lutheran ("Finding the Right Word"); and Thomas A. Baima, Catholic ("Christ's True, Real, and Substantial Presence"). I was raised with the Baptist view but have come to believe in Christ's Real Presence, a great mystery that should be at the heart of our worship, and I pray for a rediscovery of the Eucharist among evangelicals even as I respect the different views of my fellow believers.
Born Standing Up: A Comic's Life
"In a sense," Martin writes, "this book is not an autobiography but a biography, because I am writing about someone I used to know." A friend asked me if the book was funny. No, I saidthough it's full of irony and wit as well as sadness and pain (especially Martin's lingering memory of his father's aloofness and "unprovoked hostility"), and the razor-sharp observation that ...1