India: Christians Scorn ‘China Model’

Christians Scorn ‘China Model’ Fundamentalist Hindu leader’s proposal would oust missionaries.

The chief of India’s leading Hindu fundamentalist group RSS (National Volunteer Corps) publicly proposed in October that Christians in India submit to a “China model” that includes state control, church registration, and severed ties to foreign missions groups.

Christian leaders throughout India scorned the proposal, which further soured relations between India’s Hindu majority and the nation’s 38 million Christians.

Earlier this year, there was hope of dialogue between top Hindu and Christian leaders. But efforts to schedule meetings between the groups broke down into finger-pointing and mutual suspicion.

“We feel there is now a greater need for dialogue, as it would give us an opportunity to clarify our stand and highlight our contribution, not merely as Christians, but as citizens of the country,” says Dominic Emmanuel of the Catholic Bishops Conference of India.

Emmanuel believes RSS chief K. S. Sudarshan’s call to expel missionaries threatens minorities. “Faith is not bound by the national boundaries,” he says.

Hindus accuse Christian leaders of withdrawing from the talks, but Emmanuel says, “We believe in the basic Christian teaching of loving one another and everyone.” He wants reconciliation talks to include more than Hindus and Christians. (India includes sizable Muslim and Buddhist populations.)

“There was no question of withdrawal from the [meeting] as no one approached us,” says Bishop Karam Masih of Dehli.

Masih, of the Church of North India, supports talks that would exclude politically motivated Hindu nationalist groups. He favors inviting only spiritual and religious leaders to the discussions.

Stopping conversions

Hindu nationalists want India to become officially Hindu. Some resist efforts by India’s secular government to ensure constitutionally protected religious freedoms for all citizens, including the right to change faiths.

Vishnu Hari Dalmiya, president of the nationalist Vishwa Hindu Parishad (VHP), says any dialogue between Hindus and Christians hinges on the issue of religious conversion. “Talks will yield no results if Christians don’t stop converting people. There is no other issue than conversions.”

“Conversion can’t be an issue of discussion,” responds John Dayal of the All India Christian Council. “Freedom of religion is a constitutional right. The dialogue should be held with a view to strengthen the constitution, its secular fabric, and not to weaken it.”

“I am in my own country, on my own soil, and will not allow conversions by force and fraudulent means,” VHP senior leader Acharaya Giriraj Kishore said in an interview with Christianity Today.

“Foreign missionaries should withdraw from the country. Indian Christians are quite capable of carrying their mission. Foreign missionaries are fomenting terrorism in the northeastern Indian states.”

Hindu leaders accuse missionaries of circulating literature that mocks their deities or depicts them as horrible figures. “The missionaries are spreading shocking literature that distorts Hindu religion,” Acharaya Giriraj says. “We are always prepared for talks, but church leaders have no courage to confront us across the table as they always blame us but have no proof.”

Dayal says that holding talks is not a new thing. “Informal dialogue in the form of seminars and symposiums continues to take place. We invite Mr. Sudarshan for a talk too,” he says. “Talks should be held [without] an intention of confrontation.

“We are ready to talk to anybody with a clean and open mind, and a clean heart, to discuss the issues,” Dayal says. “The hate campaign and violence against Christians should be condemned.”

Christian groups in India have now organized demonstrations against the call by RSS for a state-controlled church. The All India Christian People’s Forum, a Christian action group, staged numerous sit-in demonstrations in late October.

In a statement to India’s federal president, K. R. Narayanan, the Christian forum urged the federal president to stop “the anti-minority campaign” of the RSS.

President Narayanan is widely seen as nonpartisan and concerned about religious extremism, but his constitutional powers to intervene are limited.

Copyright © 2000 Christianity Today. Click for reprint information.

Also in this issue

Anonymous Are the Peacemakers: The Nobel Peace Prize has brought fame to many peacemakers, but many unsung Christians have thwarted warfare by quiet, prayerful work.

Cover Story

Anonymous Are the Peacemakers

Briefs: North America

Quotations to Contemplate

Readers' Forum: Get Thou Over It!

Guest Columnist: Andy Crouch Crunching the Numbers

What Is Truth (About Pilate)?

Humility's Many Faces

Southern Baptists: Cracks in the Convention

Georgia: Can Jimmy Carter Say 'Farewell'?

Updates

Sexual Politics: InterVarsity Group on Probation

Bitter Pills

Intelligent Design: Design Interference

Outreach: More than 12 Steps

Chile: Leveling the Playing Field

Philippines: Hostage Drama Exposes Christians' Vulnerability

Briefs: The World

Uganda: Ebola Strikes Again

Messianic Ethiopians Face Discrimination

Not Just Another Megachurch

Wire Story

Jubilee 2000: Grassroots Activism Delivers Debt Relief

Review

The New/Old CCM

100 Years of Beatitude

Fellowship Without Borders

Reclaiming Santa

The Evolution of St. Nick

The Kinkade Crusade

The Making of an Original

Wire Story

Ariel Sharon: Mideast Peace Process Is Dead

Between the Temple Mount and a Hard Place

Brazil's Surging Spirituality

Kingdom Prodigy

The Business of Resurrection

Using Wesley's Old Playbook

From the CEO: Who's Who on the CTI Masthead

Real Political Realism

The Artist as Prophet

View issue

Our Latest

Public Theology Project

Russell Moore’s Favorite Books of 2024

The top 10 picks of CT’s editor in chief range from dystopian fiction to philosophy, with a dose of Sabbath poems, Inklings, and country music.

My Book Sales Stink. But I’m Glad I Took the Publishing Plunge.

Even though the experience bruised my ego, God redeemed it in surprising ways.

Latino Christians Deserve a Straight Answer on Immigration

The Russell Moore Show

A Conversation with Peggy Noonan

The Pulitzer Prize winner ponders who we are and what we may become.

A Better Trans Conversation

As the Supreme Court hears oral arguments on youth gender medicine, Christians must prepare to speak with love while holding fast to biblical truth.

Ethics Aren’t Graded on a Curve

President Joe Biden’s pardon of Hunter Biden was wrong, and no amount of bad behavior from Donald Trump changes that fact.

News

UK Christians Lament Landmark Vote to Legalize Assisted Dying 

Pro-life faith leaders say Parliament’s proposed bill fails to protect the vulnerable and fear it will “create more suffering and chaos.”

Strike Up the Band: Sixpence None the Richer Goes Back on Tour

With its perennial hit “Kiss Me” still in our ears and on our playlists, the Christian band reunites with nothing to prove.

Apple PodcastsDown ArrowDown ArrowDown Arrowarrow_left_altLeft ArrowLeft ArrowRight ArrowRight ArrowRight Arrowarrow_up_altUp ArrowUp ArrowAvailable at Amazoncaret-downCloseCloseEmailEmailExpandExpandExternalExternalFacebookfacebook-squareGiftGiftGooglegoogleGoogle KeephamburgerInstagraminstagram-squareLinkLinklinkedin-squareListenListenListenChristianity TodayCT Creative Studio Logologo_orgMegaphoneMenuMenupausePinterestPlayPlayPocketPodcastRSSRSSSaveSaveSaveSearchSearchsearchSpotifyStitcherTelegramTable of ContentsTable of Contentstwitter-squareWhatsAppXYouTubeYouTube