Southern Baptists: Cracks in the Convention

Texas South Baptists slash $5 million from Southern Baptist Convention.

Ben Condray considers himself theologically conservative and a traditional Southern Baptist. Yet he takes issue with the national convention’s requirement that its seminary professors and denominational leaders agree with the amended Baptist Faith and Message, approved earlier this year. In Texas, that makes him a moderate. “For the last 150 years, Baptists haven’t believed in creeds,” Condray says. “[They are] something I can’t support.”

The staff counselor at First Baptist Church of Midlothian, Texas, served as a messenger (delegate) from his church to the Baptist General Convention of Texas (BGCT) convention, held earlier this week. He finds himself in step with the denomination’s Texas convention, which cut more than $5 million in funding for the convention’s six seminaries, the Southern Baptist Executive Committee, and the Ethics and Religious Liberty Commission. The move came at the BGCT gathering October 30-31. The money will be redirected to three theological schools in Texas. Although the loss of $5 million is significant, none of the agencies or seminaries to lose money has announced a budget cut.

The issues important to Condray and his fellow Texans include local church autonomy and the right for individual Baptists to interpret Scripture.

Some 6,700 messengers from Southern Baptist churches across Texas overwhelmingly voted for the funding cut. Among other actions, convention messengers voted to allow Baptists from outside Texas to serve on BGCT governing boards.

“No Baptist coerces other Baptists about what they have to believe. That’s not how you share the gospel,” says David Currie of Texas Baptists Committed, a support organization for moderate Baptist churches.

“We have the right to partner with whomever we want. It was poor stewardship to partner with Southern Baptist seminaries that were fundamentalist and do not teach historic Baptist doctrines.”

Moderates complain that Southern Baptist conservatives who have controlled the denomination since 1979 refuse to allow them positions in leadership.

They decry what they view as legalism in the Southern Baptist Convention’s refusal to allow differing opinions on the meaning of Scripture, such as women in the pastorate, and accuse its leaders of wedding the denomination to the Religious Right. BGCT president Clyde Glazener told messengers that religious leaders of Jesus’ day used the law as a club to beat others into line and spoke against those who use the Bible to claim all others are liberals.

“The best friend to true liberalism is. … a loveless, witch-hunting fundamentalism,” Glazener said. “The thing liberalism and fundamentalism most have in common is that they both think they have God in their hip pockets.”

As for the Baptist Faith and Message, the amended version of this statement of faith omits the phrase included in the 1963 statement, “The criterion by which the Bible is to be interpreted is Jesus Christ.” This omission troubles moderates, who value traditional Baptist doctrines, including the priesthood of the believer. Moderates reject forcing leaders and professors to adhere to the 2000 statement as “creedalism,” a litmus test of sorts for believers, which Baptists have long stood against.

But SBC president James Merritt, in an interview with Christianity Today, says that requiring seminary professors to agree with the basic tenets of faith is not creedalism. The professors have had to sign an abstract of principle, stating the theological parameters around which they must teach, since the seminaries were founded, he says. “It only stands to reason that any professor teaching in a Baptist school should be willing to fully support that Baptist denomination’s confession of faith,” Merritt says.

“So that does not in any sense make it a creed. It just means that we are holding those people who work in the seminaries accountable for what they teach. I don’t know why it’s such a big issue now.

“I still see nothing in the new Baptist Faith and Message that would cause any professor who is a true theological conservative to be uncomfortable in signing.”

Merritt says that he understands the Texas moderates’ concerns, but that the integrity of the denomination is at stake. “They’re upset over what they’ve been upset over for the last 20 years, and that is, we have turned our denomination away from theological liberalism, and in fact had theological liberals teaching in our seminaries, to a denomination [that] has returned to its biblical roots of believing the Bible is the total, inerrant word of God,” he says. “That’s the real issue.”

Texas moderates, such as Condray, disagree. They maintain there are very few, if any, liberals in the denomination. “You wouldn’t find anyone in the convention hall who didn’t believe the Bible,” he says. The problem is, however, “There are 14 different definitions of inerrancy.” The dispute is interpretation, he says, and moderates disagree with conservatives’ rigid meaning to some Scripture passages that they believe are open for discussion.

Both conservatives and moderates lament that these ongoing disputes are causing further fractures within the nation’s largest Protestant denomination. “There’s no joy in my camp, and hopefully there’s no joy on the other side,” Merritt says. “I still have faith that Southern Baptists in Texas will do the right thing.”

Most Texas Baptists would welcome reconciliation but believe the two sides are too far apart to come together. “I believe I understand how a child feels when their parents are going to get a divorce,” says Clint Davis, a convention messenger and pastor from Mount Pleasant.

A messenger at the Texas convention moved that the BGCT look into calling in a professional Christian peacemaker to seek reconciliation with the SBC. The motion passed and will be considered by a BGCT committee.

Would the SBC be open to that? “Obviously, we would be open to reconciliation wherever reconciliation is possible,” Merritt says. “I don’t know if we need Christian mediators because we’re both Christians. Surely there’s enough spiritual maturity on both sides to where if there is room for reconciliation, we can sit down at a table and meet.”

But Merritt isn’t optimistic. He said that three previous attempts to discuss the matter with Texas Baptists failed. “I’m kind of intrigued that now they want to call for mediation and reconciliation. They do need to understand up front that there are certain non-negotiables, and I can tell you that the Baptist Faith and Message as it stands is a non-negotiable.”

Is there hope for mending the rift? “There’s always hope,” says Ken Sande of Peacemaker Ministries, the Billings, Montana-based group that mediates disputes between Christians. “Read Ephesians 2 and you know there’s hope. It’s not because of who we are, but because of who Jesus is.”

Related Elsewhere

For coverage from a moderate Baptist perspective read the Associated Baptist stories “Texas Baptists ratify reduced SBC funding” and “Wade cites SBC’s ‘rigid limitations’ as cause for rift with Texas Baptists.”

Or read “Texas convention weighs reconciliation with the Southern Baptist Convention” from Baptist Press, which is affiliated with the Southern Baptist Convention.

Other media coverage of the Baptist General Convention of Texas’s recent moves includes:

Texas Baptists look toward new future—The Associated Press (Nov. 1, 2000)

Texas Baptists cut funds to convention seminaries—The Washington Times (October 31, 2000)

Texas Baptists vote for change—The Boston Globe (October 31, 2000)

U.S. Baptists embroiled in uncivil war—The National Post (October 31, 2000)

Southern Baptists at Odds—The Washington Post (October 30, 2000)

Texas Baptists approve partial break with their denomination—The Miami Herald (October 30, 2000)

Copyright © 2000 Christianity Today. Click for reprint information.

Also in this issue

Anonymous Are the Peacemakers: The Nobel Peace Prize has brought fame to many peacemakers, but many unsung Christians have thwarted warfare by quiet, prayerful work.

Cover Story

Anonymous Are the Peacemakers

Briefs: North America

Quotations to Contemplate

Readers' Forum: Get Thou Over It!

Guest Columnist: Andy Crouch Crunching the Numbers

What Is Truth (About Pilate)?

Humility's Many Faces

Georgia: Can Jimmy Carter Say 'Farewell'?

Updates

Sexual Politics: InterVarsity Group on Probation

Bitter Pills

Intelligent Design: Design Interference

Outreach: More than 12 Steps

Chile: Leveling the Playing Field

Philippines: Hostage Drama Exposes Christians' Vulnerability

Briefs: The World

Uganda: Ebola Strikes Again

India: Christians Scorn 'China Model'

Messianic Ethiopians Face Discrimination

Not Just Another Megachurch

Wire Story

Jubilee 2000: Grassroots Activism Delivers Debt Relief

Review

The New/Old CCM

100 Years of Beatitude

Fellowship Without Borders

Reclaiming Santa

The Evolution of St. Nick

The Kinkade Crusade

The Making of an Original

Wire Story

Ariel Sharon: Mideast Peace Process Is Dead

Between the Temple Mount and a Hard Place

Brazil's Surging Spirituality

Kingdom Prodigy

The Business of Resurrection

Using Wesley's Old Playbook

From the CEO: Who's Who on the CTI Masthead

Real Political Realism

The Artist as Prophet

View issue

Our Latest

News

Investigation to Look at 82 Years of Missionary School Abuse

Adult alumni “commanded a seat at the table” to negotiate for full inquiry.

Have Yourself an Enchanted Little Advent

Angels are everywhere in the Bible. The Christmas season reminds us to take them seriously.

News

Western North Carolina’s Weary Hearts Rejoice for Christmas

The holiday isn’t the same with flooded tree farms and damaged churches from Helene, but locals find cheer in recovery.

News

In Italy, Evangelicals Wage a Quiet War on Christmas

Born-again Christians say the holiday is too Catholic and the celebration of Jesus’ birth isn’t based on the Bible.

The Bulletin

Exalting Every Valley with Charles King

The Bulletin welcomes historian Charles King for a conversation with Clarissa Moll about the modern relevance of Handel’s Messiah

News

After Assad: Jihad or Liberty?

A coalition of rebel fighters promises to respect Syria’s religious minorities.

Chick-fil-A Launches an App to Help Families Be Less Online

It offers the wholesome, values-centered content Christians expect from the closed-on-Sundays chain, but does the platform undercut its message?

Egypt’s Redemption—and Ours

The flight of the holy family is more than a historical curiosity. It points us toward the breadth and beauty of God’s redemption.

Apple PodcastsDown ArrowDown ArrowDown Arrowarrow_left_altLeft ArrowLeft ArrowRight ArrowRight ArrowRight Arrowarrow_up_altUp ArrowUp ArrowAvailable at Amazoncaret-downCloseCloseEmailEmailExpandExpandExternalExternalFacebookfacebook-squareGiftGiftGooglegoogleGoogle KeephamburgerInstagraminstagram-squareLinkLinklinkedin-squareListenListenListenChristianity TodayCT Creative Studio Logologo_orgMegaphoneMenuMenupausePinterestPlayPlayPocketPodcastRSSRSSSaveSaveSaveSearchSearchsearchSpotifyStitcherTelegramTable of ContentsTable of Contentstwitter-squareWhatsAppXYouTubeYouTube