Fraud: Jury Convicts Greater Ministries of Fraud

Five leaders face jail time for one of the largest Ponzi operations ever

Five leaders of Greater Ministries International Church were convicted in federal court on a total of 72 counts of conspiracy, wire and mail fraud, and money laundering, in one of the largest church fraud schemes in American history.

The five—Gerald Payne, 63, Greater Ministries’ pastor; Betty Payne, 60, his wife and the church secretary; missions director Haywood “Don” Hall, 58; financial administrator David Whitfield, 47; and legal director Patrick Talbert, 51—were immediately taken into custody after the March 12 verdict was delivered, pending sentencing. They face 25 to 190 years in prison. Their trial lasted six weeks, and the jury deliberated for three days.

Two other defendants, Andrew Krishak, 48, and James Chambers, 67, had earlier pleaded guilty to one conspiracy count each and testified for the prosecution. The charges stemmed from Greater Ministries’ “gifting” program, which operated nationwide through most of the 1990s under various names, from “Double Your Money” to “the Faith Promises Program.” Citing Luke 6:38, “Give and it will be given unto you,” Greater Ministries leaders told givers they would double their money in approximately 17 months.

The profits to finance this doubling, Greater Ministries claimed, would come from God’s blessing, and the church’s holdings of fabulously rich diamond, gold, and platinum mines in the United States and Africa. But the government charged that there were never any profits, only a series of feckless and failed mining ventures in Liberia. Investors (called “gifters” by Greater Ministries) who received money were paid with the funds of later investors—the classic definition of a Ponzi scheme.

In addition, insiders of Greater Ministries were paid monthly commissions on the investments they brought in. During the scheme’s heyday, these individual commissions totaled tens of thousands of dollars monthly. Jurors watched defendant Don Hall, on a videotape made by Greater Ministries, warning the insiders never to speak of this “gas money” to gifters or anyone outside their ranks.

Christians all over the country flocked to Greater Ministries’ meetings, which blended gospel singing and lively preaching with intensive sales pitches. An Internal Revenue Service special agent, Douglas Evaul, said after the trial that “this organization was involved with more than 18,000 investors and $448 million.”

The operation collapsed in the summer of 1998, when a shady bank in Colorado suddenly failed and its owners disappeared, causing Greater Ministries to lose almost $20 million in uninsured deposits. Distressed gifters have since filed claims for losses in excess of $190 million with Greater Ministries’ bankruptcy trustee. But the trustee has found only a few million dollars worth of assets to distribute, and the thousands of victims will recover little, if anything.

In the New Era financial scam, which collapsed in 1995, 1,100 individuals and more than 180 evangelical groups were defrauded. Though initial losses were estimated in the hundreds of millions of dollars, the final losses were limited to $135 million after charities participated in a unique plan to share their net gains and losses from New Era.

During defense testimony, witnesses contended that the money they sent to Greater Ministries was purely a gift, as stated on the program’s forms, and that they did not expect any return beyond God’s blessing. But prosecutors countered with a long list of other gifters who swore that they had been promised a doubling of their money. The government also called Michael Payne, Gerald Payne’s son, who testified under a grant of immunity that his father was a skilled manipulator who “brainwashed” people, and ran Greater Ministries as a kind of cult.

Jurors watched another videotape in which Gerald Payne told insiders of plans to buy one of the Grand Cayman islands, proclaim it an independent “ecclesiastical” nation, and defend it against any police agencies with a large arsenal they had secretly assembled. Greater Ministries solicited gifters to give money to purchase the island, to be called Greaterlands.

Attorney Dan Daly, who defended David Whitfield, told Christianity Today that the verdicts would be appealed. “The sufficiency of the government’s evidence will certainly be in dispute,” he said. “And the appellate court will have to pass on some First Amendment issues embedded in the case.”

These issues were raised principally by Patrick Talbert, who has long been involved in anti-government movements. Talbert’s attorney, John Kingston, said that Talbert and the other defendants were standing up for the freedom of Christians to believe and support their church as they choose, without government interference.

The elders are due to be sentenced in June.

Copyright © 2001 Christianity Today. Click for reprint information.

Related Elsewhere

Christianity Today‘s earlier coverage of Greater Ministries includes:

Weblog: Greater Ministries Found Guilty of ‘One of the Largest Ponzi-Type Schemes Ever Investigated’ (Mar. 13, 2001)

Defrauding the Faithful | If convicted, Greater Ministries defendants face massive fines, prison terms. (Feb. 8, 2001)

$100 Million Missing in Greater Ministries Scandal (Oct. 4, 1999)

Federal Authorities Collar Greater Ministry Leaders | Accusations include fraud, money laundering. (Apr. 26, 1999)

Judge Orders Gift Refunds | Greater Ministries found in contempt of court. (Mar. 1, 1999)

A Gospel Gold Mine or a Sinking Pyramid? | Greater Ministries International promises eye-popping returns, but investigators suspect a Ponzi. (Jan. 11, 1999)

Greater Ministries International Church has an official Web site, with a feature called Legal Eagle that follows the ministries court proceedings. The page claims that Greater Ministries has helped poor and starving people worldwide and bailed out several churches in debt.

The Tampa Tribune offers many past Greater Ministries news stories.

Also in this issue

Myth Matters: Why C.S. Lewis's books remain models for Christian apologists in the 21st century.

Cover Story

Myth Matters

My House, God's House

Old Wisdom for New Times

Reimagining Missions

Slouching into Sloth

Unfair Use Alleged

Homosexuality: Presbyterians Vote Down Same-Sex Prohibition

Church-State: Evangelicals Squabble Over Charitable Choice

Briefs: North America

Readers' Forum: Truth at Risk

New Study Reveals Which Churches Grow

Sri Lanka: Christians Mediate for Peace

Jerusalem: Holy Land Roadblocks

Briefs: The World

India: Christians Help Overlooked Villages

Zambia: Church Leaders Publicly Oppose Third Term for Christian President

Brunei: Christians in Detention for Prayer

Making Space for God

Wire Story

Updates: Defrocked Episcopal Bishop Resigns

Wire Story

Anglicans: Discipline of Episcopal Church Derailed

Wire Story

Equal Access Case Argued

Wire Story

Christian Zionists Rally for Jewish State

2001 Christianity Today Book Awards

Review

Rap's Demon-Slayer

The Wright Stuff

News

Left Behind: Author LaHaye Sues Left Behind Film Producers

Life Is Unfair (and That’s Okay)

Latest Books by CT Staff

Letters

The Morality Supermarket

Bad Ideas Have Consequences

The Violent Face of Jihad in Indonesia

Quotations to Stir Mind and Heart

View issue

Our Latest

News

Church of England Leaders Kept Evangelical Beatings Secret

Archbishop Justin Welby resigns after abuse report exposes cover-up dating back to 1982.

Review

New & Noteworthy Books

Chosen by Matt Reynolds, CT senior books editor.

News

Recovery Ministries Help Portland Get Clean

After an attempt to decriminalize drugs made the addiction crisis in Oregon even worse, local Christians are pleading with the sick—and the state—to let them help.

A Solution for Seasonal Overwhelm

Focusing on the few in front of us makes a tangible difference in our local communities.

News

Finding Sobriety—and Jesus—in Vietnam’s Christian Drug Rehabs

The country’s church-run addiction centers are so effective that communist officials are taking notice.

Review

The Black Church Has Five Theological Anchors

Walter Strickland’s sweeping narrative of African American Christianity portrays a big God who is strong to deliver.

Review

Tending and Keeping the Christian Past in an ‘Ahistoric Age’

Why the work of historical stewardship isn’t just for historians.

Apple PodcastsDown ArrowDown ArrowDown Arrowarrow_left_altLeft ArrowLeft ArrowRight ArrowRight ArrowRight Arrowarrow_up_altUp ArrowUp ArrowAvailable at Amazoncaret-downCloseCloseEmailEmailExpandExpandExternalExternalFacebookfacebook-squareGiftGiftGooglegoogleGoogle KeephamburgerInstagraminstagram-squareLinkLinklinkedin-squareListenListenListenChristianity TodayCT Creative Studio Logologo_orgMegaphoneMenuMenupausePinterestPlayPlayPocketPodcastRSSRSSSaveSaveSaveSearchSearchsearchSpotifyStitcherTelegramTable of ContentsTable of Contentstwitter-squareWhatsAppXYouTubeYouTube