Does God Know Your Next Move?

Part 1:Introduction | John Sanders 1 | Chris Hall 1 | Sanders 2 | Hall 2

Part 2:John Sanders 3 | Chris Hall 3 | Sanders 4 | Hall 4 | Sanders 5 | Postscript

Dear John,

How about your interpretation of Judas’s betrayal of Jesus? I would argue that this narrative clearly demonstrates God’s perfect and complete knowledge of the future. Jesus is not caught off guard by Judas’s action. Rather, Jesus demonstrates a full awareness of what Judas is soon to do (Matt. 26:23-25). Perhaps even more telling, however, is the comment of Matthew that the purchase of the potter’s field with Judas’s blood money and its subsequent naming as the “Field of Blood” fulfilled a prophecy of Jeremiah made hundreds of years before the event (Matt. 27:5-10).

I find your interpretation of the Judas narrative [outlined in a previous unpublished e-mail] to be both selective and strained. First, you appear to base your explanation of Judas’s actions on the highly idiosyncratic interpretation of William Klassen, a study you argue “demonstrates that Judas was not ‘betraying’ Jesus.” Is Judas, as Klassen and you seem to believe, acting to bring the high priest and Jesus together so that they “could resolve their differences and bring about needed reforms”? When Jesus tells Judas to “[d]o quickly what you are going to do,” does this instruction truly violate “a fundamental rule of Judaism” by telling Judas “to go out and deliberately commit a sin”? You appear convinced by Klassen, writing that “in this light it is clear that Judas is not betraying Jesus and that Jesus is not issuing any prediction of such activity.” I remain unconvinced, especially because of the role Jesus assigns to Satan in Judas’s activities.

Second, you argue that paradidomi “does not mean ‘betray’ to the temple authorities.” Why not? Liddell and Scott [in Liddell-Scott’s Greek-English Lexicon] provide clear instances in secular Greek sources where paradidomi does mean betray. If so, why can’t it mean betray here?

Third, you write that “because Judas has come to symbolize villainy, we tend to think that Jesus’ words are clear and that everything is working out according to some foreordained plan.” I don’t agree. Judas is almost invariably considered a villain in the history of interpretation because that is precisely how Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John portray him. John, for example, gives us a glimpse into Judas’s character when he explains the motive behind Judas’s objection to Jesus’ anointing at Bethany. “He did not say this because he cared about the poor but because he was a thief; as keeper of the money bag, he used to help himself to what was put into it.” If such was Judas’s character, it seems plausible to me to view his betrayal of Jesus as an opportunity for Judas to make a quick buck that goes terribly awry; I don’t think Judas realized his short-sighted action would lead to Jesus’ death.

While you don’t see the Judas narrative linked “to some foreordained plan,” Matthew clearly makes such a connection through his reference to Jeremiah’s prophecy (Matt. 27:9-10). Peter also distinctly connects Judas’s actions and fate to a prophecy spoken “through the mouth of David” (Acts 1:16). Neither Matthew’s nor Peter’s comments make sense if this predictive/prophetic element is drained out of the Judas narrative.

As I mentioned earlier, strikingly absent from your discussion of Judas is any mention of the role of Satan in the whole affair, while Matthew insists that “Satan entered Judas” the evening of the Last Supper, indicating that demonic motivation or inspiration lay behind Judas’s thoughts and actions (cf. Matt. 22:3). Not only so, but John had previously informed his reader of the shady character of Judas. Jesus, it seems to me, clearly predicts Judas’s betrayal in John 13, just as he predicted the exact number of times Peter would betray Jesus.

How, by the way, could Jesus possibly know that Peter would choose to deny him three times if God cannot know beforehand the choices of free individuals, a position held by many openness theologians? Was Peter not free? Did God force him to deny Jesus? Was he simply a puppet? If so, why would Jesus consider him morally responsible for his actions and call him to repentance and renewal in John 21?

Blessings,Chris

John Sanders replies, next page.

Copyright © 2001 Christianity Today. Click for reprint information.

Also in this issue

Solitary Refinement: Evangelical assumptions about singleness still need rethinking.

Cover Story

Solitary Refinement

Schools: School Fights Christian Athletes Club

Quotations to Stir Mind and Heart

Conservation: Protecting Bald Eagles and Babies

Sudan: No Greater Tragedy

Resisting Relevancy

Significance in a Small Package

Resisting Church Divorce

Merchants of Cool

"Education: Reading, Writing, Reform"

Health Fraud: Health Ministry in Receiership

Investor Fury: Elderly Investors Target Accountant

Briefs: North America

Wild Child: How Bad Is Child Care for Kids?

Few to Receive AIDS Medicines

Flying Unfriendly Skies

Briefs: The World

Malaysia: Muslim Leader Appeals to Evangelicals

Nigeria: Teens 'Rescued' from Muslim Marriages

Ecumenism: Pope Apologizes

Does God Know Your Next Move?

Does God Know Your Next Move?

Does God Know Your Next Move?

Does God Know Your Next Move?

Counteroffensive on RU-486

Wire Story

Indictments: Indictments Handed Down

Wire Story

Rainbow Ministry: Summit Equips Leaders for Ethnic Outreach

Wire Story

Islam Muslims Report Steady Growth

Review

Three Chords and the Truth

The Man Who Ignited the Debate

A Singular Mission Field

Surf Here Often?

Kissing Nonsense Goodbye

Does God Know Your Next Move?

Where Do We Go from Here?

Wire Story

Presbyterians Launch ’Confessing Movement’

Bush's Prolife Strategy Questioned

Basic Buddhism

Weighed Down by Karmic Debt

Blood and Tears in Tibet

Hollywood's Idol

Mind Over Skepticism

The Genesis of Our Woes

Revisiting Mt. Carmel

Putting Faith Back in Public Service

Straight Outta Dharamsala

Letters

View issue

Our Latest

News

Space Force Hymn Lifts Prayer to the Heavens

Southern Baptist chaplain says God prompted him to write song for the newest branch of the US military. 

Beijing, Let My Daughter Come Home

Power Without Integrity Destroys Us

Evangelicals helped elect Trump. Can evangelicals also hold him accountable?

The Bulletin

Sultan of Swing

The Bulletin addresses the election of Donald Trump.

What Another Trump Presidency Means To Evangelicals Around the World

Christian leaders from Nepal to Turkey greet the US election results with joy, grief, and indifference.

Our Faith’s Future Depends on Discipleship

The Lausanne Movement’s State of the Great Commission report details where and how Christianity is growing. 

News

Trump’s Promised Mass Deportations Put Immigrant Churches on Edge

Some of the president-elect’s proposals seem unlikely, but he has threatened to remove millions of both undocumented and legal immigrants.

God Is Faithful in Triumph and Despair

I voted for Kamala Harris and mourn her loss. But I want to keep politics in its proper place, subordinate to Jesus.

Apple PodcastsDown ArrowDown ArrowDown Arrowarrow_left_altLeft ArrowLeft ArrowRight ArrowRight ArrowRight Arrowarrow_up_altUp ArrowUp ArrowAvailable at Amazoncaret-downCloseCloseEmailEmailExpandExpandExternalExternalFacebookfacebook-squareGiftGiftGooglegoogleGoogle KeephamburgerInstagraminstagram-squareLinkLinklinkedin-squareListenListenListenChristianity TodayCT Creative Studio Logologo_orgMegaphoneMenuMenupausePinterestPlayPlayPocketPodcastRSSRSSSaveSaveSaveSearchSearchsearchSpotifyStitcherTelegramTable of ContentsTable of Contentstwitter-squareWhatsAppXYouTubeYouTube