Ideas

Resisting Relevancy

Columnist

The church suffers when pastors confuse anecdotes with parables

Jesus said “Feed my sheep,” not “Nurse my lambs.” I recorded this observation on the margin of a bulletin while sitting out a particularly simple-minded sermon in the back pew of a church I no longer attend.

Reformer John Calvin, so I’m told, claimed that stupidity is a sin. By this I assume he meant something like willful ignorance or mental sloth rather than limited native intelligence. Having witnessed for 20 years the squandering of intellectual resources in the dumbing down of school curricula and news media, I am now distressed to see the same trend at work in the church. When I retreat from the educational trenches to the sanctuary on Sunday, I too often find the meat of the Gospels boiled down to mush. Preachers I know to be intelligent human beings who love God and are called to proclaim the Word succumb to the downward pull of media culture by seeking to entertain rather than to challenge or to “re-mind”—to make us mindful. Homely references to daily life certainly have their place in sermons, but the temptation to compete with standup comedians or to indulge in mediaspeak for the sake of a spurious relevancy seems to be almost irresistible to clergy who think their flock comes only for the fun parts.

Amusing anecdotes don’t necessarily function as parables. References to New Yorker cartoons, Dilbert, Seinfeld, or Star Wars might serve to illustrate a point, but too often digress rather than direct our attention to the Word that hangs like a plumb line in a crooked world. Moreover, invoking popular culture can have the dubious effect of endorsing it. A reference to Seinfeld suggests that we all watch it and chuckle together over its variable repertoire of narcissistic preoccupations and flip one-liners. And Seinfeld, from what I can tell by a limited sampling, offers marginally more than most sitcoms, on which typical conversations endure no more than 45 seconds, most transactions are exercises in one-upmanship, and few people are old, poor, sick, or wrestling with the complexities of real moral dilemmas.

Dipping into the familiar fare of film, television, or the Internet is only one form of dumbing down. Others may be worse. Certain ways of sentimentalizing, oversimplifying, or sweetening Jesus amount to blasphemy. In one of her many moments of shocking lucidity, Flannery O’Connor claimed that sentimentality is to Christianity what pornography is to love. There’s not much room for healthy fear of the Lord in a theology that makes Jesus everyone’s best pal.

The outright bafflement of the disciples must itself seem baffling to those who rest comfortable in the belief that they “know” the Lord on such intimate terms that they need only ask themselves “What would Jesus do?” to arrive at an immediate solution to any moral dilemma. How is it, I wonder, that they’re so sure they know what Jesus would do? The very disciples who followed him around appear to have been regularly taken by surprise.

What Jesus did do was most often characterized by counterintuitive, jolting, baffling, puzzling, or unconventional moves that even his closest followers seemed unable to predict or interpret. His parables were riddles. His teaching was always loving, sometimes comforting, often disturbing, and full of paradox. People met him and changed their lives, went home rejoicing or sorrowing, plunged into self-examination or action of kinds they never would have thought to take on.

Sermons (not to mention praise songs and Sunday-school fare) betray their cause when they don’t challenge us to think and act counterculturally; to review and rethink the norms that numb; to look squarely at poverty, injustice, and irresponsible policymaking and recognize our own participatory responsibility; or to work for the Kingdom rather than serving corporate interests. Reinhold Niebuhr’s provocative maxim about the function of sermons—”to comfort the afflicted and afflict the comfortable”—sets a usable standard. Most of us, as Americans, are by definition in the latter group, though we all also live with the various ills that flesh is heir to.

The Walt Disney Company isn’t going to provide the salutary affliction we need. The screens and billboards we look at offer narcotics to conscience. The church has the only antidote that will work against materialism and media addiction. And, like most antidotes, it may have to hurt to heal.

Copyright © 2001 Christianity Today. Click for reprint information.

Related Elsewhere

Christianity Today‘s sister publication Leadership has more discussion on preaching and communicating Christian truth in a relevant way. One such article discusses lessons from a stand-up comedy course.

Previous McEntyre columns for Christianity Today include:

My House, God’s House | Hospitality is not merely good manners but a ministry of healing. (May 9, 2001)

Rx for Moral Fussbudgets | Good guilt entails more than repentance for merely personal sins. (Mar. 19, 2001)

Community, Not Commodity | Let us acknowledge, and even mourn, what we lose when worship meets media. (Jan. 16, 2001)

Nice Is Not the Point | Sometimes love is sharp, hard-edged, confusing, and seemingly unfair. (Nov. 29, 2000)

The Fullness of Time | I’d like life to be a series of pauses like a poem, rather than a fast-paced, page-turner airport novel. (Oct. 12, 2000)

‘I’ve Been Through Things’ | Meditating on “Honor your father and your mother.” (Sept. 6, 2000)

Silence Is to Dwell In | An hour of quiet is a rare gift, hard to come by in an ordinary week, even for those who seek it. (Aug. 10, 2000)

Also in this issue

Solitary Refinement: Evangelical assumptions about singleness still need rethinking.

Cover Story

Solitary Refinement

Schools: School Fights Christian Athletes Club

Quotations to Stir Mind and Heart

Conservation: Protecting Bald Eagles and Babies

Sudan: No Greater Tragedy

Significance in a Small Package

Resisting Church Divorce

Merchants of Cool

"Education: Reading, Writing, Reform"

Health Fraud: Health Ministry in Receiership

Investor Fury: Elderly Investors Target Accountant

Briefs: North America

Wild Child: How Bad Is Child Care for Kids?

Few to Receive AIDS Medicines

Flying Unfriendly Skies

Briefs: The World

Malaysia: Muslim Leader Appeals to Evangelicals

Nigeria: Teens 'Rescued' from Muslim Marriages

Ecumenism: Pope Apologizes

Does God Know Your Next Move?

Does God Know Your Next Move?

Does God Know Your Next Move?

Does God Know Your Next Move?

Does God Know Your Next Move?

Counteroffensive on RU-486

Wire Story

Indictments: Indictments Handed Down

Wire Story

Rainbow Ministry: Summit Equips Leaders for Ethnic Outreach

Wire Story

Islam Muslims Report Steady Growth

Review

Three Chords and the Truth

The Man Who Ignited the Debate

A Singular Mission Field

Surf Here Often?

Kissing Nonsense Goodbye

Does God Know Your Next Move?

Where Do We Go from Here?

Wire Story

Presbyterians Launch ’Confessing Movement’

Bush's Prolife Strategy Questioned

Basic Buddhism

Weighed Down by Karmic Debt

Blood and Tears in Tibet

Hollywood's Idol

Mind Over Skepticism

The Genesis of Our Woes

Revisiting Mt. Carmel

Putting Faith Back in Public Service

Straight Outta Dharamsala

Letters

View issue

Our Latest

News

Investigation to Look at 82 Years of Missionary School Abuse

Adult alumni “commanded a seat at the table” to negotiate for full inquiry.

Have Yourself an Enchanted Little Advent

Angels are everywhere in the Bible. The Christmas season reminds us to take them seriously.

News

Western North Carolina’s Weary Hearts Rejoice for Christmas

The holiday isn’t the same with flooded tree farms and damaged churches from Helene, but locals find cheer in recovery.

News

In Italy, Evangelicals Wage a Quiet War on Christmas

Born-again Christians say the holiday is too Catholic and the celebration of Jesus’ birth isn’t based on the Bible.

The Bulletin

Exalting Every Valley with Charles King

The Bulletin welcomes historian Charles King for a conversation with Clarissa Moll about the modern relevance of Handel’s Messiah

In the Divided Balkans, Evangelicals Are Tiny in Number, but Mighty

A leading Serbian researcher discusses how evangelicals have made a tangible difference.

Chick-fil-A Launches an App to Help Families Be Less Online

It offers the wholesome, values-centered content Christians expect from the closed-on-Sundays chain, but does the platform undercut its message?

Egypt’s Redemption—and Ours

The flight of the holy family is more than a historical curiosity. It points us toward the breadth and beauty of God’s redemption.

Apple PodcastsDown ArrowDown ArrowDown Arrowarrow_left_altLeft ArrowLeft ArrowRight ArrowRight ArrowRight Arrowarrow_up_altUp ArrowUp ArrowAvailable at Amazoncaret-downCloseCloseEmailEmailExpandExpandExternalExternalFacebookfacebook-squareGiftGiftGooglegoogleGoogle KeephamburgerInstagraminstagram-squareLinkLinklinkedin-squareListenListenListenChristianity TodayCT Creative Studio Logologo_orgMegaphoneMenuMenupausePinterestPlayPlayPocketPodcastRSSRSSSaveSaveSaveSearchSearchsearchSpotifyStitcherTelegramTable of ContentsTable of Contentstwitter-squareWhatsAppXYouTubeYouTube