Editor's note: February's cover package, "The Best Ways to Fight Poverty—Really" (part one, part two), received remarkable numbers of pageviews, praises, and protests. It also provoked responses from many organizations devoted to fighting poverty. Today, leaders of those ministries respond, including World Vision US president Richard Stearns, Samaritan's Purse president Franklin Graham, Habitat for Humanity International CEO Jonathan Reckford, HOPE International president and CEO Peter Greer, World Relief president and CEO Stephan Bauman, Food for the Hungry workers Greg Forney and Lucas Koach, and TEAR Australia national young adults coordinator Matt Anslow. Also today, Christianity Today senior managing editor Mark Galli, whose article "A Most Personal Touch" led off the February cover package, replies to the ministry leaders.
This week I have been eyewitness to the inadequacy of governments alone to solve the problems of poverty. Mark Galli argues that governments are the best institutions to raise the poor's standard of living. Yet over the past week I have visited the poor in Cambodia, and I can attest that while economic growth in Asia has been tremendous, government efforts are not enough to change the lives of the poor. The church and private nonprofits, on the other hand, can do exactly that.
Galli says the church is insignificant compared to the resources of government. But he seems oblivious to the scale and significance of American Christianity. Its power to reduce global poverty is massive—and could be even greater.
World Vision—just a portion of the American church's effort to alleviate poverty—spends roughly $2.8 billion annually to care for the poor. That would rank World Vision about 12th within the G20 nations in terms of overseas development assistance. In the U.S., private giving to international causes exceeds government humanitarian and development programs.
Yet poverty is extensive. Despite the progress toward the Millennium Development Goals, roughly 1.4 billion people live on less than $1.25 per day. Should we simply wait for the effects of government policies to work their way toward the poor? The answer should be obvious to anyone in our own country, where the latest census figures show that nearly half of Americans are either poor or low income.
Government policies that bring about economic growth are powerful factors in lifting people out of poverty. But as beneficial as growing income is, cultural and personal values are often a root cause of poverty and injustice. Relative to churches and faith based organizations, governments don't do so well at addressing community values, beliefs about right and wrong, and personal behavior.
A few days ago I met a girl who had been trapped in a brothel, forced to have sex with men. Ruse (not her real name) escaped only because of the work of International Justice Mission, who raided her brothel and took Ruse and others to World Vision's recovery center for victims of the sex trade. World Hope provided her with job training, and today she works as a nanny. Ruse is caring for her two younger brothers, taking them on Sundays to her Baptist church. This was a veritable "bucket brigade" of faith-based institutions.
The government's efforts to stop the sex trade have been ineffective because it cannot change core community values. But that's exactly what Christians do. Solving the causes of poverty requires both large-scale, top-down action and the compassion and social activism of the church.
The American church certainly has the ability to do it. Ending systematic poverty is possible if individual Christians respond and if the whole church exercises its massive resources and voice. When that happens, the church is neither ineffective nor impotent.
Copyright © 2012 Christianity Today. Click for reprint information.
Related Elsewhere:
February's cover package included:
The Best Ways to Fight Poverty—Really | The government is by far the best institution to raise the poor's standard of living. The church does something more important for them. By Mark Galli
Cost-Effective Compassion: The 10 Most Popular Strategies for Helping the Poor | Economists rate impact. By Bruce Wydick
Other replies today include:
Focus on Solving the Poverty of the Soul | Our aid to the poor should always address their area of greatest need. By Franklin Graham, president of Samaritan's Purse
What Do You Mean by Poverty? | Overcoming poverty is possible and proven. But superficiality has paralyzed the church. By Stephan Bauman, president and CEO of World Relief
We Can't Do Everything | But we can change systems to protect the poor, and that requires cooperation on all fronts. By Jonathan Reckford, CEO of Habitat for Humanity International
The Biggest Poverty-Fighting Tool: Job Creation | Employment for the poor restores their dignity and keeps them off their knees. By Peter Greer, president and CEO of HOPE International
Poverty Has Many Enemies | The solution does not require a choice between individuals and institutions. By Greg Forney and Lucas Koach, Food for the Hungry
The Local Church's Neighbors Are Everywhere | The church isn't just a network of institutions trying to stretch across the globe. By Matt Anslow, national young adults coordinator of TEAR Australia
Also, Mark Galli responds to the responses.
