News

Sensation Before Scholarship: Gospel Fragment Tantalizes Experts

Previous forgeries make announcements of new archeological discoveries difficult to believe.

Sensation Before Scholarship: Gospel Fragment Tantalizes Experts

Sensation Before Scholarship: Gospel Fragment Tantalizes Experts

Photo by DAVID O' NEILL / DKIMAGES

Early copies of the Gospel of Mark are not as common as the other three gospels. The reason: 90 percent of Mark is in the Gospel of Matthew, so few early scribes copied it, says Daniel Wallace, founder of the Center for the Study of New Testament Manuscripts and New Testament Studies professor at Dallas Theological Seminary.

But in February, Wallace announced during a debate that not only has a new fragment of Mark's gospel been discovered in Egypt, but it is the oldest portion of the New Testament now known. He claimed the fragment dates to the first century, within decades of the time of Christ.

Speculation about the fragment's whereabouts has centered on the Green Collection: tens of thousands of ancient manuscripts bought over the past three years by the owners of Hobby Lobby. In December, collection director Scott Carroll issued a tantalizing message on his Twitter account: "For over 100 years the earliest known text of the New Testament has been the so-call[ed] John Rylands Papyrus. Not any more. Stay tuned …" A publicist for the Green Collection denied that it owns the Mark fragment.

Other New Testament scholars won't get a chance to study this gospel portion until it is published in a book about a year from now. They are admittedly skeptical, since the alleged fragment would be almost two centuries older than the current oldest copy of Mark.

"I won't believe it until I see it," said Simon Gathercole, editor of the Journal for the Study of the New Testament at Cambridge University in the United Kingdom.

Peter Head, a New Testament research fellow at Tyndale House, a British residential center for biblical research, is likewise eager to get a look at the fragment before rendering an opinion.

"Other claims for first-century dates for New Testament papyri have not been persuasive," he said. "Also, the approach that puts the 'announcement' before the scholarship is a style that doesn't always seem that bothered with making sure the scholarship is right."

Biblical scholars are increasingly frustrated with sensational finds, often announced during the Christmas and Easter seasons. Magazines, book publishers, and cable channels seem more interested in pumping up sales and viewers than in assuring that discoveries stand up under scholarly scrutiny.

Last year, metal codices that surfaced in Israel were touted as a possible Christian version of the Dead Sea Scrolls because they seemed to contain ancient Greek and Hebrew writing. The codices have since been dismissed as modern forgeries.

This year, a first-century tomb in the East Talpiot neighborhood of Jerusalem was touted in February as possibly the tomb of Joseph of Arimathea, related to another nearby tomb touted in 2007 as the tomb of the family of Jesus.

"The technology they used, with a remote robotic camera, was ground-breaking," said Andrew Vaughn, executive director of the American Schools of Oriental Research (ASOR). "But with regard to their theory, it's my assessment that there's zero percent chance that it's true."

As soon as the Talpiot tomb news conference was over, Vaughn appointed two scholars as guest editors on the ASOR blog for the month of March. They moderated blog posts by almost a dozen scholars—most quite critical of the Talpiot announcement. "It's just the appropriate way to do [scholarly scrutiny] now," Vaughn said of the blog strategy.

Steven Ortiz, a professor of archaeology at Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary, says archaeologists and Bible scholars have become much more wary about announcing discoveries following a long antiquities fraud trial in Jerusalem. The March verdict largely exonerated defendants Oded Golan and Robert Deutsch, and most of the antiquities under scrutiny—such as the much-hyped James Ossuary—were not proven to be forgeries (yet not authenticated either). The message is clear.

"Any spectacular find now is always going to be questioned," Ortiz said. "The way the media hypes things, scholars are more aware that we have to have a stronger voice in the community—to jump into the debate itself."

So, given this scholarly antipathy to the growing trend of announcements before scholarship, why did Wallace jump the gun on the Mark fragment and six other New Testament portions he announced during a debate with Bart Ehrman at the University of North Carolina's Chapel Hill campus "I did not discover these papyri," he said. "I was permitted to make a public announcement about them when I debated [Ehrman] over the text of the New Testament."

Ehrman, a UNC professor of religious studies, has written several books questioning the textual foundation of the New Testament. He and Wallace have debated several times.

"His position, if applied to classical literature, would drive us right back into the Dark Ages," Wallace said. "Because we have on average about 1,000 times more evidence for the New Testament than we do for classical authors, in terms of literary remains."

Currently 127 portions of the New Testament on papyrus have been found; Greek manuscripts on parchment have also increased. Wallace's center, founded to search out and publish more ancient copies of the New Testament, has discovered approximately 70 new manuscripts so far.

So Wallace used the alleged new Mark fragment to make his point during the debate; but for New Testament scholars, it will be a long frustrating year until they get a look for themselves.

Copyright © 2012 Christianity Today. Click for reprint information.

Related Elsewhere:

Previous Christianity Today stories on biblical archeology include:

Scholars Aim to Bust Archaeological Fantasies | Peer review can take years—but academic society says some claims can be dismissed in a few blog posts. (April 4, 2012)

Trial on Antiquities Fraud Ends, But Not the Controversy | Judge doesn't rule whether James ossuary is authentic, but acquits antiquities collectors on almost all charges. (March 14, 2012)

My Top 5 Books On Archaeology | Picks from Craig A. Evans, author of the forthcoming Jesus and His World. (March 27, 2012)

Archeology's Rebel: Bible in One Hand, Spade in the Other | Eilat Mazar is unafraid to claim archaeological finds of biblical proportions. (November 11, 2011)

Archaeology in Turkey: Major Finds in Asia Minor | But researchers say Turkish government is shutting them out. (October 27, 2011)

Scholars Doubtful About Metal Plate Documents' Authenticity | "More significant than the Dead Sea Scrolls"It's very unlikely. (April 1, 2011)

Also in this issue

The CT archives are a rich treasure of biblical wisdom and insight from our past. Some things we would say differently today, and some stances we've changed. But overall, we're amazed at how relevant so much of this content is. We trust that you'll find it a helpful resource.

My Top 5 Books On Fatherhood

Getting to the Crux of Calvary

Works and Words: Why You Can't Preach the Gospel with Deeds

From Powerlifter to Powerless

Throwing Christ Over the Cliff

Review

Brave New Web: Navigating the Conflict Between Pluralism and Freedom

Teach Us to Pray: Learning from Prayer Partners in History

News

Quebec: Canada's Prodigal Province

News

Black Church Barrios: African American Churches Adapt to Latino Neighbors

Touched by Jesus: Healing Body and Soul

Miracles in Mozambique: How Mama Heidi Reaches the Abandoned

News

Marketing Martyrs: Does Iranian Pastor's Theology Impact Advocacy on His Behalf?

Helping Urbana Find Its Voice

News

Should Churches Halt Missions Trips to Mexico?

Wilson's Bookmarks

The Choir's Steve Hindalong: Celebrating Sobriety

Private Faith and Public Policy: Where Obama and Santorum Agree

Letters to the Editor

Forced Out: Pastors' Fight and Flight

Should We Stop Child Placement Programs if We're Required to Work with Same-Sex Couples?

Review

Dollars and Moral Sense: What Money Can't Buy

News

Quotation Marks

Excerpt

Subversive Kingdom

Review

Journeys of Faith

News

Foreign Aid Cut from Religious Charities, Authorities Target Official Churches, Religious Quota Creates Controversy, and More News

Review

Rhetorical Darwinism

Review

How God Became King

News

Migrant Ministries: European Churches Revitalized by Asian Diaspora

News

Passages

News

Go Figure

Review

Mercyland: Hymns for the Rest of Us

Editorial

The ‘Monsters’ Among Us: Child Sex Abusers in Our Midst

Why We Need 'Community'

Q & A: Ross Douthat on Rooting Out Bad Religion

View issue

Our Latest

Public Theology Project

How to Get Through the Next Four Years

The nonstop news cycle will be crazy. You don’t have to be.

News

And the Word Became Accessible: Publishers Release Dyslexia-Friendly Bibles

Designer hopes a new, custom typeface will be a life-changing tool for those with reading disorders.

‘Heretic’ and the Truth That Sets Us Free

In the Hugh Grant horror movie, Latter-day Saint missionaries are entrapped in more ways than one.

The Russell Moore Show

Media and Leadership in a World on Edge

Jeffrey Goldberg, editor in chief of ‘The Atlantic,’ talks about politics, Palestine, and publishing.

News

Church of England Leaders Kept Evangelical Beatings Secret

Archbishop Justin Welby resigns after abuse report exposes cover-up dating back to 1982.

The Incarnation is More than the Manger

How an ancient African bishop championed the incarnation’s redemptive arc.

Review

The Black Church Has Five Theological Anchors

Walter Strickland’s sweeping narrative of African American Christianity portrays a big God who is strong to deliver.

A Solution for Seasonal Overwhelm

Focusing on the few in front of us makes a tangible difference in our local communities.

Apple PodcastsDown ArrowDown ArrowDown Arrowarrow_left_altLeft ArrowLeft ArrowRight ArrowRight ArrowRight Arrowarrow_up_altUp ArrowUp ArrowAvailable at Amazoncaret-downCloseCloseEmailEmailExpandExpandExternalExternalFacebookfacebook-squareGiftGiftGooglegoogleGoogle KeephamburgerInstagraminstagram-squareLinkLinklinkedin-squareListenListenListenChristianity TodayCT Creative Studio Logologo_orgMegaphoneMenuMenupausePinterestPlayPlayPocketPodcastRSSRSSSaveSaveSaveSearchSearchsearchSpotifyStitcherTelegramTable of ContentsTable of Contentstwitter-squareWhatsAppXYouTubeYouTube