News

At Purple Churches, Pastors Struggle with Polarized Congregations

A challenging year threatens to divide Christians who have resisted the cultural trend.

Illustration by Paige Stampatori

The problem is not that people in the church disagree about who to vote for.

The problem is not that people get angry, shoot fiery emails to the pastor, and get into bruising fights with other church members on Facebook. (Though that does happen.)

And really, the problem is not even that some things are suddenly intensely political, though they weren’t before—trusting health experts, saying everyone is created in the image of God, or preaching on a passage of Scripture that mentions the poor.

The problem of polarization, according to the pastors of purple churches struggling to minister to red Republicans and blue Democrats during another divisive election, is that people stop fighting. They part ways. And they sort themselves by political preference.

Polarization makes it seem like unity in Christ can only come after political unity. Polarization makes it seem like partisanship is stronger than the gospel.

“The polarization is so deep now,” said LeRoy Lawson, an Independent Christian Church minister who started preaching in the 1950s, “[that] most churches lean to the Left or lean to the Right and they think only left or right can be true Christians.”

Polarization is a 30 years cultural trend, according to sociologists and political scientists. When Bill Clinton beat George H. W. Bush in the 1992 presidential election, a little more than a third of Americans lived in “landslide counties,” where one of the two candidates won more than 70 percent of the vote. In 2016, when Donald Trump beat Hillary Clinton, more than 6 out of 10 Americans lived in landslide counties. Most people lived surrounded by people who thought just like they did, “clustering,” as sociologist Bill Bishop wrote in The Big Sort, “in communities of like-mindedness.”

Some American evangelicals have embraced this kind of segregation. One of the premises of the church growth movement taught by Donald McGavran at Fuller Theological Seminary in the 1970s and ’80s was the “homogeneous unit principle,” which said that people should be able to convert to Christianity and join a church without having to cross too many barriers of race, class, caste, language, or even politics.

But others have rejected this. They’ve worked to resist the cultural trend, saying the gospel calls Christians to something different.

“I think a church ought to be solidly purple,” said Chris Rea, pastor of Church of the Savior, a Christian Reformed Church in South Bend, Indiana.

“Our identity should be in Jesus, not in anything else,” she said. “Our political persuasion should not be our primary identity.”

At Pantano Christian Church in Tucson, Glen Elliott said demographic diversity creates opportunities for outreach. When people are convinced that “Christian” means conservative, that limits evangelism to conservatives, according to Elliott.

“If I say this is a right-wing Republican church, well, that’s who comes,” he said. “We want to reach lost people. Not just lost people of a certain segment. I want to reach anyone who doesn’t know Jesus.”

The 3,500 who regularly attend Pantano are predominately conservative, but there are left-leaning Christians too, especially among the younger attendees and the roughly 50 percent who aren’t white.

That creates tensions. The congregation has had conflicts over the election, the phrase “black lives matter,” and the proper response to the coronavirus.

According to a recent LifeWay Research survey, responses to the pandemic are a major point of conflict in 2020. About a third of Protestant pastors said the struggle to maintain unity was the No. 1 “point of pressure” caused by COVID-19.

Trevin Wax, senior vice president of theology and communication at LifeWay, said there has always been polarization in American culture and American evangelical churches, but the coronavirus has made it worse. Even if most people in a congregation “kind of bear with their church leadership,” the 10 percent or 20 percent who strongly disagree with decisions about health rules and the pandemic can be very loud and disruptive.

At New Life Bible Fellowship, about 25 miles from Pantano on the other side of Tucson, John Beeson got an angry email about his church’s requirement for a recent service that everyone wear masks and stay physically distant, following health rules.

New Life also got an angry reaction to a social media post with a picture and caption that said everyone is made in God’s image. Someone in the church saw that as a statement about Black Lives Matter and fired off a response.

Beeson worries about how easy it would be for church staff to want to get rid of those people, accepting the inevitability of polarization. Instead, church leadership has tried to return to basic themes, not avoiding the issues but addressing them in a different way.

“We’re doing a series on the kingdom parables—a not-so-subtle attempt to say, ‘Let’s remember and reorient ourselves around the king and the kingdom,’ ” Beeson said. “Kingdom language is so helpful, reorienting our identity, reshaping our hopes, and giving us clarity about where our peace comes from.”

A lot of purple churches are doing politics-themed sermon series right now. Faith Church in Indianapolis is running a series on the prophet Micah, looking at the issues the prophet challenges God’s people to care about.

Pastor Jeff Schultz tells the Evangelical Free congregation that there are some convictions that aren’t negotiable. The church is committed to supporting pro-life ministries and to helping the refugees who moved into nearby apartments. The Bible doesn’t teach theories of racial superiority, and it condemns rich people taking advantage of the poor.

But Schultz points out that Christians can disagree about how to apply these principles. The church has Republicans, Democrats, and Independents on staff, and they all have blind spots. We all need to act with humility, he said.

“Hopefully we can acknowledge that in any election, it’s not pure good versus pure evil, white hats versus black hats,” Schultz said. “Our identity is in truth, and the ultimate truth is the God who doesn’t fit neatly into political categories.”

It can be hard to tell if the proclamation of a God and gospel bigger than partisanship is enough to counter the forces of polarization. In the middle of the coronavirus, a national discussion about racism, and a presidential election, it’s easy to feel like it’s not. Every pastor who is trying to minister to a congregation that spans the political divide has a story about a family that left, a fight that blew up, or a feeling of futility that was overwhelming.

But the pastors of purple churches say they can only keep preaching what they know to be true.

“We’re saved by grace,” Lawson said. “I think churches will be saved by grace and communities will be saved by grace. Learning to extend grace is the only thing I know, honestly.”

Daniel Silliman is news editor for Christianity Today.

Also in this issue

The costs of health care in America are staggering. Those blessed with the right insurance watch mind-boggling medical bills evaporate into the ether, as if by magic. But millions of others risk having their lives derailed by such bills, or they risk the life-threatening consequences of forgoing treatment because they could not begin to pay for it. The modern US system of insurance-based care began as a Christian invention to help the vulnerable, but today it often feels like a punitive system denying medicine to those who need it most. Our cover story this month asks: Can Christians once again find a better way?

Cover Story

Christians Invented Health Insurance. Can They Make Something Better?

Hope Is an Expectant Leap

News

Gleanings: November 2020

Our November Issue: An Ocean of Need

Paulโ€™s Most Beloved Letter Was Entrusted to a Woman

Meet the TikTok Generation of Televangelists

Testimony

I Was a World Series Hero on the Brink of Suicide

We All Know Christโ€™s Dying Words. But Can We Define the โ€˜Itโ€™ That Is โ€˜Finishedโ€™?

News

Who Preaches on Politics? Most Pastors.

News

Churches Search for Sounds of Heaven

5 Books That Turn Our Grumbling into Gratitude

News

Creation Care Movement Takes Action with Solar Panels and Petitions

Editorial

Post-Election Civility Is Not Enough

Reply All

Itโ€™s Okay Not to Be Okay

Cultivating Chaos

Joy That Wonโ€™t Wither

How Churches Elevate and Protect Abusive Pastors

Review

A True Religion Does Three Things and Answers Four Questions

Review

Share the Gospel with Prisoners. Then Apply It to the System.

New & Noteworthy Fiction

View issue

Our Latest

News

Died: Jack Iker, Anglican Who Drew the Line at Womenโ€™s Ordination

The Texas bishop fought a bitter legal battle with the Episcopal Church and won.

Why Canโ€™t We Talk to Each Other Anymore?

Online interactions are draining us of energy to have hard conversations in person.

Church Disappointment Is Multilayered

Jude 3 Project founder Lisa Fields speaks about navigating frustrations with God and fellow believers.

The Robot Will Lie Down With the Gosling

In โ€œThe Wild Robot,โ€ hospitality reprograms relationships.

How Priscilla Shirer Surrenders All

The best-selling Bible teacher writes about putting God first in her life and how healthy Christian discipleship requires sacrifice

The Bulletin

Second Hand News

The Bulletin talks presidential podcasts, hurricane rumors, and the spiritual histories of Israel and Iran.

Which Church in Revelation Is Yours Like?

From the lukewarm Laodicea to the overachieving Ephesus, these seven ancient congregations struggled with relatable problems.

Apple PodcastsDown ArrowDown ArrowDown Arrowarrow_left_altLeft ArrowLeft ArrowRight ArrowRight ArrowRight Arrowarrow_up_altUp ArrowUp ArrowAvailable at Amazoncaret-downCloseCloseEmailEmailExpandExpandExternalExternalFacebookfacebook-squareGiftGiftGooglegoogleGoogle KeephamburgerInstagraminstagram-squareLinkLinklinkedin-squareListenListenListenChristianity TodayCT Creative Studio Logologo_orgMegaphoneMenuMenupausePinterestPlayPlayPocketPodcastRSSRSSSaveSaveSaveSearchSearchsearchSpotifyStitcherTelegramTable of ContentsTable of Contentstwitter-squareWhatsAppXYouTubeYouTube