News
Wire Story

Back to the Future?

Antischool-prayer crusaders cite a 50-year-old case in resisting the proposed Religious Freedom Amendment.

When the House Judiciary Committee on March 5 approved the Religious Freedom Amendment barring the government from infringing on religious expression in public schools, 85-year-old Vashti McCollum thought she had won such a battle long ago.

It was five decades to the month that the Supreme Court ruled in her favor in McCollum v. Board of Education, prohibiting for the first time religious instruction in public schools.

“Ever since the decision was handed down, people have tried devious ways to put sectarian religion in the public schools and to get the public funds for parochial schools,” says McCollum. “I think [the Religious Freedom Amendment] is designed to undermine the First Amendment of the Constitution.”

However, Rep. Ernest J. Istook Jr. (R-Okla.), who has been leading the fight for the Religious Freedom Amendment, says federal judges are the ones who are undermining the Constitution. “When prayer or religious expression occurs on public property, [judges] turn a blind eye to the fact that it’s protected as free expression of religion.” He believes judges are misapplying the constitutional ban on the establishment of religion. He says, “The same First Amendment that protects us has been turned upside-down and is used as a weapon against religion.” His amendment, Istook believes, will restore full freedom of religion as originally intended.

McCollum’s own case began in the early 1940s in Champaign, Illinois, where public school students thought nothing of saying the Lord’s Prayer before assembly.

McCollum was a homemaker raising three sons when her eldest, 9-year-old Jim, came home and asked her for a quarter so he could take religious instruction in his public grammar school. The McCollums had never been church-goers, and her husband, John “Pappy” McCollum, a University of Illinois professor, vehemently opposed the class. But Vashti, although a humanist, gave Jim the money so he would not feel left out.

‘RELIGIOUS INDOCTRINATION’: Jim McCollum, now 63 and a computer consultant in Magnolia, Arkansas, remembers balking at illustrated Bible stories, and his mother recalls fuming over a poster her son made of the Resurrection.

The next year, Jim opted out of religious instruction and often spent the hour in a chair in the hallway used for detention. “He came home crying and I thought, If he can’t take it, I can’t take it.

School administrators were unresponsive, she says, so she contacted Philip Schug, a local Unitarian minister, who agreed she had grounds for a lawsuit. Schug, now 83, remembers rustling up support from wealthy Chicago liberals committed to church-state separation. “Soon we were raising a lot of money,” he says, “and we filed a suit against the legislature of Illinois.”

Their first lawyer, Landon Chapman, wanted to prove that religious teaching is inevitably sectarian by demonstrating how minority groups were discriminated against when schools got involved in religion. Vashti McCollum’s father, a prominent atheist, took the stand and announced to the court that the Adam and Eve story was fictitious and ministers who believed in God were insane. Soon the press dubbed his daughter “the atheist mother.” The court ruled Jim was not harassed, that the Champaign system was not sectarian, and that religion class was like any other extracurricular activity in the schools.

ANOTHER STRATEGY: When the Illinois Supreme Court agreed to hear the case on appeal, Vashti McCollum hired a new lawyer, Walter Dodd, an expert on constitutional law. Dodd argued that publicly segregating students in sectarian groups for religious education in schools during school hours violated constitutional guarantees of freedom of religion. And he said such action is not validated by allowing children to be excused.

In June 1947, the U.S. Supreme Court agreed to review the case.

Given the potential precedent, religious groups that had remained on the sidelines went public with their support of Vashti McCollum. The Synagogue Council of America, the American Unitarian Association, and the General Conference of Seventh-day Adventists filed briefs on her behalf. The Joint Conference Committee on Public Relations, set up by the Southern Baptist Convention, the two Northern Baptist Conventions, and the National Baptist Convention, also filed a brief backing the McCollums.

In March 1948, the Supreme Court ruled 8 to 1 that public school systems may not assist religious groups in giving religious instruction and thus spreading their faith. Half a century later, Istook says that his amendment (CT, April 27, 1998, p. 15) is a response to decades of Supreme Court decisions that have barred or discouraged religious expression in public places. Istook says the McCollum case had the unacceptable consequence of shutting out religious expression from public places. The amendment would restore students’ right to religious expression, including prayer, in public schools.

Copyright © 1998 Christianity Today. Click for reprint information.

Also in this issue

McCartney on the Rebound: He started a ministry to heal men's relationships while his own marriage was in crisis; he drew a million men to Washington only to announce a few months later that he was laying off all his staff. Now he's hiring them back. Who is this man piloting Promise Keepers' wild ride?

Cover Story

McCartney on the REBOUND

New Oratorio Features Black Gospel

I Didn't Mean to be Rude

Inside the Vatican

Classic & Contemporary Excerpts from May 18, 1998

And the Word Was ... Debatable

Falwell Denounces Operation Rescue

Bankruptcy Exemption Progresses

Leaders Retain 'Chastity' Vow

Two Cook Magazines Join CTi

Comic Relief: Lulu Brimley's Last-Chance Christian Books

Senators Champion Rival Bill on Religious Persecution

Evangelicals Warned Against Persecution Apathy

Pope's Visit Blindsides Evangelicals

'Antimissionary' Bill Effort Backfires

Five Killed in Mission Plane Crash

Do Churches Send Wrong People?

Evangelicals Protest Media Shutdowns

Gambling with the Enemy

News

News Briefs: May 18, 1998

Augustine Who?

The Bottom Line

Bright Lights, Big Pity

The Power of Art

Nonprofits: The Myth of the Needy Child?

Hispanic Christian Radio Grows by Blocks and Blends

News

News Briefs: May 18, 1998

News Update: Up from the Ashes?

The Coach's Burden

None Dare Call It Sin, plus America's Gambling Habit

Colombia's Bleeding Church

The Day We Were Left Behind

Under the Streets of Bucharest

View issue

Our Latest

News

Charlie Kirk Aims to Expand Turning Point USA to Evangelical Campuses

But not all Christian campuses have embraced the conservative group.

News

Sarah Jakes Roberts Evolves T. D. Jakes’s Women’s Conference

At a record-setting event this fall, 40,000 followers listened to her preach about spiritual breakthrough and surrender.

Being Human

Walking the Camino de Santiago with Barrett Harkins

The missionary to pilgrims shares wisdom from the trail.

News

The Evangelical Voters Who Changed Their Minds

Amid a hyperpartisan electorate, a minority plan to vote differently than they did in 2016 and 2020.

News

Meet the Evangelical Expats Staying in Lebanon

Shout to the Lord in a Foreign Language

Worshiping God with words we don’t understand may seem strange. But I consider it a spiritual practice.

Jesus Is Still Right About Persecution

Nine truths believers need to understand to pray well for the suffering body of Christ.

The Bulletin

Electioneering

The Bulletin discusses the final presidential campaign push, churches in the age of screens, and the UN’s work in Gaza.

Apple PodcastsDown ArrowDown ArrowDown Arrowarrow_left_altLeft ArrowLeft ArrowRight ArrowRight ArrowRight Arrowarrow_up_altUp ArrowUp ArrowAvailable at Amazoncaret-downCloseCloseEmailEmailExpandExpandExternalExternalFacebookfacebook-squareGiftGiftGooglegoogleGoogle KeephamburgerInstagraminstagram-squareLinkLinklinkedin-squareListenListenListenChristianity TodayCT Creative Studio Logologo_orgMegaphoneMenuMenupausePinterestPlayPlayPocketPodcastRSSRSSSaveSaveSaveSearchSearchsearchSpotifyStitcherTelegramTable of ContentsTable of Contentstwitter-squareWhatsAppXYouTubeYouTube