Brazil: Scholars Debate Mission Methods

Scholars fault Western approaches to evangelism, advocate a new vision for spreading the gospel.

With the dramatic Iguassu Falls as their backdrop, scholars and missionaries gathered in October for lively discussions about mission strategy, theology, and cultural conflicts.

The 159 participants in the Iguassu Missiological Consultation came to Foz do Iguassu from 53 countries to examine the way Christian mission is changing at the turn of the millennium.

Set on the border between Brazil and Argentina, Iguassu Falls is a two-and-a-half-mile wide waterfall system of 275 cataracts.

The rugged terrain around the Iguassu Falls is also where actors Robert DeNiro and Jeremy Irons reenacted a bloody incident from Latin America’s colonial history for the 1986 motion picture The Mission. The actors played a Jesuit missionary and convert soldier resisting Portuguese conquerors bent on murdering the native Guarani and stealing their land.

That history of imperialism still lives in the memories of some who attended the consultation, sponsored by the Singapore -based World Evangelical Fellowship (WEF). Seattle-based anthropologist Miriam Adeney told attendees the parable of the mouse who danced with the elephant and was squashed—despite the elephant’s enormous good will. Dozens of speakers and discussion participants invoked that image to explain their feelings toward North America and its missions organizations.

MISSIONARY AS MARKETER? Peruvian missiologist Samuel Escobar was unable to attend the consultation because of family illness. But in a paper discussed at the meeting, he criticized the “managerial missiology” practiced by certain North American groups. “The distinctive note” of this approach to missions “is to reduce Christian mission to a manageable enterprise,” Escobar wrote. Practitioners of this approach focus on the quantifiable, measurable tasks of missions and ask pragmatic questions about how to achieve goals. Escobar called this statistical approach “anti-theological” and said it “has no theological or pastoral resources to cope with the suffering and persecution involved because it is geared to provide guaranteed success.”

Joseph D’Souza, chair of the All India Christian Council, also indicted missiological trends that “have tended to turn communication [of the gospel] into a technique where we market a product called ‘salvation.’ The consumer is the sinner and the marketer is the missionary. In the bargain, what is missed is redemptive living in society.”

This managerial approach is “a major leap onto the secular stage of strategic planning,” according to a monograph from retired Eastern College professor James Engel. In the event’s opening address, consultation director William Taylor quoted extensively from Engel, who was among the first to foster evangelical adoption of marketing principles.

Engel noted the “darker side” of plans to complete the task of evangelism by A.D. 2000. “Quantifiable results soon became a virtual obsession,” Engel wrote. “Organizational public relations machinery geared up to fever-pitch reporting the numbers allegedly reached through crusades, the media, and intensified personal evangelism initiatives.” Engel is concerned that such efforts do not produce “definite evidence that the kingdom of God is being exemplified” among peoples reached in this way.

The discussion sometimes seemed divided along First World-Third World lines, but statistical and strategic approaches to mission had their Latin American defenders. Rudy Giron, former chair of the indigenous Latin American missions movement Comibam, said such approaches help him envision the task of evangelization. Giron credits the approach with the growth of the missionary movement in Latin America.

Research can aid the task of evangelism, said Steve Hoke, vice president of the Anaheim, California-based Church Re source Ministries, which grew in part out of the church-growth philosophy developed at Fuller Seminary’s School of World Mission. “If all truth is God’s truth, we can borrow principles from marketing. Jesus was very felt-need-oriented in his approach.

“Doesn’t it make sense to look strategically at fields that may be white unto harvest, or where, perhaps, we have neglected to sow?” Hoke asked.

WINNING IS NOT EVERYTHING: If missiology is sometimes too marketing-oriented, it is also sometimes too magical. Paul Hiebert of Trinity Evangelical Divinity School outlined the persistence in modern life of mythic cosmic dualism in literature, sport, government, business, religion—and even missions. Whether in football or evangelism, the universe is seen as the battleground between equal, opposing forces, Hiebert said. The outcome of the battle is uncertain, and winning is everything. In contrast, the biblical world-view sees God ruling over all, including the evil powers. “The very existence of Satan and sinners are a testimony to [God’s] mercy and love,” he said. There is cosmic struggle, but the outcome is certain and winning is not everything.

Hiebert applied this world-view analysis to the way spiritual warfare is often waged. Missionaries who try to deliver populations by praying against evil spirits sell human sinfulness short by treating people as the hapless victims of invisible forces rather than as moral agents responsible before God.

NEW DIRECTIONS: The consultation affirmed newer models of mission that contrast with the paternalism of the past. The 2,275-word Iguassu Affirmation, signed by participants at a closing Communion service, reverses the traditional flow from First World to Third World and advocates a vision “from people of all nations to people of all nations.” (The text is available from the www.ChristianityToday.com archives.)

Participants also endorsed the development of missions movements in every country where there is a mature Christian church and explored the meaning for missions of the Christian teaching that God is Three in One.

Copyright © 1999 Christianity Today. Click for reprint information.

Also in this issue

Where Would Civilization Be Without Christianity? Over the past 2,000 years, the gospel has transformed countless lives. Likewise, Christian ideas have shaped cultures. At this turn of the millennium, what contributions to civilization should we celebrate?

Cover Story

Where Would Civilization Be Without Christianity? The Gift of Mission

Cover Story

Where Would Civilization Be Without Christianity? The Gift of Humility

Cover Story

Where Would Civilization Be Without Christianity? The Gift of Literacy

Cover Story

Where Would Civilization Be Without Christianity? The Gift of Science

Cover Story

Where Would Civilization Be Without Christianity? The Gift of Dignity

Elegy for a Jesus Freak

Reflections on Christmas

No Room in the Womb?

Why We Still Need Moody

Fatherhood on the Rebound

Meditations: Drive-Through Christmas

Cassie Said Yes, They Say No

Dispatch From Sierra Leone: Suckled on Gunpowder

Is Christmas Pagan?

The Abortion Debate Is Over

Redeeming Fire

Making Room for God

Ending Hunger in Our Lifetime

New & Noteworthy: Church History

Doctor’s Orders

Ban May Go to Supreme Court

Marketing Martyrdom to Teens

JESUS Film Debuts on DVD

In Brief: December 06, 1999

Feed the Children Battles Controversy

Court Upholds Video Poker Ban

Violence Mars Bonnke's Revival

Arrested Christians Face Deportation

In Brief: December 06, 1999

Hindus Protest Papal Visit

First United Nations 'Spiritual Summit' Planned

Wire Story

Plans for Meeting Between Baptist Jewish Heads Called Off

Wire Story

Homosexuality: Falwell Tames His Tongue

Wire Story

Christians Protest Proposed Mosque

Moscow Meeting Eases Russia's Interchurch Tensions

The Grove Press Bible

Positive About Potter

Lord's Prayer a Musical Hit in United Kingdom

Jailed Sudanese Priests Reject presidential Amnesty

Two Major Philippine Churches Sign Agreement for Closer Links

Leading German Bishop Says Church Will Bow to Rome in Abortion Controversy

Tashkent Christian Threatened with Two-Year Prison Term

New Delhi Center Dedicated to Princess Di's Wish to End 'Stigma' of Leprosy

Homosexual Group Institutes Award for Straight Religious Leaders

Amassed Media: Evolution Wars

Wire Story

Ministries Intensify As East Timorese Refugee Camps Grow

Jerusalem's Church Leaders Usher in Millennium Celebrations

Help Us Develop Our Souls Mandela Tells World Religious Leaders

Australian Church Agrees to Run Controversial Room for Injecting Drugs

Leading Catholic Theologian Outlines His Vision of Next Pope

Campbell Remains Optimistic As She Looks to Life After the NCC

Amassed Media: God Bless America's Candidates

One Denomination at Its Best and Worst

Letters

Ned Graham’s Woes Shake East Gates

Texas Southern Baptists: Submission Rejected

Alabama: An Education Gamble

Buddhism: Spirituality Without Religion

Editorial

More of the Same

View issue

Our Latest

News

Ghana May Elect Its First Muslim President. Its Christian Majority Is Torn.

Church leaders weigh competency and faith background as the West African nation heads to the polls.

Shamanism in Indonesia

Can Christians practice ‘white knowledge’ to heal the sick and exorcize demons?

Shamanism in Japan

Christians in the country view pastors’ benedictions as powerful spiritual mantras.

Shamanism in Taiwan

In a land teeming with ghosts, is there room for the Holy Spirit to work?

Shamanism in Vietnam

Folk religion has shaped believers’ perceptions of God as a genie in a lamp.

Shamanism in the Philippines

Filipinos’ desire to connect with the supernatural shouldn’t be eradicated, but transformed and redirected toward Christ.

Shamanism in South Korea

Why Christians in the country hold onto trees while praying outdoors.

Shamanism in Thailand

When guardian spirits disrupt river baptisms, how can believers respond?

Apple PodcastsDown ArrowDown ArrowDown Arrowarrow_left_altLeft ArrowLeft ArrowRight ArrowRight ArrowRight Arrowarrow_up_altUp ArrowUp ArrowAvailable at Amazoncaret-downCloseCloseEmailEmailExpandExpandExternalExternalFacebookfacebook-squareGiftGiftGooglegoogleGoogle KeephamburgerInstagraminstagram-squareLinkLinklinkedin-squareListenListenListenChristianity TodayCT Creative Studio Logologo_orgMegaphoneMenuMenupausePinterestPlayPlayPocketPodcastRSSRSSSaveSaveSaveSearchSearchsearchSpotifyStitcherTelegramTable of ContentsTable of Contentstwitter-squareWhatsAppXYouTubeYouTube