Is Christmas Pagan?

Long before Constantine, Christians found ways to redeem local cultures and salvage those elements that naturally pointed to Christ.

Shaun Menary / Lightstock

Q: A friend says her church doesn't celebrate Christmas because it began as a pagan holiday. Why then do most churches celebrate Christmas?

—Brian Smith, via the Internet.

A: Was the event we now call Christmas originally a "pagan holiday"? In some ways. Does that mean the church should discard it, along with its lights, tinsel, and increasing commercialism? Only if we are prepared to abandon many other holidays and common Christian practices that the early church co-opted for its own purpose of glorifying Christ.

Christmas has its origins in the fourth century. December 25, which Christians now herald as Jesus' birthday, was actually the date on which the Romans celebrated the birth of the sun god.

After the Roman emperor Constantine converted to Christianity at the Milvian Bridge in 312, he sought to combine the worship of the sun god with worship of Christ. Christian leaders accepted Constantine's conversion in a positive light and saw the "Christ-mass" celebration as a vital part of the process of converting the pagan world.

Long before Constantine, Christians found ways to redeem local cultures and salvage elements in those cultures that naturally pointed to Christ, whether Hebrew, Syrian, Greek, or Roman. They denounced inhumane pagan practices, but at the same time took over pagan temples and converted them to churches. They replaced the old gods in popular devotion with heroic martyrs of the persecutions. And they replaced the holy days of paganism with festivals of the Christian year.

Larger questions loom behind the observance of Christmas: Why a church calendar at all? Why a Sunday? Why an Easter? Is there New Testament authority for religious holidays?

As Christmas, Easter, and Sunday all indicate, the Christian calendar is based upon the major events of the New Testament. Early Christians shared a conviction that believers need regular reminders of the great events of redemptive history. Didn't Jesus himself endorse the practice when he instituted the Lord's Supper? "This do in remembrance of me."

Besides, our celebration of Christmas or any other Christian "holy day" goes much deeper than the date on which we observe it. The first Christmas celebration did not commemorate a date at all but a supremely important event—the appearance of Israel's promised Messiah and Lord of the Nations.

Early Christians did not know the specific night the angels sang or the baby cried any more than we do. A few believers tried to calculate the date, but most of these indulged in all sorts of speculations and differed with each other. As a result, down to the first half of the fourth century the churches attached no greater significance to December 25 than to many other dates.

This much we know: Before there was December 25, there was January 6. As early as the second century, Christians celebrated Jesus' appearance at the Jordan and his baptism by John on January 6. Some time later they expanded this festival to include Christ's appearance at birth. Christians called it Epiphany, or manifestation. So the meaning of the first Christmas was not pagan; it was a celebration of the Word manifest in flesh.

It is important to note that the link between Christ and Constantine's sun god was light. For generations, Christians had been singing about Christ's appearance as the true Light, as the light of Creation and redemption. Christians in these early centuries were fascinated by the image of light breaking into our darkness. "We have seen a sign from heaven, the shining star," the choir sings in one early liturgy. Another hymn announces:

The whole creation proclaims,
The Magi proclaim,
The star proclaims:
Behold! the king's son is here!

This impulse to sing the praises of Christ's birth did not come from paganism. It was a result of Christians reflecting on the fact that God became man in Jesus Christ and condescended to our lowly estate.

Many in the fourth-century church viewed Constantine's conversion as the fulfillment of Malachi's prophecy: In the day of the Lord, the "Sun of Righteousness will arise with healing in his wings" for those who fear the Lord's name (4:2).

In a Christmas sermon, Bishop Ambrose in Milan spoke for many Christians of that day when he said, "Well do Christian people call this holy day, on which our Lord was born, the day of the new sun; and they assert it so insistently that even Jews and pagans agree with them in using that name for it. We are happy to accept and maintain this view, because with the day spring of the Savior, not only is the salvation of man kind renewed, but also the splendor of the sun. … For if the sun withdrew its light when Christ suffered, it must shine at his birth with greater splendor than ever before."

Bruce L. Shelley is senior professor of church history at Denver Seminary.

Copyright © 1999 Christianity Today. Click for reprint information.

Also in this issue

Where Would Civilization Be Without Christianity? Over the past 2,000 years, the gospel has transformed countless lives. Likewise, Christian ideas have shaped cultures. At this turn of the millennium, what contributions to civilization should we celebrate?

Cover Story

Where Would Civilization Be Without Christianity? The Gift of Mission

Cover Story

Where Would Civilization Be Without Christianity? The Gift of Humility

Cover Story

Where Would Civilization Be Without Christianity? The Gift of Literacy

Cover Story

Where Would Civilization Be Without Christianity? The Gift of Science

Cover Story

Where Would Civilization Be Without Christianity? The Gift of Dignity

Elegy for a Jesus Freak

Reflections on Christmas

No Room in the Womb?

Why We Still Need Moody

Fatherhood on the Rebound

Meditations: Drive-Through Christmas

Cassie Said Yes, They Say No

Dispatch From Sierra Leone: Suckled on Gunpowder

The Abortion Debate Is Over

Redeeming Fire

Making Room for God

Ending Hunger in Our Lifetime

New & Noteworthy: Church History

Doctorโ€™s Orders

Ban May Go to Supreme Court

Marketing Martyrdom to Teens

JESUS Film Debuts on DVD

In Brief: December 06, 1999

Feed the Children Battles Controversy

Court Upholds Video Poker Ban

Violence Mars Bonnke's Revival

Arrested Christians Face Deportation

In Brief: December 06, 1999

Hindus Protest Papal Visit

First United Nations 'Spiritual Summit' Planned

Wire Story

Plans for Meeting Between Baptist Jewish Heads Called Off

Wire Story

Homosexuality: Falwell Tames His Tongue

Wire Story

Christians Protest Proposed Mosque

Moscow Meeting Eases Russia's Interchurch Tensions

The Grove Press Bible

Positive About Potter

Lord's Prayer a Musical Hit in United Kingdom

Jailed Sudanese Priests Reject presidential Amnesty

Two Major Philippine Churches Sign Agreement for Closer Links

Leading German Bishop Says Church Will Bow to Rome in Abortion Controversy

Tashkent Christian Threatened with Two-Year Prison Term

New Delhi Center Dedicated to Princess Di's Wish to End 'Stigma' of Leprosy

Homosexual Group Institutes Award for Straight Religious Leaders

Amassed Media: Evolution Wars

Wire Story

Ministries Intensify As East Timorese Refugee Camps Grow

Jerusalem's Church Leaders Usher in Millennium Celebrations

Help Us Develop Our Souls Mandela Tells World Religious Leaders

Australian Church Agrees to Run Controversial Room for Injecting Drugs

Leading Catholic Theologian Outlines His Vision of Next Pope

Campbell Remains Optimistic As She Looks to Life After the NCC

Amassed Media: God Bless America's Candidates

One Denomination at Its Best and Worst

Letters

Ned Grahamโ€™s Woes Shake East Gates

Texas Southern Baptists: Submission Rejected

Brazil: Scholars Debate Mission Methods

Alabama: An Education Gamble

Buddhism: Spirituality Without Religion

Editorial

More of the Same

View issue

Our Latest

Review

The Internetโ€™s Sins Are Our Sins. But It Shouldnโ€™t Escape All Blame.

A critic of tech panic forgets that our tools shape us just as we shape them.

Heaven Is A Homeplace

Hurricane Helene devastated the land I love. My pain points me toward what’s to come.

Review

We Have Never Been Deplorable

A new book critiques elitesโ€™ incurious accounts of the American right and illuminates their complicity in our social breakdown.

You Are the Light of the Public Square

American Christians can illuminate our countryโ€™s politicsโ€”if we engage with moral imagination, neighborliness, boldness, and humility.

Where Ya From?

From Pain to Empowerment with Orsika Fejer-Baas

Orsika Fejer-Baas shares her story of resilience and overcoming domestic abuse.

The Bulletin

October 7, 2023 Remembrance with Yossi Halevi

The Bulletin remembers the tragic events in Israel on October 7, 2023 and the year of turmoil that has come after.

News

UK Regulators Investigate Barnabas Aid over Reports of Misused Funds

The charity is under an โ€œunprecedented level of scrutiny on our financial processesโ€ after founders and top leaders were suspended.

News

Global Methodist Bishops to Dance

The new denomination tussles over its authority structureโ€”but also finds surprising points of unity.ย 

Apple PodcastsDown ArrowDown ArrowDown Arrowarrow_left_altLeft ArrowLeft ArrowRight ArrowRight ArrowRight Arrowarrow_up_altUp ArrowUp ArrowAvailable at Amazoncaret-downCloseCloseEmailEmailExpandExpandExternalExternalFacebookfacebook-squareGiftGiftGooglegoogleGoogle KeephamburgerInstagraminstagram-squareLinkLinklinkedin-squareListenListenListenChristianity TodayCT Creative Studio Logologo_orgMegaphoneMenuMenupausePinterestPlayPlayPocketPodcastRSSRSSSaveSaveSaveSearchSearchsearchSpotifyStitcherTelegramTable of ContentsTable of Contentstwitter-squareWhatsAppXYouTubeYouTube