News

YouTube’s Blocked Testimony

(UPDATED) An ex-Muslim’s lawsuit has implications for law and church.

Update (July 7): Ergun Caner has been ordered to pay more than $34,000 in attorney's fees in a copyright infringement lawsuit concerning YouTube videos used to explain his Muslim past. A federal judge on July 1 dismissed the lawsuit, declaring that, of two videos in question, one was protected under the U.S. Copyright Office's fair use doctrine and Caner did not adequately prepare for a copyright lawsuit over the other.

In his opinion, Virginia district court judge Norman Moon further noted that Caner used "frivolous arguments" and was "objectively unreasonable" during the case:

[Caner]'s conduct in this court leads me to conclude that he acted with improper motive in bringing this suit, that he took multiple, objectively unreasonable legal and factual positions, and that a fee award is needed to encourage defendants like Autry to protect their rights against those who, like Caner, seek to suppress criticism. Equally, those like Caner should be deterred from exploiting the court system for their own purposes.

The Associated Baptist Press reports more details.

—–

Critics of ex-Muslim academic Ergun Caner say his attempt to remove online videos of his talks is designed to quell criticism. Caner's attorney says it's a case of simply defending copyright.

The case is slowly working its way through federal court, and has implications for how churches communicate.

Now a vice president at Arlington Baptist Theological Seminary near Dallas, Caner sued two men last June for posting the videos on YouTube.

The videos show Caner in 2005 warning U.S. Marines that Muslims are a danger. They were first posted by Jason Smathers, an Arizona Baptist pastor, who got them from the Marines through a Freedom of Information Act request. Jonathan Autry, a graduate of Liberty Baptist Theological Seminary, where Caner had been dean, saw them and became concerned. He believed Caner had tried to deceive people into believing that he (Caner) had been a radicalized Muslim from Turkey.

Autry believed that because Caner was "lying to Marines in the midst of two wars," he was someone "people needed to be warned about." He posted 34 videos of Caner on his own YouTube channel. YouTube took down the videos, but Autry and Smathers successfully appealed to have them republished. Caner is suing to have them removed permanently. He is also seeking compensation.

The coauthor of Unveiling Islam, Caner in 2005 became the first former Muslim to head an evangelical seminary. Liberty Seminary removed him as dean in 2010 after bloggers challenged his testimony.

Kel McClanahan, attorney for Smathers, says Caner is dodging accountability.

Caner attorney David Gibbs III says Caner has the right to control how his work is distributed. "Just like music and [books], speech can have copyright protection," he said.

Douglas Laycock, a law professor at the University of Virginia, said the case could shape how courts understand "fair use" exceptions to copyright. "Copyright holders think a lot of that [criticism] is infringing; those who make such works think they are engaged in free speech," he said. "Courts struggle to draw the line."

Gibbs warned church leaders that the long online life of digital content increases the possibility of litigation. The attorney advises pastors to think twice before posting every sermon online. "The cyber-attack crowd aims to hurt and destroy Christian leaders," he said.

Autry says his intent was not to hurt Caner's ministry but to inform people about it. He felt that because he previously promoted Caner as a trustworthy spiritual leader, he now needed to say something.

"The damage," Autry said, "is probably best described as having one's trust violated."

Also in this issue

The CT archives are a rich treasure of biblical wisdom and insight from our past. Some things we would say differently today, and some stances we've changed. But overall, we're amazed at how relevant so much of this content is. We trust that you'll find it a helpful resource.

Cover Story

New Life After the Fall of Ted Haggard

Cover Story

Letting Pastors Be Real

Reply All

Testimony

How I Escaped the Mormon Temple

The Gift of Being Evangelical

Peace and Goodwill? 'Bah, Humbug,' Says the Holy Spirit

Biblical Adoption Is Not What You Think It Is

Three Views: Why Confess Sins in Worship When It Seems So Rote?

Editorial

Four Powerful Ways to Solve the Crisis in Orphan Care

Miracle of Science: 65 Diseases Treated With Adult Stem Cells

Perfecting 'The Ask'

Trauma Counseling for Christian Journalists

Christ In Color

Meet the Christian Reporter Climbing the Ladder at The New York Times

The Scary Truth About Christian Giving

Review

Stop Blaming 'The Culture' for Our Distorted View of God

Review

What Birmingham Means Today

Eric Metaxas: My Top 5 Books for Nonbelievers

New & Noteworthy Books

Trading Tracts for Trafficking

News

Help the Persecuted Stay? Or Help Them Move?

News

Gleanings: December 2013

News

Should Christian Colleges Encourage Students to Marry Each Other?

News

Church and State (Dept.): John Kerry Gets Religion

News

Why So Many Christians Are Relaxing Over Drinks

View issue

Our Latest

News

Back at Shooting Site, Trump Supporters Pray for His Protection

Still shaken by the tragic attack, Butler, Pennsylvania, welcomed the former president back with cheers of triumph and a memorial for the previous rally’s victim.

News

JD Vance Says Trump White House Will ‘Fight for Israel’

The candidate’s message at an October 7 memorial rally was popular among Christian supporters.

Review

The Internet’s Sins Are Our Sins. But It Shouldn’t Escape All Blame.

A critic of tech panic forgets that our tools shape us just as we shape them.

Heaven Is A Homeplace

Hurricane Helene devastated the land I love. My pain points me toward what’s to come.

Review

We Have Never Been Deplorable

A new book critiques elites’ incurious accounts of the American right and illuminates their complicity in our social breakdown.

You Are the Light of the Public Square

American Christians can illuminate our country’s politics—if we engage with moral imagination, neighborliness, boldness, and humility.

Where Ya From?

From Pain to Empowerment with Orsika Fejer-Baas

Orsika Fejer-Baas shares her story of resilience and overcoming domestic abuse.

The Bulletin

October 7, 2023 Remembrance with Yossi Halevi

The Bulletin remembers the tragic events in Israel on October 7, 2023 and the year of turmoil that has come after.

Apple PodcastsDown ArrowDown ArrowDown Arrowarrow_left_altLeft ArrowLeft ArrowRight ArrowRight ArrowRight Arrowarrow_up_altUp ArrowUp ArrowAvailable at Amazoncaret-downCloseCloseEmailEmailExpandExpandExternalExternalFacebookfacebook-squareGiftGiftGooglegoogleGoogle KeephamburgerInstagraminstagram-squareLinkLinklinkedin-squareListenListenListenChristianity TodayCT Creative Studio Logologo_orgMegaphoneMenuMenupausePinterestPlayPlayPocketPodcastRSSRSSSaveSaveSaveSearchSearchsearchSpotifyStitcherTelegramTable of ContentsTable of Contentstwitter-squareWhatsAppXYouTubeYouTube