The Dallas Morning News reviews what bishops knew
For the last three months The Dallas Morning News has studied what U.S. bishops knew and did about sexual abuse in their dioceses. In results released today, the paper reports that "roughly two-thirds of the top U.S. Catholic leaders have allowed priests accused of sexual abuse to keep working."
The study finds that 111 of 178 bishops either ignored warnings about suspicious behavior or failed to dismiss priests after admissions of wrongdoing, diagnoses of sexual disorders, legal settlements, or even criminal convictions. The 111 bishops are from at least 40 states and eight are now cardinals in U.S. archdioceses.
Today's article looks at the shadow these findings cast on this week's bishops' meeting in Dallas and explains why bishops would have allowed accused priests to stay in their parishes or be moved to other communities. Two of the common explanations of bishops's actions are "they did what they did many years ago [and] on the advice of skilled therapists who had treated the priests."
While many of the cases now being exposed are decades old, The Dallas Morning News found several examples of accused priests transferred or left in their congregations since the late 1990s.
The Rev. Francis Maniscalco, a spokesman for the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops, told the paper that deciding on the best methods to handle clergy sexual abuse has been an issue for decades and individual bishops made the most prudent choices they could.
"Why should anybody's feet be held to the fire?" he asked. "The bishops made what they thought were prudent decisions at the time. The decisions were made on the best advice available."
Other stories on the sex abuse scandal include:
- The head of the Catholic bishops group gains stature amid church scandal | One key American figure has gained stature this year -- Bishop Wilton Gregory, the prelate who will lead this week's conference. (Associated Press)
- Two more bishops resign in sex scandal church | Leaders to meet to discuss policy on abusive priests (The Washington Post)
- Also: Bishop quits as others prepare to meet on abuse scandal (The New York Times)
- Also: Two bishops step down in Catholic sex scandal (The Washington Times)
- Bishops confront demands to give more power to laity | As the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops prepares to convene Thursday in Dallas for the first time since the scandal erupted, the bishops face a day of judgment. (Los Angeles Times)
- Also: Bishop quits as others prepare to meet on abuse scandal (The New York Times)
- People in the pews speak out on web | Voice of the Faithful receives over 500 e-mails a day on scandal. (Newsday)
- Once a victim, a priest wants zero tolerance | He became a priest, but also became the president of a victims' group. (The New York Times)
- Four churches, one priest: ministry's new math | Pastor logs miles as he tends to flocks in age of Catholic clergy shortage. (The Dallas Morning News)
- Bishops may meet with victims' group | Bishop Wilton Gregory, president of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops, said Monday that he would contact members of SNAP. (The Dallas Morning News)
- Church abuse policy criticized by Texas author (Daily Texan)
- Lawyers question Brooklyn bishop on what he knew of priest abuse allegations | Bishop Thomas Daily of Brooklyn was questioned Monday about his dealings with a defrocked priest whose case sparked the sex abuse scandal within the Catholic church. (Associated Press)
- Scholars say prayer not enough in scandal | After decades in which the Catholic Church frequently described the crisis in theological terms, many bishops and others are saying one lesson they have learned is that spirituality is not enough. (The Boston Globe)
Missouri monks mourn; police find no motive in killings
The bells of Missouri's Conception Abbey rang 80 times yesterday, one for each year that two slain monks had given to their faith. The monks did not gather for group prayer but privately meditated while police continued to canvass the crime scene where Lloyd Robert Jeffress, 71, killed Brother Damian Larson and the Rev. Philip Schuster on Monday. Two others were seriously wounded.
Investigators still do not know why Jeffress, a former Catholic who recently attended a Methodist church, would open fire in the monastery before taking his own life. In fact, they can figure out little of anything about the man.
"It's very unusual to find a person this private, where their family doesn't even have contact with him," Sgt. Sheldon A. Lyon, a Missouri Highway Patrol spokesman, told The New York Times. "It makes it difficult to say why this man would do this. Usually there are some red flags that indicate why a gunman like this will have acted the way he did. But that's not the case here."
New York kindergartner can pray at snack time
In January five-year-old Kayla Broadus held hands with classmates and prayed over their cupcakes and milk, "God is good. God is great. Thank you, God, for my food." Her teacher stopped her, citing separation of church and state; the principal agreed.
In response, Broadus' mother filed a lawsuit that was settled last night by a school board vote. In the settlement, which the board approved unanimously, no payments will be made, the lawsuit is dropped, and Kayla can pray. The New York school district also does not have to admit any wrongdoing.
The school board says nothing has changed. After the suit was filed, the Saratoga Springs Board of Education passed a resolution confirming that it never had a policy restricting audible prayer. Board of Education President Sandra Lewis told the local Saratogian: "Kayla was able to pray before the lawsuit and it will continue to remain the same."
Southern Baptist convention:
- Southern Baptists skip convention | Local churches don't send many to meetings. (The News & Observer)
- Southern Baptists take their message to strip clubs | Their mission was part of the Southern Baptist Convention's annual meeting. But the big story could be the Baptists who do not show up. (Chicago Tribune)
- Baptists' strong words spark protest| The head of the Southern Baptists condemned homosexuality from the podium yesterday as angry homosexual-rights protesters and a Muslim group marched through the convention hall. (The Washington Times)
- Also: Gay rights protesters disrupt Baptist meeting | 50 arrested at St. Louis convention. (The Dallas Morning News)
- Also: Protesters interrupt Baptist meeting (Associated Press)
- Muslims angered by Southern Baptist on Islam | A leading Islamic group demanded Tuesday that the Southern Baptist Convention condemn "bigoted" and "hate-filled" statements made by one of its pastors. (CNN)
- Also: Pastors back Vines' comments on Islam (Atlanta Journal-Constitution)
Politics and law:
- Church leaders want judge to okay settlement | Lawsuit accused Cincinnati police of harassing blacks (Associated Press)
- The last pro-life democrat? | Robert Casey Jr's crushing defeat raises a question with national political implications (Robert Novak)
Other stories of interest:
- Folks flock to church to see face of Jesus | Pastor notices apparition while closing up church (WPBF, West Palm Beach, Fla.)
- Sects and the Church | If it is truly serious about opposing new religious movements, the Orthodox Church should rely more on its own preaching and internal discipline and less on the courts and police. (Lawrence Uzzell, The Moscow Times)
- A faith near to heaven | A century and a half ago, French priests brought Catholicism to the Tibetan plateau. There it has endured, despite war, Maoism and rival religions. (Los Angeles Times)
- Youth Day cross arrives in Toronto | 'It's not made of marble. It's just ordinary wood. It's very touchable, it's very tangible': 43-day trek by foot. (National Post)
- Flying monks and piercing pain at Christian exhibit | Masterpieces from the Vatican and other Italian Collections has been brought to Toronto by the Catholic Church and Hydro One. (National Post)
- Churches vow before Queen to work for unity | Archbishop of Canterbury says said that although the Churches were still separate institutions, the past few decades had seen an enormous rapprochement (The Times, London)
- Royals at prayer for coronation day | Call for unity as Christian leaders attend Windsor service (The Guardian, London)
- Pope, Orthodox Leader Sign Document | Both the pope and Ecumenical Patriarch Bartholomew I have described the declaration as another step in helping bridge the nearly 1,000-year-old rift. (Associated Press)
- Pope courts Anglicans in attempt to heal rift | The Vatican has invited Anglicans, including a woman priest, to an unprecedented conference this week in an attempt to end four centuries of division between the Roman Catholic Church and the Church of England. (The Times, London)
- A spiritual centennial | Point Loma Nazarene stays true to its roots in stress on spiritual and academic values (San Diego Union-Tribune)
- Conservative Lilongwe grapples with sex education | Malawi Censorship Board has ordered the removal of a controversial condom advertisement that it has declared offensive and pornographic. (UN Integrated Regional Information Networks)
- Area Protestant schools host 'non-proms' | Dancing is notably absent from many of the program, but not prom gowns, tuxedos, corsages, limosines and other traditional trappings of the graduates' big night. (The Herndon [Va.] Times)
- A majority of those surveyed want evolution, intelligent design to get equal time in school | The State Board of Education is struggling with the issue of what students should learn about human origins. (The Plain Dealer, Cleveland)
- New bishop eyes politics | Chane has also questioned the bodily resurrection of Jesus Christ. (The Washington Times)
- Bishop Chane's brave, new Episcopalians | Bishop Chane has promised to make Washington the "most exciting diocese in the Episcopal Church." Exciting, perhaps, in the way that a plane crash or a soccer riot is exciting. (Editorial, The Washington Times)
Copyright © 2002 Christianity Today. Click for reprint information.
See our past Weblog updates:
June 11 | 10
June 7 | 6 | 5 | 4 | 3
May 31 | 30 | 29 | 28
May 24 | 23 | 22 | 21 | 20
May 17 | 16 | 15 | 14 | 13
May 9 | 8 | 7 | 6
Subscribe to Christianity Today and get access to this article plus 65+ years of archives.
- Home delivery of CT magazine
- Complete access to articles on ChristianityToday.com
- Over 120 years of magazine archives plus full access to all of CT’s online archives
- Learn more
Read These Next
- TrendingDon’t Pretend the Ugandan Homosexuality Law Is ChristianNot everything that’s a sin is a crime—let alone one punishable by death.Français简体中文繁體中文
- From the MagazineHow One Family’s Faith Survived Three Generations in the PulpitWith a front-row seat to their parents’ failures and burnout, a long line of pastor’s kids still went into ministry. Why?
- Editor's PickPCA’s 50th Anniversary Comes During a Season of GriefPresbyterians expect less fight and more fatigue as they gather following the Covenant shooting and the deaths of Harry Reeder and Tim Keller.