Several newspapers this morning report clergy members' reaction to President Bush's address last night (text | audio | video ) promising military action if Saddam Hussein does not go into exile. Given denominational leaders' earlier comments opposing any U.S. military action in Iraq, it's not surprising that most clergy members still oppose it.
"It's not Thomas Aquinas, who gave reasons for a just war, but the founder of Christianity, Jesus Christ, who said 'Blessed are the peacemakers, for they are the children of God,' " J. Alfred Smith, senior pastor of Allen Temple Baptist Church in Oakland, California, said at a news conference. "If it's wrong for blacks to kill each other in the Oakland flatlands, it's also immoral for them to participate in a war where they would be pouncing on a small country."
The Vatican, which has opposed an attack on Saddam Hussein, responded to Bush's speech in a somewhat cloudy one-line statement: "Those who decide that all peaceful means that international law makes available are exhausted assume a grave responsibility before God, their conscience, and history."
But there's some indication through other newspapers that clergy are supporting Bush now that war seems more inevitable. "I respect President Bush and his moral character," Mark Eaton, pastor of Porterfield Baptist Church in Little Hocking, Ohio, told the Marietta Times. "I know he would not send our troops to war without a real threat from Saddam Hussein. … For weeks, months, our church has been praying for Bush, for his advisers, for Congress. We have been praying for wisdom to do what is right."
"I am not in favor of a total anti-war movement. I stand opposed to that," Lawrence Richmond of Anchor Baptist Church in Ledyard, Connecticut, told Newsday. "We have a biblical responsibility to submit ourselves to … authority."
Kenneth Hostetler, pastor of Trinity United Methodist Church in Arcadia, Florida, approved of Bush's address. "It didn't leave any doubt in the American mind as far as where we stand," he tells the Charlotte Harbor Sun. "I really feel, biblically, God has given nations the responsibility to administer justice and the church the responsibility to administer mercy and grace. [Bush has been] generous in mercy and grace to Saddam Hussein."
Charles J. Simones of St. Sophia Hellenic Orthodox Church in New London, Connecticut, apparently has the opposite problem of many church leaders around the country: he's more in favor of military intervention than his parishioners are. "You have a holy responsibility to take up arms to protect your family, your country, and the Christian faith," he tells Newsday.
Even Unitarian Universalist ministers are backing Bush. "It's hard to argue with his logic," Diane Dowgiert told the Marietta Times, though she adds, "I have not seen anywhere in the world where war has made a more peaceful planet."
But does what a pastor thinks about war really influence the congregation? Richard Ostling of the Associated Press notes a Gallup poll earlier this month that says 63 percent of those who attend church almost weekly favored a U.S. military invasion of Iraq, while 59 percent of the general public supported it. The difference isn't much more than the three-point margin of error.
Washington Episcopalian Jim Oakes says his church's presiding bishop, Frank Griswold, is free to oppose the war "as a private citizen," but says, "I strongly object to his claiming to represent the body of the Episcopal Church, because he doesn't. It's similar to a rock star making pronouncements on world peace. It's very interesting, but what do they know?"
Religion historian Martin Marty puts it this way: "The mainstream Protestant laity has been roughly where the public is as long as I've known them. Barring some special factor, the laity is indistinguishable from the larger culture."
The mainline is indistinguishable from the larger culture? Hey, he said it. Not us.
Meanwhile, the National Association of Evangelicals is keeping clear of the should-we-or-shouldn't-we debate. Rich Cizik, the group's vice president of government affairs, has been one of the more hawkish voices in the religious debate lately, but a press release from new NAE president Ted Haggard calls for prayer without taking sides. "I encourage prayers for a peaceful resolution to this situation," Haggard says. "As the likelihood of armed conflict increases, I ask Americans to pray for God to protect innocent lives, give wisdom to our leaders, and advance the cause of freedom."
More on war with Iraq:
- US churches urge Blair to stop war | Sojourners spent an estimated £100,000 ($156,000) placing ads in British newspapers (The Guardian, London)
- Bush's Messiah complex | He may have discarded the word "crusade," but it's a crusade that he's on. (The Progressive)
- Church groups urge John Howard to peacefully resolve Iraq crisis | Even fundamentalist Christians such as Dr Peter Jensen, the Anglican Archbishop of Sydney, remain unconvinced (The World Today, Australian Broadcasting Corp)
- Field day of doom prophets | One is stunned by the creativity the prospect of the final battle manages to stir in the virtual world of the Web. (Uwe Siemon-Netto, UPI)
- Southern Baptists publicly support war | Among the nation's major religious orders, only the Southern Baptist Convention publicly supports war with Iraq (The Daily News, Galveston County, Tex.)
- Jeeeee-hawd! Bush's war cry? | After reading a load of Bush's speeches and interviews when he has talked about God and Iraq in the same breath, I see a guy who prays for strength and counsel and who has a religious faith that good will triumph, somehow. I don't see a guy who thinks he's God's personal agent. (Dick Meyer, CBS News)
- Religious groups go online for peace | Groups representing Christians, Jews and Muslims are using the Internet to express antiwar sentiments and, in some cases, rally support for the broader peace movement (The Washington Post)
- Iraqi Christians fear post-Saddam Islamists | Iraq's Christian minority fears that religious tolerance may be an unintended casualty of any U.S.-led war to topple President Saddam Hussein (Reuters)
- Sermons of 1776, with a spirit of 2003 | Members of the First Presbyterian Church in Greenwich Village have discovered two sermons dating from the Revolutionary War (The New York Times)
- Also: A battle cry for revolution | In a sermon excerpted here and dated Jan. 14, 1776, the Rev. John Rodgers, pastor of the First Presbyterian Church of New York, issued a call to arms (The New York Times)
Persecution and violence:
- Christians brace for more hits | One year after a suicide bomber killed four worshippers in a Christian church in Islamabad, church leaders warned on Monday that a war on Iraq could trigger more deadly attacks against the Christian minority (The Daily Times, Pakistan)
- Also: Fears for Pakistani Christians (BBC)
- No particular concern | Leaving Saudi Arabia off the list of countries that have "engaged in or tolerated particularly severe violations of religious freedom" is a particular affront to fact and logic (Editorial, The Washington Post)
- Price of redemption | Slavery in Sudan is a reality. Some Americans buy and free slaves, but several humanitarian groups say this only creates more trouble (Ventura County [Calif.] Star)
- Hindu campaigners combat Christian conversions | Secularists see a more sinister plan behind the rivalry, accusing the Hindu right-wing of whipping up fear of Christian conversions in the same way as fascism traditionally creates an artificial enemy in order to flourish (Reuters)
- Hot cross banned | Councils decree buns could be 'offensive' to non-Christians (The Daily Telegraph, London)
- Nazareth panel wants mosque razed before appeal decision | The district planning committee asked the court to prevent the Waqf from "playing for time with claims that have already been rejected in the past." (Haaretz, Tel Aviv, Israel)
- Palestinian Christian family fights for farm | Alison Jones-Nassar and her family are living at a different kind of ground zero, in the midst of one of the world's most intractable human conflicts (Richmond [Va.] Times-Dispatch)
- Israeli couple surrender inside Nativity Church | Clergymen had initially thought the couple was armed (Reuters)
- Also: Couple who entered Church of the Nativity with fake guns surrender to authorities (Associated Press)
- Verdict expected in Kopp trial | Pro-choice groups are confident that Tuesday will be the day that James Kopp will finally be convicted of murdering a U.S. abortion doctor—yet they remain worried that other fundamentalist Christian gunmen are prepared to pick up where Mr. Kopp left off (The Globe and Mail, Toronto)
Church and state:
- ACLU doesn't want Fremont to replace religious marker knocked off base | Marker's pins sheared off after car slides into it (The Grand Island [Neb.] Independent)
- Ten Commandments to be part of display in county building | Historic documents, two flags to be installed this week (Elkhart [Ind.] Truth)
- Roy Moore's lawyers say monument is constitutional | Phillip L. Jauregui of Birmingham and Herbert W. Titus of Virginia Beach, Va., asked the 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals to overturn U.S. District Judge Myron Thompson's Nov. 18 ruling that the monument violates the First Amendment's ban on state establishment of religion as well as his Dec. 19 order to remove the monument (The Birmingham [Ala.] News)
- Schools to accept baptized children first | Parents will be asked for proof that their children have been baptized as part of a series of steps designed to reduce the intake of pupils to popular schools in the capital. (The Scotsman)
- Elite Anglican schools feel a chill from the winds of Jensenism | Educators wonder how the tug-of-war in the church could affect their institutions (The Sydney Morning Herald)
- War may delay school prayer bill | Florida House Speaker Johnnie Byrd, who has voted for the bill in past years himself, says the timing isn't right to take such a measure to the House floor (Tallahassee Democrat)
- Indonesian teachers protest over religious education bill | Religion-based schools which are open to children from other faiths will in future have to provide religious teachers for those faiths (Radio Australia)
Missions and ministry:
- The book of numbers | Rick Warren's purpose-driven attack on American Christianity (Slate.com)
- Man dies on mission trip to Guatemala | Family awaits results of autopsy but says Jimmy Scarbrough injured his head in a fall believed caused by either an aneurysm or a heart attack (Mobile [Ala.] Register)
- Blacks find mission possible | Global ranks growing as economics, education improve (The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)
- Holland natives' website is based in faith | Christdot is designed as a Web forum for discussion of religion and news from a Christian viewpoint (Associated Press)
- Related: Christdot
- Religion forum more divisive than diverse | The ADL's 'No Place for Hate' process is so deeply flawed it's not worth pursuing (Editorial, York [Penn.] Daily Record)
- Christian crusades for Jews | During the past 14 months, Schindler's Ark has taken in $13,600, which it has redistributed to various groups devoted to protecting and otherwise helping Israel's Jews (Contra Costa [Calif.] Times)
- Dissenters criticize United Baptist | More than 20 alienated members and a former pastor attended the annual UBC meeting, most of them ineligible to vote (Sun Journal, Lewiston, Maine)
- Surrounded by Harvard, and hoping to survive | Parishioners at the Swedenborg Chapel, a gray Gothic speck in the crowded crimson landscape of Cambridge, Mass., must raise $2 million by Sept. 30 to keep their church (The New York Times)
- Chapel that embraces all creeds | Simple cubicle provides place to pray at sea (Seattle Post-Intelligencer)
Christianity and faith:
- Do spiritual people live their faith? | Remarkably, a new Gallup Poll reports that 79.8% of Americans would say yes to these questions which measure an "Inner Commitment" to God, a vertical relationship with Him. (The Daily Journal, Kankakee Ill.)
- On the low road to Jensenism | We are in an era of what the political scientist Ken Minogue has called "Christophobia", in which tolerance is offered to any religion save Christianity, and even many nominal Christians cannot tolerate those of their co-religionists who take it literally and seriously. (Paddy McGuinness, The Sydney Morning Herald)
- A question of faith | Round Table discussion with teens tackles how religion affects their lives (The Courier-Journal, Louisville, Ky.)
Copyright © 2003 Christianity Today. Click for reprint information.
Suggest links and stories by sending e-mail to firstname.lastname@example.org
See our past Weblog updates:
and more, back to November 1999
Subscribe to Christianity Today and get access to this article plus 65+ years of archives.
- Home delivery of CT magazine
- Complete access to articles on ChristianityToday.com
- Over 120 years of magazine archives plus full access to all of CT’s online archives
- Learn more