Tim and Jerry on the cover of Newsweek
What more can be said about the Left Behind series? Not much, though this week's Newsweekcover story tries to go for one less-played angle by profiling authors Tim LaHaye and Jerry Jenkins rather than focusing on the popularity of premillennial dispensationalism.
There's some nice bits in the piece, though LaHaye comes off as a bit caustic while Jenkins is the humble peacemaker. When it comes to salvation and eschatology, writer David Gates understands that they're talking about the same thing in different ways. But he misses the similarity when they start talking about themselves.
"Those millions that I'm trying to reach take the Bible literally," LaHaye says. "It's the theologians that get all fouled up on some of these smug ideas that you've got to find some theological reason behind it. It bugs me that intellectuals look down their noses at we ordinary people."
Ah, a heaping helping of anti-intellectualism, which Gates attributes to a "still-aggrieved sense of social class."
Jenkins says, "Pedestrian writing, thin characters—I can handle the criticism," he says. "I write to pedestrians. And I am a pedestrian. I write the best I can. I know I'm never going to be revered as some classic writer. I don't claim to be C.S. Lewis. The literary-type writers, I admire them. I wish I was smart enough to write a book that's hard to read, you know?" Gates characterizes this as evidence of Jenkins "chronic modesty," but misses the jibe. That's gloating, friend.
Ah, but while the magazine promises to show how the "contrasting sensibilities" of the "most successful literary partnership of all time … suggest the complexities of the entire evangelical movement, often seen as monolithic," it can't help but add to those same mistaken stereotypes. Newsweek explains that evangelicals are "Christians who say they have a personal relationship with Jesus Christ," while Fundamentalists are "Christians who believe the Bible is the literal, inerrant word of God."
In a sidebar, fundamentalists are contrasted with Eastern Orthodox Christians and Lutherans, as Lisa Miller explains that "Christian fundamentalists … are devoted to Revelation, and believe that the events it describes will come to pass—perhaps sooner rather than later."
There's a hint that LaHaye is supposed to represent fundamentalists while Jenkins is more of the evangelical fold, but there's little help for the reader who tries to discern the difference between the two groups, or whether one is a subset of the other.
Likewise, there's no hint about whether the critical "fellow Christians, who find the books more interested in God's wrath than God's love, as well as scripturally questionable" are evangelicals, fundamentalists, or some other breed. Over at GetReligion, Terry Mattingly rightly critiques the article as mischaracterizing the eschatology debate as one between liberals and conservatives. "Even in most Episcopal churches, the congregation still affirms its belief that 'Christ has died, Christ is risen, Christ will come again,'" he writes. "The disagreements center on what the world will look like until then."
Newsweek repeatedly suggests that Left Behind is popular because of global terrorism and the Iraq war. "That LaHaye and Jenkins's books are selling so briskly at a time of global chaos suggests that millions are taking refuge in literal renderings of Scripture, seeking a port amid the storm of the present," writes editor Jon Meacham. Problems like the abuse at Abu Ghraib prison raise "Difficult questions, with … few easy answers. Little wonder, then, that so many people are turning to fiction to alleviate the burden of fact."
Likewise, writes Gates, "As the world gets increasingly scary, with much of the trouble centered in the Mideast—just where you'd expect from reading the Book of Revelation—even secular Americans sometimes wonder (or at least wonder if they ought to start wondering) whether there might not be something to this End Times stuff."
One small problem with this theory, though: Left Behind first came out in 1995, and the series was a bestseller long before 9/11.
Miller has a different theory:
John [the Revelator] was a passionate, furious Christian, and he had a very clear message, one that resonates strongly with evangelical Christians today: Do not be seduced by the temptations of secular culture. … Substitute a sex-drenched mainstream popular culture for the emperor, and you can begin to understand why the "Left Behind" books have hit such a nerve with evangelicals. Jenkins, LaHaye and their readers feel driven to defend their values and way of life against the onslaught of secularism, and for them, Revelation describes the battle lines.
But it's not only pre-millennial dispensationalists who share this concern about the onslaught of secularism. And that's the real story, says evangelical Anglican theologian Kendall Harmon:
The only way I know to teach about eschatology is to teach what Christians have understood about these things, and then to dialogue with dispensationalism and explain why those who teach it are wrong. I believe dispensationalists deserve our great respect, because at least they are trying to understand these vital subjects, whereas nearly every Episcopal Church ignores them. It is hypocritical in the extreme for mainline churches to sneer at Tim LaHaye and others without explaining why he is wrong (which he is) and what the right theology is in all of this.
In short, Newsweek's piece is fine, but it's just one more pass over overplowed sod (as is a sidebar drawing a spurious line from Left Behind theology to Bush's foreign policy). The magazine is late to the party, but it's still better than its odd Christian music piece a few years back. Examining LaHaye and Jenkins as archetypes for various streams in the evangelical movement actually could have been a fresh angle, so long as it didn't stray into angry fundamentalist vs. friendly evangelical caricatures. Better to focus on LaHaye's longterm efforts to inform, teach, and disciple the church, how this differs from Jenkins's frequent efforts to create cultural (and largely evangelistic) artifacts that have mainstream appeal, and what the popularity Left Behind (along with Jabez, Veggie Tales, The Passion, and other recent Christian entries into popular culture) means when these two items meet. Have evangelicals changed their cultural engagement strategy from overt evangelistic appeals to seeing various aspects of theology as "entry points" into the larger Christian story?
The other article that hasn't yet been done: examining how the dispensationalist theology of the Left Behind books (and of Tim LaHaye specifically) differs from the "progressive dispensationalism" being taught at Dallas Theological Seminary, the cornerstone of such eschatological thought.
There are other stories, too, but time is running out. LaHaye and Jenkins are still writing a prequel and sequel to the core series, but articles on the Left Behind phenomenon are going to seem stale after the 10-year anniversary of the first book's publication.
- 20 dead in fresh Plateau violence despite state of emergency | More than 20 Christian villagers have been killed in a fresh outbreak of religious violence in Plateau State in central Nigeria, where President Olusegun Obasanjo imposed a state of emergency earlier this week, residents in the area told IRIN (IRIN)
- Nigerian state split on emergency | Residents of Plateau State are divided over the emergency which was declared this week after hundreds were killed in communal clashes (BBC)
- Nigerian papers round on president | The press in Nigeria has plenty of harsh words for President Olusegun Obasanjo following his decision to declare a state of emergency in the central state of Plateau in a bid to stem communal clashes there (BBC)
- Poverty behind Nigeria's violence | Nigeria's combination of poverty for the majority and wealth for the few makes it an ideal breeding ground for the sort of violence which led to a presidential order for a state of emergency to be declared in the centre of the country this week (BBC)
- Addressing Nigeria's economic problems and the Islamist terrorist threat | Islamist radicals hope to exploit Nigeria's poverty, political turmoil, and inadequate law enforcement--thereby making Nigeria a potential regional security threat (Ariel Cohen and Brett D. Schaefer, The Heritage Foundation)
- Genesis of a crisis | What has been happening in Plateau State in the last four months has its root in the ethno-religious carnage that swept through the state in September 2001 (Funmi Peter-Omale, This Day, Nigeria)
- Nigerian MPs back state emergency | Both houses of Nigeria's parliament have approved the state of emergency in the central state of Plateau declared by President Olusegun Obasanjo (BBC)
- Sudan militia violence spreads to the south | Government-backed Arab militias have razed the homes of 23 000 villagers in southern Sudan, despite talks to end 21 years of civil war, a senior church official said on Thursday (Reuters)
- Stopping Sudan's slow-motion genocide | Sudan is Rwanda in slow motion (Anthony Lake and John Prendergast, The Boston Globe)
- Slaughter in Sudan | Unless the world is spurred quickly to rescue the displaced villagers and ensure their safe return home, the likely result is massive suffering and death on a scale comparable to the genocide of 800,000 Tutsis by the Hutu military in Rwanda 10 years ago (Editorial, The Baltimore Sun)
Politics of Communion:
- Democrats criticize denial of communion by bishops | In a letter to a cardinal, 48 Roman Catholic lawmakers criticized threats by bishops to deny communion to pro-choice politicians (The New York Times)
- 48 House Catholics warn bishops' stance could spark bigotry (The Washington Post)
- Kerry and communion: The real issue | The media's obsession with his churchgoing misses the point. At stake is an attempt to erode the church-state boundary (Patricia O'Connell, BusinessWeek)
- Kerry open to antiabortion judges | Democrat John Kerry said Wednesday he's open to nominating anti-abortion judges as long as that doesn't lead to the Supreme Court overturning the landmark 1973 ruling that made abortion legal (Associated Press)
- Abortion-rights supporters stick by Kerry | Abortion-rights advocates are standing by Democratic presidential candidate John Kerry despite his comments in an interview that he would be open to nominating anti-abortion judges (Associated Press)
- Flip-flop-flip | Kerry's statements on prolife judges are contradictory (Ramesh Ponnuru, The Corner, National Review Online)
- The Kerry challenge | The Catholic difference (George Weigel, Ethics and Public Policy Center)
Religion & politics:
- End times | The Bushies may be accomplishing what liberals never could -- bringing the era of conservative morality to a close (Michael Tomasky, The American Prospect)
- A family business | For the Rev. Lou Sheldon and his daughter, marriage means only one thing (The Washington Post)
- Related: What the Post story missed (Ramesh Ponnuru, The Corner, National Review Online)
- Group sues over Democratic Convention protest plan | The process for getting permits to demonstrate at the Democratic National Convention in Boston tramples on free speech, a Christian group said on Wednesday in a federal lawsuit filed against the host city (Reuters)
- Religious beliefs vs. public service | Religious certitude comes with a conviction of righteousness and presumption that prevents people from seeing the errors of their ways or the heart and mind of others (Charles DeMotte, The Ithaca Journal, N.Y.)
- McGovern faces fight over 'values' | The nation's culture wars are coming to a new front: the Commonwealth's Third Congressional District (Joan Vennochi, The Boston Globe)
- Curve ball | Curves gym, with its no-stress workout for exercise-averse women, is the fastest-growing franchise in the U.S. But revelations that its founder gives millions of dollars to antiabortion groups has its customers divided over just what a "female-friendly" business is (Rebecca Traister, Salon.com)
- Religious leaders seek carbon dioxide monitors | A group of religious leaders and scientists issued a plea to the Senate asking lawmakers to pass legislation to regulate carbon dioxide and other gases linked to global climate change (The Washington Post, third item)
- Church leaders told "b***** off to Africa" | A spokesman for the British National Party has told Bramhall church leaders "to bugger off to Africa" after they urged Stockport voters to keep extreme right wingers out of local and European government (Stockport Express, England)
- Hearts and minds | The post-9/11 world is on PC-overload (Andrew C. McCarthy, National Review Online)
- Pueblo bishop joins debate | Pueblo Roman Catholic Bishop Arthur Tafoya has called on his flock this election year to consider not just abortion but also poverty, war, the death penalty and working for peace and justice (The Denver Post)
- Colombia's priests keep paths of peace open | Last week's agreement between right-wing militia leaders and the government was facilitated by the Catholic clergy (The Christian Science Monitor)
Church & state:
- Fundamentally unfaithful | By painting his case in black and white, Judge Roy Moore sells out his own religious tradition (James Heflin, Valley Advocate, Easthampton, Mass.)
- Prayer, angst come to council | Defending the name of Jesus Christ against perceived attack, a pastor invoked Jesus in an unofficial prayer during a Porterville City Council meeting Tuesday and was seconded by the comments of about half a dozen other citizens (The Porterville Recorder, Ca.)
- Pledge opponent fights legal fees in daughter custody case | The man who challenged the words "under God" in the Pledge of Allegiance argued that he should not be require to pay for lawyers "to take away my child." (Associated Press)
- U.S., Okla. settle Muslim head scarf case | A sixth-grade Muslim girl in Oklahoma can wear a head scarf to school under a settlement between the school district and the Justice Department, officials announced Wednesday (Associated Press)
- Kidnapped priest found in MMA MNA's home | Secret agencies accused of faking incident (The Daily Times, Pakistan)
- Kosovo's religious tables turned | Six years ago the US launched a noble experiment, becoming the first nation to proclaim international religious freedom as a goal of its foreign policy. Unfortunately, that experiment has been poisoned by interest-group politics (Lawrence A. Uzzell, The Christian Science Monitor)
- A fight to keep the faith | A young man of Pakistani origin tells Barney Zwartz of his long and bitter struggle since converting to Christianity (The Age, Melbourne, Australia)
- Culture clash in the South Seas | The mysterious John Frum movement has existed peacefully on an island in the South Pacific for decades; but a violent feud has now broken out between its followers and a new Christian movement (BBC)
War & terrorism:
- Kana's Iraq | A story you can't hear enough of (Meghan Clyne, National Review Online)
- Blind faith | Muslims, like Jews and Christians, must own up to problems in their holy book (Irshad Manji, The Wall Street Journal)
- The religious warrior of Abu Ghraib | An evangelical US general played a pivotal role in Iraqi prison reform (Sidney Blumenthal, The Guardian; also at Salon.com)
- You won, now give it back | In every Ponzi scheme, some investors profit early on. But courts can force them to return the money, even if they were unaware of the fraud (Los Angeles Times)
- Former Lodi pastor assaulted in Sacramento County | Mark Malvitz, a pastor throughout the 1990s in Lodi, Morada and Stockton who is being sued in Sacramento County on allegations of spiritual abuse, fraud and using church members' account numbers, was assaulted after a service last week, the Sacramento County Sheriff's Department said (Lodi News-Sentinel, Ca.)
Weigh Down Workshop raided:
- Ministry's offices searched for clues in boy's death | Detectives seize files from Weigh Down (The Tennessean, Nashville)
- Weigh Down crackdown | Faith-based weight loss headquarters raided for possible role in boy's death (Williamson County Review Appeal, Tenn.)
- Police raid Weigh Down Workshop | Police said the raid was part of a murder investigation (WTVF, Nashville, video)
Church day care under fire:
- Judge to hear dispute over church's 'camp' | State permitted to inspect facility (The Tennessean, Nashville)
- Deputies serve injunction to stop Bible school | There's no end to the legal standoff between an Antioch church and state officials (WTVF, Nashville)
Missions & ministry:
- Bible proofreaders sweat the small stuff | Thank the Lord — and the proofreaders at Peachtree Editorial and Proofreading — that the Bible refers to "our ancestors" instead of "sour ancestors," and calls for an end to "factions" — not "fractions." The proofreading service caught those typos and others before the latest edition of the Holy Book went to press (Associated Press)
- Episcopal diocese puts emphasis on health issues | Last Sunday, as every third Sunday of the month at Christ Episcopal Church in Columbia, Cynthia Willis offered blood pressure screenings to parishioners leaving the service (The Washington Post)
- 4 churches pledge $1 million for shelter | Four large evangelical Christian churches in the suburbs have pledged to raise $1 million to help build a facility in Buffalo for homeless women and children (The Buffalo News, N.Y.)
- XXXchurch wants no more XXX | The site -- which advertises itself as the No. 1 Christian porn site -- features downloadable bible studies, a virtual prayer wall and free software that records sites visited by Internet users and sends the log to a third party (Wired News)
- Faith and the fork | Is it time for religion to examine its role in expanding waistlines? (San Diego Union-Tribune, Ca.)
- Christian leader campaigns against anti-Semitic views | Earl Cox is the leader of the American Christian Reserve Israeli Defense Force, a group he first organized in South Carolina to combat what he perceives as the media's negative portrayal of Israel (The Post and Courier, Charleston, S.C.)
- Diversifying the pulpits and the pews | 'White flight' forces county churches into difficult 'stay or relocate' decisions (The Washington Post)
- U.K. cyber church tightens security | Britain's first three-dimensional cyber church has been forced to tighten security after a slew of abusive visitors ranted from the pulpit and swore in the aisles (Associated Press)
- Proposed church expansion causes neighborhood debate | Readers give their opinions on the proposed expansion of St. Andrew's Presbyterian Church (Daily Pilot, Newport Beach, Ca.)
- Lawyer reviews village zoning related to churches | Wilmette is one of many communities taking a look at its zoning laws concerning religious land use after a 2000 federal law has led to successful lawsuits by congregations who say zoning laws effectively bar them from opening new houses of worship (Wilmette Life, Ill.)
- Newark archdiocese may close 16 churches | The Roman Catholic Archdiocese of Newark has begun a major reorganization effort that will result in some of its churches being closed (The New York Times)
- Luther sparked a real revolt | Sewickley priest not a revolutionary (Brian David, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)
- Tucson bishop heading to Rome to meet Pope | The Roman Catholic Diocese of Tucson's ongoing woes with sexual-abuse lawsuits will be among the subjects Bishop Gerald F. Kicanas is expected to address when he heads to the Vatican next week (Associated Press)
- Mahony closes discussion on ousted priest | The Roman Catholic Archdiocese of Los Angeles said Wednesday it has no plans to give more details on the dismissal of a popular priest from a Covina church, saying that apparently no explanation will satisfy some parishioners (Pasadena Star News, Ca.)
- Earlier: Mahony letter gives reasons for popular pastor's removal | Cardinal Roger Mahony said a popular pastor released from St. Louise de Marillac Catholic Church this spring was emotionally unstable, harsh in exercising authority and interfered with an internal church investigation (Pasadena Star News, Ca.)
- Cardinal Mahony calls Southland priest emotionally unstable, harsh | popular Catholic priest transferred from a Covina parish was emotionally unstable and harsh in exercising authority, Cardinal Roger Mahony wrote in a letter to parishioners, it was reported Wednesday (KNBC, Los Angeles)
- Catholics: Belief is a private matter | A majority polled said church pressure on public officials was wrong - a boost for Gov. McGreevey, a pollster said (The Philadelphia Inquirer)
Marriage & divorce:
- Italy marriage vow to change to "I receive you" | Italian Roman Catholic bishops said on Wednesday they had approved the change to underscore that marriage should not be seen as one person possessing the other but each receiving the other as a gift from God (Reuters)
- Divorce: First, keep all the lawyers | Invented more than a decade ago, collaborative divorce is gaining in popularity around the nation and has recently made its way to New York State (The New York Times)
- Not a social contract | Marriage is more than affection and good times (Jennifer Roback Morse, National Review Online)
- Mrs. Bush welcomes gay-issues debate | Won't endorse amendment effort (The Boston Globe)
- Vt. likely to favor civil unions, AG says | Vermont's attorney general said yesterday that his state will probably consider Massachusetts same-sex marriages the equivalent of civil unions, whose approval in Vermont four years ago created a furor (The Boston Globe)
- The rite outfits | As same-sex couples who secured waivers of the three-day waiting period got hitched by city clerks and on-call justices of the peace, they wore just about everything from shorts, T-shirts, and baseball caps to vintage dresses and pinstriped suits, with plenty of linen in between (The Boston Globe)
- Gay marriage solves, creates money issues | While many people focus on the religious, moral, and ethical issues around gay marriage, the financial community are looking at the monetary picture (The Boston Globe)
- Losing its nonchalance, France feuds over gay vows | The leader of France's tiny leftist Green Party announced that he would defy tradition by officiating at France's first gay wedding ceremony (The New York Times)
- Will 'I dos' end the gay-marriage debate? | Based on a look at the past, social historians predict that after initial resistance, same-sex marriages will eventually gain public acceptance (The Christian Science Monitor)
- Same-sex rites pastors just can't get arrested | What if you broke the law to make a point and no one arrested you? That's what happened Tuesday to four pastors who defied Arizona law by marrying same-sex couples over the weekend (The Arizona Republic)
- Earlier: Ministers vow to fight Arizona ban on same-sex unions (Associated Press)
- 'Marriage' mayhem | It's all or nothing. Federalism isn't going to work (Stanley Kurtz, National Review Online)
- Values devaluation | Now that same sex marriage is on its way to a spurious legality, it is time to ask where does it end? If same sex marriage can be defined by the courts as legal, then why not polygamy, pedophilia, child marriage? (Arnold Beichman, The Washington Times)
- The right can't win this fight | With gay marriage on a roll, it's time to move on to another battle (Max Boot, Los Angeles Times)
- Slippery slop | The maddening "slippery slope" argument against gay marriage (Dahlia Lithwick, Slate)
Gay marriage in Mass.:
- Massachusetts Senate votes to end 1913 law | Action is tied to gay marriages (The Boston Globe)
- Massachusetts Senate vote aids gay 'marriages' | The Massachusetts state Senate yesterday voted overwhelmingly to repeal the 1913 law that Gov. Mitt Romney says forbids out-of-state homosexual couples from "marrying" in Massachusetts (The Washington Times)
Homosexuality and religion:
- Anglicans seek gay bishop removal | Eighteen Anglican archbishops, most of them from Africa and Asia and representing more than 55 million Anglicans, have called on the Episcopal Church to "repent" its pro-homosexual policies within three months or face expulsion from the worldwide Anglican Communion (The Washington Times)
- Tax rebellion over gay dean | The row over the appointment of gay priest Jeffrey John as Dean of St Albans escalated this week with one church openly rebelling by refusing to pay its diocesan tax (St. Albans Observer, England)
- Both sides in Presbyterian same-sex marriage dispute disappointed | A Presbyterian Church (USA) minister who resigned in a dispute over same-sex marriages and the church member who sought to rebuke him for performing them said Wednesday they foresee a time of tumult that could split the 2.5 million-member denomination (Associated Press)
- Adoption bills net praise, protest | Adoption agencies would be allowed to use moral and religious judgments when placing children in homes, under a set of bills proposed by a Lapeer County lawmaker (The Flint Journal, Mi.)
- Bishop calls for total ban on smacking | A bishop will try in the House of Lords today to outlaw parents smacking children (The Independent, London)
- Baby boy abandoned at church door | A newborn abandoned on the doorsteps of a church will be placed in state custody after the blond-haired boy is released from a hospital, police said (The Sun Herald, Biloxi, Miss.)
- Abandoning public schools is not the Christian thing to do | The school my kids attend has shown absolutely no hostility toward Christianity or religion (Phil Valentine, Williamson County Review Appeal, Tenn.)
- Â£8m Catholic-Anglican school plan | A Wrexham school is to become the first joint Catholic and Anglican secondary school in Wales (BBC)
- On sale at Urban Outfitters: irreverence | Funky retailer is lightning rod for controversy (Lexington Herald-Leader, Ky.)
- Some former customers angered by Christian dating service | Owner points to other success stories as evidence that it works (WFAA, Dallas)
- Daystar asks FCC to freeze KOCE sale | Christian broadcaster claims the board of KOCE-TV foundation doesn't represent the local community (The Independent, Huntington Beach, Ca.)
- Newspaper remains agnostic about voices on Catholicism | It is not for us to referee contests within the Catholic Church over who is legitimate and who is not. (Don Wycliff, Chicago Tribune)
- Culkin gets 'Saved!' from his crazy past | He giggles as he remembers one U-2 sound-alike Christian band where "a pastor gets up there and he's quoting Pink and Madonna more than the Bible, I mean it's crazy" (Zap2It.com)
Copyright © 2004 Christianity Today. Click for reprint information.
Suggest links and stories by sending e-mail to firstname.lastname@example.org
Check out Books & Culture's weekly weblog, Content & Context.
See our past Weblog updates:
and more, back to November 1999