When the Wisconsin Supreme Court handed down its decision in favor of a controversial Milwaukee “school choice” proposal last month, an unlikely cross-section of conservatives, liberals, Catholics, Protestants, Jews, and inner-city parents across the nation let out a cheer. For the first time, the idea of allowing poor families to use state funds to send their children to private schools had survived a constitutional challenge in the courts.

“It was a shot in the arm, … the boost [school choice] needed,” says Polly Williams, the Democratic Wisconsin state legislator who has become a nationally recognized spokesperson on the issue. Williams and other school-choice advocates believe the decision will now spark a national, grassroots revolution in education.

The idea of providing government support for options other than the public schools has been around for a long time, largely promoted by supporters of Catholic parochial schools. Today many proposals are being advanced, including allowing parents a choice between public schools, granting tax credits to families who use private schools, and distributing government vouchers that may be used at any school.

Support for the idea has broadened; school choice has become a pet issue for conservative Protestant groups, pro-family groups that promote traditional values, and low-income minority families who want the same flexibility as the wealthy.

In Wisconsin, the new coalition was able to pass the experimental “Milwaukee Parental Choice Program,” which allows inner-city children to use their state public-school funds in private, nonsectarian schools. The program was immediately challenged, but last month the state supreme court ruled that it “passes constitutional scrutiny.” Wrote Judge ...

Subscriber access only You have reached the end of this Article Preview

To continue reading, subscribe now. Subscribers have full digital access.

Have something to add about this? See something we missed? Share your feedback here.

Our digital archives are a work in progress. Let us know if corrections need to be made.