Judge: Ashcroft overstepped duties in enforcing law, but doctors don't overstep when they kill
U.S. District Court Judge Robert Jones ruled yesterday that the Department of Justice can't block Oregon's assisted-suicide law. The attorney general, Jones said, has no authority "to decide, as a matter of national policy, a question of such magnitude as whether physician-assisted suicide constitutes a legitimate medical purpose or practice." When Attorney General John Ashcroft decided to use federal drug laws to punish doctors who killed their patients, it was an effort "to get through the administrative door what they could not get through the Congressional door, seeking refuge with the newly appointed attorney general whose ideology matched their views."
That administrative door is apparently still closed, reports The Oregonian. "The decision … could inflame election year rhetoric in Congress, but decisive action against the law is unlikely soon," reports the Portland paper. Democrats control the Senate, and Republicans don't want to risk putting Sen. Gordon Smith against the Oregon voters who approved an assisted-suicide measure in 1994 and reaffirmed it in 1997. "If there were a Republican who was determined to press ahead on this, I think he would certainly get a lot of informal pressure from his colleagues to back off," Rutgers University political science professor Ross Baker tells the paper. "The last thing any Republican would want is to lose a Republican senator."
Meanwhile, religious and profamily groups are really upset. "Oregon's argument that its 'Death with Dignity Act' regulates the practice of medicine and that Ashcroft's order interferes with its state right to do so is preposterous on its face," says the Family Research Council's Jan LaRue. "A license to cure isn't a license to kill."
The Christian Medical Association agrees. "This judicial intrusion into the ethics of medicine that has protected patients for over two millennia is unconscionable," executive director David Stevens says. "Do we really want to return to the days before Hippocrates when patients didn't know if their physician was a healer or an agent of death?"
Likewise, Concerned Women for America's senior policy director, Wendy Wright, complains, "Judge Jones ignored centuries of ethical guidelines that physicians should heal, not kill. This lone judge claims that doctors in Oregon can ignore federal law by killing their patients with powerful drugs. This decision must be appealed."
The Oregonian is sympathetic to these arguments, but says the judge's decision was "predictable, clear, and mostly correct." "We continue to oppose assisted suicide, so we'd dispute the judge's assertion that the question is settled," the paper editorializes today. "But we follow Jones' thinking up to a point. We don't think the corridors of the Ashcroft Justice Department are the right place to resolve the argument."
Dobson, others say it's time to leave public schools
"In the state of California and places that have moved in the direction that they've gone with the schools, if I had a child there I wouldn't put that youngster in the public schools," James Dobson said on his March 28 Focus on the Family radio broadcast with guest Pat Buchanan. "I've been very careful not to be negative to the public schools, because there are many Christian teachers that are struggling mightily to do what's right there, and I haven't wanted to put pressure on them. But given the fact that in every classroom in the state, for 13 public school years, they're being taught homosexual propaganda and these other politically correct, post-modern views, I think it's time to get our kids out. And I'm going to get hit for that." (Listen here: the comments start just shy of 16 minutes into the program).
So far, he's getting support instead. "I stand with Dr. James Dobson," Laura Schlessinger said on her April 9 show. "Take your kids out of public schools." (While Schlessinger was apparently talking about all public schools, Dobson was more limited. "There are other states where that's not happened. And there are many states where there are a lot of Christian people and Christian influences still there, particularly in the South and to some degree in the Midwest," he said. "But where that happens, we cannot sacrifice our kids on the altar of some kind of public schools ideal.")
Radio host Marlon Maddoux similarly supported Dobson on his show that day.
The Alliance for Separation of School and State, an anti-public school organization, told conservative Web site WorldNetDaily that its "Proclamation for the Separation of School and State," which was getting about five signatories a day, jumped to 100 a day after Dobson's broadcast.
- Familiar words, revised and updated | More and more churches are experimenting with new vocabulary to refer to God and gender (The New York Times)
- The high priests of Bible-bashing | Those who insist that every part of the Bible is false are just as closed-minded as those who insist the reverse. (Gregg Easterbrook, Beliefnet)
- Reflecting on body and spirit | In her new book, Honoring the Body: Meditations on a Christian Practice, Stephanie Paulsell, a Harvard Divinity School lecturer, argues that Christian Scriptures hold the key to protecting and respecting human bodies (The Boston Globe)
- Should science look for God? Search could be interesting | Can we live with a scientific answer about the real purpose of the universe? (Jane Eisner, The Philadelphia Inquirer)
- Evolution vs. creation | Creationism should be taught at home and in churches, where it can be given its proper religious context. It doesn't belong in schools (Reggie Rivers, The Denver Post)
- Stop the fighting: Use 'creation-evolution' conflict as teaching tool | We'll never get beyond the battling until we help students understand the range of views — religious and non-religious — about the claims of science (Charles Haynes, Freedom Forum)
- 'Intelligent design creationism and its critics': Supernatural selection | In the essays compiled in this anthology, intelligent-design creationists and their opponents go head-to-head. (The New York Times Book Review)
- The Father, the Son, and the Holy JumboTron | In the new Media Reformation, churches employ high-tech gizmos and hip spin to boost their diminishing flocks. (Salon.com)
- Fewer Americans in church | Some pollsters say at best, religion is losing its grip on American society; at worst, growing amounts of Americans are finding the institution irrelevant (The Washington Times)
- Bishop refuses to censor speaker | The Episcopal bishop of Virginia has told his churches that he won't censor a talk by a Bible scholar who has said Christianity began as a diverse spiritual movement later oppressed by male bishops. (The Washington Times)
- House moves to maintain housing tax break for clergy | Pre-emptive strike against potential court decision (The Washington Times)
- Also: House considers clergy tax breaks (Associated Press)
- Among the Vatican goals, guidelines for priests | U.S. cardinals who have been summoned to the Vatican to discuss sex abuse and priests will also agree on guidelines to restore a sense of trust in the church. (The New York Times)
- Uniform policy on priests' abuse proposed | D.C.'s Cardinal McCarrick urges more openness with public, authorities (The Washington Post)
- Church goes from too little to too much | Procedures in wake of abuse scandal claim a good priest (Timothy O'Leary, The Dallas Morning News)
- Church's problems not new | If we're going to indict the Roman Catholic Church for crimes, misdemeanors and coverups, let's go way back (Stephanie Salter, San Francisco Chronicle)
- A belief so deep, priest scandals can't shake it | Catholics like Maria Lopez don't lose faith. She says God does too much for her. (Los Angeles Times)
- Prosecuting the church | Many Americans are demanding that ways be found to hold religious leaders accountable. (The New York Times)
- Reluctant Mexican church begins to question its own | For first time, a bishop acknowledges pedophilia cases (The Washington Post)
Crime and violence:
- The convert | David Frost was a Christian missionary living in India. Now he's a Muslim. (The Hamilton [Ontario] Spectator)
- 14 face trial on missionary murder | The trial in the murder of an Australian missionary and his young sons was adjourned today until next month after a series of hearings had to be postponed because defence lawyers were absent, Indian court officials said (Associated Press)
- Freedom for 6,000 in Sudan | Group says it pays for, negotiates release in war-torn nation (The Boston Globe)
- Not even clergy being spared violence of Colombia's rebels | "It's raining death threats," says the Rev. GersaÍn Paz (The Miami Herald)
- Teen titles | An increasing number of book publishers are starting to put out sophisticated teen-centric religion titles, hoping to sell God to the same 23 million young people who have snapped up $120 billion worth of soft drinks and skateboards in the last year. (The Washington Times)
- Witch doctors placated | The Ivory Coast government of has settled a long-running dispute with disgruntled witch doctors who claim to have had a hand in the country's only African Nations Cup success. (BBC)
- Wanted. Fringe act to spread gospel | In an attempt to ensure a fair sprinkling of moral fibre is injected into the Edinburgh Fringe program, the Scottish Bible Society is willing to bless a playwright or company staging a production that will spread the gospel with £1000 in cash (The Scotsman)
- Timely album for Jars of Clay (The Washington Times)
- Reading in rapture | The latest publishing phenomenon to storm the US bestseller lists is religious fiction. (The Age, Melbourne, Australia)
- Off playing field, Orioles' Chris Singleton devotes his life to religion | Outfielder and his wife are associate pastors at church in Atlanta area (The Baltimore Sun)
- Religion sent to cellphones | The Philippine Roman Catholic church will launch a campaign to spread the "Good News" using cell phone text-messaging technology that is very popular in this Southeast Asian nation, especially among youths. (SAPA)
- Internet inspiration for preachers | Just when you think all pastors need is the Good Book on their desks, here comes the information superhighway to offer clergy another avenue to a meaningful message. (Ken Garfield, The Charlotte Observer)
See our past Weblog updates:
Subscribe to Christianity Today and get access to this article plus 65+ years of archives.
- Home delivery of CT magazine
- Complete access to articles on ChristianityToday.com
- Over 120 years of magazine archives plus full access to all of CT’s online archives
- Learn more