Are the openly religious barred from the bench?
At least Bill Pryor has experience with religious questions during confirmations. Of course, the Roman Catholic rite of confirmation is pretty different from the U.S. Congress's judicial confirmation hearings.
Last week, a group called the Committee for Justice published ads in Maine and Rhode Island newspapers saying, "some in the U.S. Senate are attacking Bill Pryor for having 'deeply held' Catholic beliefs to prevent him from becoming a federal judge." The ads showed a courthouse door with a sign reading "Catholics Need Not Apply."
The tone of those ads carried into the Senate Judiciary Committee yesterday as Republicans and Democrats faced off over whether Democrats were applying "religious tests" for a public office—something expressly prohibited by the U.S. Constitution.
"The left is trying to enforce an antireligious litmus test," Sen. Orrin Hatch (R-Utah) said during yesterday's panel meeting. "It appears that nominees who openly adhere to Catholic and Baptist doctrines, as a matter of personal faith, are unqualified for the federal bench in the eyes of the liberal Washington interest groups. Period. … The litmus test, whether you call it an abortion litmus test or a religious litmus test, is being applied with full force against Pryor because of his faith and the personal views consistent with it."
Sen. Jeff Sessions (R-Ala.), Pryor's main sponsor, said the nominee's views on abortion are fully consistent—in fact, mandated—by the Roman Catholic Church, and that barring judges with those views essentially bars orthodox Catholics. "Let me tell you, the doctrine that abortion is not justified for rape and incest is Catholic doctrine," Sessions said. "It's the position of the Pope, and it's the position of the Catholic Church. Are we saying that if you believe in that principle, you can't be a federal judge?"
Democrats howled in protest.
"As a person who was raised Catholic and is a practicing Catholic, I deeply resent this new line of attack from the right wing that anyone who opposes William Pryor is guilty of discrimination against him because he is a Catholic," said Sen. Richard J. Durbin (D-Ill.) "Many Catholics who oppose abortion personally do not believe the laws of the land should prohibit abortion for all others in extreme cases involving rape, incest, and the life and health of the mother."
Perhaps so, but in doing so they contradict the doctrines of their faith—which is exactly the case Pryor's supporters are making. Anyone who consistently holds to Catholic doctrine is effectively banned by Democrats from holding judicial office.
One of Pryor's problems, according to Durbin, is that Pryor doesn't consistently hold to Catholic doctrine. "The Catholic Church is opposed to the death penalty. Pryor is in favor of it," Durbin said. "I'm not going to ask Senator Sessions to make a judgment as a Methodist whether that makes him a good Catholic or not."
Durbin's non-question still demands an answer. In fact, while the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops has called for the abolition of the death penalty in all cases, the Vatican has not.
"Assuming that the guilty party's identity and responsibility have been fully determined, the traditional teaching of the church does not exclude recourse to the death penalty, if this is the only possible way of effectively defending human lives against the unjust aggressor," says the Catechism of the Catholic Church. "The cases in which the execution of the offender is an absolute necessity 'are very rare, if not practically non-existent.'" By contrast, the Catechism's opposition to abortion is comprehensive, direct, and without exception. At its simplest, Catholic doctrine does like this: You can get excommunicated for supporting abortion, but not for supporting the death penalty.
Doesn't Durbin know this? If not, what kind of Catholic lawmaker is he? If so, his statement is very disingenuous.
Sen. Patrick J. Leahy (D-Vt.), said the Committee for Justice's ads and the accusation that Democrats were imposing a religious test are "the most serious I've seen in 29 years in the United States Senate. It is despicable. It is contemptible. It goes back to a darker time."
Yet in the media coverage Weblog has seen, no Democrats are quoted answering the question at hand: Is anyone who opposes abortion based on religious belief automatically unqualified for office?
At the end of the day, the committee voted 10-9 to send Pryor's nomination to the Senate floor. But the Democrats are set on defeating it outright—or preventing a floor vote via a filibuster.
Sex abuse report released:
- Abuse scandal far deeper than disclosed, report says | Victims of clergy may exceed 1,000, Mass. Attorney General estimates (The Boston Globe)
- Report: Over 1,000 in Boston archdiocese were likely abused | Statute bars indictment of top leaders (The Washington Post)
- 789 children abused by priests since 1940, Massachusetts says | The report cited an "institutional acceptance of abuse," but the child-protection laws pertaining to that time would not allow charges to be filed (The New York Times)
- Many outraged, some cautious after Reilly's report (The Boston Globe)
- AG says leaders stood in the way | Queries church's ability to move beyond 'secrecy' (The Boston Globe)
- Law's lieutenants scorned in report | Information said to be concealed from authorities (The Boston Globe)
- Massachusetts AG hits church for sex abuse (Associated Press)
- Abuse woes continue for Catholic Church (Associated Press)
Homosexual rift in the Anglican Church:
- Anglican conservatives warn of 'realignment' | U.S. Episcopalians may confirm gay bishop (The Washington Post)
- Conservative Anglican leaders warn of a schism | Conservative Episcopal bishops in the United States and from the developing world share a sense of alienation from the Anglican dioceses that do not denounce homosexuality (The New York Times)
- American gay bishop 'would shatter Church' | In their most powerful statement yet, seven primates and a number of bishops—representing more than half the 75 million-strong Church—demanded that Canon Gene Robinson be stopped from becoming bishop of New Hampshire (The Daily Telegraph, London)
- Anglicans lobby against same-sex measures (Associated Press)
- Swedish gays run 'gay kid' ads | A campaign by a Swedish gay group to promote awareness that non-heterosexual orientation can start from an early age caused a backlash on Wednesday from a child protection group that said the sexual depiction of children could encourage pedophiles (Reuters)
- Austin minister targeted by anti-gay campaign | The lawyer and complaining witness, Paul Rolf Jensen, appear to have turned a campaign against homosexuality into a full-time job (The Austin Chronicle)
- Baylor notebook (pt 1, pt 2) | This fundamentalist controversy is phony (Rod Dreher, Dallas Morning News)
- A few clarifications | The president of the Baylor Alumni Association responds to Dreher (Dallas Morning News)
- Baylor president faces up to critics | It was a little testy at first, but Friday's face-off between Baylor University's controversial president and his critics evolved into something more polite than rancorous (The Dallas Morning News\)
- Re-Christianizing higher education is important | Re-Christianizing a significant portion of higher education may be just about the most subversive activity going on anywhere, and near the top in importance (William Murchison, The Dallas Morning News\)
- At Baylor forum, fundamentalism is prime concern | President's plan criticized by alumni at `family dialogue' (Houston Chronicle)
- Let D.C. try vouchers | I believe that education is a local issue and that if the mayor wants this program, it should be given the chance to work. (Dianne Feinstein, The Washington Post)
- Anti-school choice lacks standing | We need to worry less about where our children are being educated and more about whether they are being educated (Clint Bolick, The Washington Times)
- Teaching creationism muddies the waters of science education | When a school district teaches a pseudo-scientific theory espoused by a religious community as scientific fact, it crosses a line (Art Coulson, Pioneer Press, St. Paul, Minn.)
- Teaching religion: the final frontier? | Some colleges, like Muhlenberg, using 'Star Trek' as an aid (The Morning Call, Allentown, Pa.)
- Religion dept. FSP location frustrates | Students who have attended the Foreign Study Program said that the courses they took at New College Divinity School came up short intellectually—in large part because of the institution's theological focus (The Dartmouth Online)
Scripture at the Grand Canyon:
- Canyon plaques back, for now | Park Service chief of public affairs said that the decision came because of the deputy director's discomfort with the Park Service making such a judgment call (Arizona Daily Star, Flagstaff)
- Also: Bible plaques back at Grand Canyon (The Arizona Republic)
- A clear view of both sides of Grand Canyon dispute | Awe-struck visitors to the Grand Canyon will continue to feel the touch of God, even if there are no signs or plaques to remind them of his presence (Jim Jones, Ft. Worth Star-Telegram, Tex.)
Church and state:
- Unholy row erupts over 'war' Nativity | A life-sized Nativity scene, which its creator has compared to an image of war-torn Baghdad, is to become a centerpiece of the Capital's festive celebrations (Evening News, Edinburgh, Scotland)
- Pledge spurs family feud in High Court | A family feud has broken out in the Supreme Court between California parents who disagree about whether their daughter — and other children — should start each school day with the Pledge of Allegiance (Associated Press)
- ACLU demands removal of Ten Commandments from state plaza | Arizona officials say matter is under review; religious-rights group says monument doesn't violate church-state separation (Associated Press)
- A higher principle | Children's backpacks shouldn't be weighed down with religious outreach material, good news or not (The Baltimore Sun)
- He's no Goldfinger | Liberia's troubles are hurting Pat Robertson's gold prospects (Fortune)
- Earlier: Pat Robertson's quest for eternal life | He's making bets to ensure that his evangelical empire outlasts him. His portfolio so far: a gold mine in Liberia, a mothballed oil refinery, and $78 million in losses (Fortune, May 28, 2002)
- Republicans trying to find balance with outspoken televangelist | With evangelical Christians a key part of the Republican Party's base, Pat Robertson's strong stands raise questions of whether he is helping or hurting Republicans entering a presidential election cycle, or if he is merely a colorful fringe figure who no longer matters much politically (Knight Ridder)
- The 'prayer offensive' | One would think a man who has just survived prostate cancer, as the Reverend Robertson has, would think twice about saying a fellow cancer survivor, Justice Ginsburg, should hang up her robe (Editorial, The Berkshire Eagle, Pittsfield, Mass.)
- Also: 'Prayer offensive'? Yes, indeed | The heavens must be convulsing in laughter at religious broadcaster Pat Robertson's "Operation Supreme Court Freedom" and his "prayer offensive" entreating God to remove three justices from the highest court in the United States (Linda Campbell, Ft. Worth Star-Telegram, Tex.)
- Jesus ossuary' promoters unfazed by forgery arrest | Jewish filmmaker Simcha Jacobovici, Gabi Barkai of Bar-Ilan University stand by the authenticity of the ossuary inscription (The Jerusalem Post)
- Explorer who discovered the 'Titanic' sets out to prove that Noah's flood formed Black Sea | No one disputes that the Black Sea was once a fresh-water lake that in ancient times became inundated by the salty Mediterranean. The arguments have been over how quickly it happened (The Independent, London)
- Restoring the reputation of 'apostle to the apostles' | Of all the ways to malign a woman's dignity, Mary Magdalene got one of the worst raps (The Kansas City Star)
- A switch for rock | Switchfoot asks some big questions (Mark Joseph, National Review Online)
- New day dawns for Christian recording artist | Now in recovery from addiction, Michael English back in studio (The Tennessean)
- The gospel truth about Dylan | Host of church singers serves music of a born-again icon (International Herald-Tribune)
- New Phila. archbishop's career back on fast track | For reasons no one could explain, Pope John Paul II passed Rigali over three times when naming new cardinals (The Philadelphia Inquirer)
- Catholic mass gets fine-tuned | Planned changes to start Nov. 30 (Chicago Tribune)
- Bishops fear purge of liberals as Pell gives nod to conservatives | Catholic bishops will confront the Sydney Archbishop, George Pell, tomorrow over the appointment of two new bishops which some fear is part of a Vatican campaign to purge the Sydney archdiocese of its liberal streak (The Sydney Morning Herald)
- Pope's health in spotlight as heat wave grips Italy | The pontiff's health seems to have worsened in recent weeks and as temperatures soar in a relentless Italian heat wave so rumors fly about his frail condition (Reuters)
Suggest links and stories by sending e-mail to firstname.lastname@example.org
Check out Books & Culture's weblog, Content & Context.
See our past Weblog updates:
and more, back to November 1999
Subscribe to Christianity Today and get access to this article plus 65+ years of archives.
- Home delivery of CT magazine
- Complete access to articles on ChristianityToday.com
- Over 120 years of magazine archives plus full access to all of CT’s online archives
- Learn more