I keep thinking I saw this movie before, except that then it starred Shirley Temple. A lovely young person appears and touches the lives of people from all walks of life, bringing them a little bit of sunshine, and guilelessly showing the way to a better life. But in the other movie there wasn't a close-up of maggots crawling through a moose carcass. Not that I remember, anyway.

Into the Wild is a pretty infuriating movie, because it insists on treating the central character as an escapee from Godspell. In Jon Krakauer's slim, fascinating, and disturbing book by the same title, Christopher McCandless is an ambivalent and somewhat pitiable figure. The son of a high-achieving couple, he did well at Emory University, but dwelt on courses concerning apartheid and the African food crisis. Chris became increasingly agitated by the gap between rich and poor, and revolted at his parents' hard-earned success, as well as their hopes for his life. In a letter to his sister Carine, Chris told how their offer of a new car as a graduation present outraged him. (Chris had significant problems with his father, as Krakauer had with his own father, all of this contributing to the power of the book.)

Emile Hirsch as Chris McCandless

Emile Hirsch as Chris McCandless

The verb "to drop out" isn't heard much these days, but that's what Chris decided to do. He would disappear after graduation and travel around the country, living on as little as possible, a resistor to the conformity machine. He abandoned his car, burned his cash, and dined on nuts and berries. The impact on the African food crisis has not yet been reported.

Chris also determined to make his escape in a way that would unmistakably shut his parents out. He arranged that the letters they sent him all summer (in lieu of calling; he had no phone) would be held until August 1, then returned-to-sender in bulk. At that point the trail would be cold: Chris had taken off two months previously. His parents would never hear from him again.

When Chris' body was found in a bus near Alaska's Denali National Park, people began to come forward who recalled meeting him on his travels. A middle-aged hippie couple named Jan and Bob (in the movie, Bob's name is changed to Rainey) picked him up hitchhiking, and Jan tried to talk him into contacting his parents. In the book, Jan has fond memories of Chris (who by this time was using the name "Alexander Supertramp"). But in the movie, Jan is pulling away from Rainey and silently brooding over something; we see her walking away down a stretch of beach. Chris tells Rainey that he is afraid of water, but has to start getting used to it sometime. He runs down the beach and playfully urges Jan into the waves, where the two of them leap and play. That evening we glimpse Rainey and Jan having a heart-to-heart in their tent. It worked!

William Hurt and Marcia Gay Harden as Chris's parents

William Hurt and Marcia Gay Harden as Chris's parents

Ron Franz, an octogenarian who also gave Chris a ride, gets the same treatment. In the book, Chris lectures Ron that he too should sell all his belongings and live on the road—youthful ardor both touching and amusing. But in the movie, when Ron asks Chris, "What are you running from?" Chris shoots back, "I could ask you the same," and brings Ron to a breakthrough regarding his own retreat from life.

In the movie, Chris' only flaw is idealism. Even his parents' grief is a fruit of Chris' heroism. His sister Carine (Jena Malone) notes in voiceover that "What Chris was saying had to be said," and that, if Mom and Dad were becoming better people, it was thanks to the hard lesson he had taught. When she felt pity for them, she had to remember that Chris would not, that "these are not the parents he grew up with, but people softened by the forced reflection of their loss."

Director Sean Penn films his leading man

Director Sean Penn films his leading man

So why give the movie three (out of four) stars? Mostly, because of the stars. Despite the gripes above, this is a terrific movie. It's a gripping story, played out in visually astonishing places (brace yourself for some rough images, though). But it's the acting that deserves the most praise. Into the Wild was directed by an actor, Sean Penn, and he knows how to make the most of an actor. Catherine Keener is just right as Jan, conveying a mysterious backstory in every cheery-yet-weary glance. William Hurt, as Chris's dad, preserves a numb, stony face throughout, only to crumple it exquisitely into tears in a fleeting but powerful moment near the end. Non-actor Brian Dierker, given an opportunity to play Rainey, creates an affable, scene-stealing character.

Article continues below

All of this means that Emile Hirsch, just 22 years old, has to share the screen with many venerable performers; but he holds his own, in a role that made extraordinary physical demands (he dieted precipitously for the starvation scenes, dipping below 115 pounds). Just about every performer here deserves similar praise, and there's well-deserved Oscar talk going around. Into the Wild has great acting, great scenery, and a great story, and any viewer will be awed. It would have been just that much better if it had given us to see the real, flawed Chris McCandless, rather than a version made over into Shirley Temple.

Talk About It

Discussion starters
  1. Chris' journey was a decidedly solitary one. Yet toward the end, it seems to have dawned on him that (in a passage he underlined in Tolstoy) it was necessary "to be used to do good to people." He noted in the margin of another book, "Happiness only real when shared." If he had been able to return to civilization, how might his life have changed?
  2. There is an impulse to blame Chris for his own death (Krakauer reports getting a great deal of negative mail, particularly from Alaskans). Yet he was prepared and cautious enough to survive for a long time, and was not at fault for getting "trapped in the wild." Why do we look for someone to take the blame for a disaster? Why do we prefer to think it can be explained by stupidity?
  3. Some surprisingly positive Christian notes pop up in the movie. Ron tells Chris, "When you forgive, you love, and when you love, God's light shines on you"—at which point the clouds part and they are hit by a beam of light. Real-life desert evangelist Leonard Knight, the artist-caretaker of Salvation Mountain, tells Chris, "This is a love story [for] everyone in the whole world." Chris' last message is "I have had a happy life and thank the Lord. Goodbye and may God bless all." If you had met Chris on his wanderings, what would you have wanted to tell him?

The Family Corner

For parents to consider

Into the Wild is rated R for language and some nudity. In addition to coarse language, partial nudity, and a brief glimpse of a couple having sex, there are some stomach-turning scenes involving the butchering of a moose. Chris' tragic descent toward starvation is also realistically depicted; the actor dropped below 115 pounds for this part of the story. Take the R-rating seriously.

What other Christian critics are saying:

Into the Wild
Our Rating
3 Stars - Good
Average Rating
 
(14 user ratings)ADD YOURSHelp
Mpaa Rating
R (for language and some nudity)
Directed By
Sean Penn
Run Time
2 hours 28 minutes
Cast
Emile Hirsch, Vince Vaughn, Catherine Keener
Theatre Release
October 19, 2007 by Paramount Vantage
Browse All Movie Reviews By:
Tags: