The first public “vaccines” campaign in US history was led by a Puritan preacher.

Cotton Mather had seen smallpox kill many fellow Bostonians, including his first wife and several of his children. The disease was a scourge on Native Americans and colonists living in New England in the 17th and 18th centuries. But Mather knew disease wasn’t inevitable. He had studied the sciences at Harvard before taking over his father’s influential congregation, Boston’s North Church. He believed God revealed truth in the book of Scripture and the book of nature, and Mather published several works showing the harmony between the two.

Mather’s scientific mind drove him to investigate his slave Onesimus’s claims that “he had undergone an Operation, which had given him something of ye Small-Pox, and would forever preserve him from it.” Onesimus showed him a scar on his arm where he had deliberately inserted a small amount of smallpox pus, inducing immunity. It sounded similar to reports Mather had read in a Royal Society paper. Should a smallpox epidemic befall Boston, Mather vowed, he would urge residents to get inoculated.

That epidemic came in spring 1721, after the HMS Seahorse pulled into Boston Harbor carrying traces of the disease. By the end of 1721, nearly half of the city’s 11,000 residents were infected. Basic precautions such as quarantines failed to prevent 844 Bostonians from dying that year alone.

Acting as a public servant, Mather urged doctors and his own congregants to get inoculated. But his campaign met strong resistance. Some feared that inoculation would spread smallpox further. Others thought humans shouldn’t try to fight what was clearly the judgment of God. Still others, reflecting the entrenched racism of the time, questioned adopting a practice used by Africans. Mather’s campaign “raised an horrid Clamour” not unlike what we see today whenever vaccines are mentioned on Facebook.

To be sure, history has proven Mather wrong on a lot of things (Salem Witch Trials, anyone?). But when it comes to vaccines, at least, history has proven him right: When 242 Boston residents got inoculated, only 6 died. At the end of the 18th century, Edward Jenner invented the smallpox vaccine. Some 200 years later, the World Health Organization declared that smallpox had been eradicated from the earth.

Cotton’s father, Puritan minister and statesman Increase Mather, provided wisdom during his son’s public flogging. He called inoculation a “wonderful providence of God . . . the most successful and allowable method of preventing death,” teaching that it fulfills the sixth commandment by preserving human life.

Will Christians today follow in the Mather men’s footsteps, doing all they can to protect their communities from disease? We hope this month’s cover story will help you decide.

Follow Katelyn Beaty on Twitter @KatelynBeaty

To contribute: Give online at or send checks (US dollars only) to: Christianity Today, Attn: Donor Relations, Box CT0515, 465 Gundersen Drive, Carol Stream, IL 60188. Christianity Today International is a 501(c)(3) organization.

Have something to add about this? See something we missed? Share your feedback here.